Companies make investments in response to consumer demand.
In the case of Apple, I’m sure they have all the robots and workers they need in order to accomplish their goals (since they are sitting on billions already). A few billion more in the bank isn’t going make them go out and hire someone.
You know what makes a company invest more? More customers. Customers are the real driver of growth.
If I couple this with Warren Buffet recently advising that the Dow will go to 1 million in 100 yrs [0], I can read between the lines (as you always need to with Warren) that big money already knows it can keep its big money for a very long time. Getting value consolidated into a) a few really large companies; in b) preferably the US; c) quickly; seems to be the bet.
I also agree that jobs is the target here. Special dividends and buybacks will be the way to extract this money back to the US economy (unless your a foreign rich investor who already sees this and starts pulling money out of oil and into the US - still a win for the US?). And then we get some more case studies in whether trickle-down works or not. If it does, we've created a (more?) solid small business climate, where theoretically more innovation and growth comes in. (?) If it doesn't, well, we'll continue to see the middle class disappear.
At least that's what i think i see, but who knows on timeline and i'm not a finance guy. All I know is that this current tax plan puts about $60/month back in my pocket using my 2016 numbers, so if i invest that $60 into AAPL i'm most likely going to have more than $60*12 at the end of the year.
[0] https://www.google.com/search?q=buffet+dow+10k - and thats 1000000 in points, not dollars... (!)
Cause all three of those things create jobs.
We're also talking two buckets of money. The money coming back in to the US, and the taxes the govt collects. I think this one-time tax money in this case is already spent with these tax cuts?
I'd like to imagine Ford Motor company could have been a worker co-op, but truth is it couldn't until later in life. Henry Ford raised $28,000 to start it in 1902, nominally that's around $1M today, but it's actually far more than that. Average income was around $450 a year, so he raised about 60 times the average worker's annual salary. Without wealthy investors, there was no shot at starting Ford. Once it was churning out Model Ts by the millions the workers co-op could have succeeded, but they could never get there.
There is no reason to believe that Apple feels it needs to invest more. And, if it did, it could borrow the money from its foreign subsidiaries and spend it without paying any taxes (and charge itself whatever it wanted in interest since it's borrowing from itself).
As the past 9 years since the Great Recession have shown, companies do not make investments just because they have more money. They invest for business reasons. It is true that Apple investors will be worth more if the money is repatriated, but more jobs?? not so much.