News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by eganist on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @05:51PM (#15657901)
Can't fight them on price? Fight them on talent.

Whoever at AMD who refused to match the offer probably made a terrible decision. This is about the worst time to lose that talent right after inking a gpu die deal which, in light of this news, will only be temporary. AMD just got played.

If I were AMD, I would review Mark Papermaster's comp and incentives to ensure he doesn't leave.

(I'm long AMD)

Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by eksu on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @08:19PM (#15658881)
I don’t think this was all about money. Raja had been trying to run Radeon Technologies Group like an independent company and pushing for separation from AMD for a while. HardOCP did a good piece on this -> https://hardocp.com/article/2016/05/27/from_ati_to_amd_back_...

I think the recent Intel + AMD custom chip was probably the last thing Raja did before he got pulled RTG got the reins put back on and now he’s hoping ship to peruse what he’s wanted all along. To work with more independence.

Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by burnte on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @10:05PM (#15659484)
Taking the GPU unit independent was never going to happen. The entire point of the ATI acquisition was to create the APUs that AMD has made for years, as well as get ahold of that great gaming market profit.
Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by Terribledactyl on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @09:10PM (#15659193)
What leads you to think Intel will give him more autonomy? Or is their integrated graphics team setup differently than Radeon? I would suspect the old ATI boundaries after 11 years would still be stronger than something Intel has homegrown over the past 20.
Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by 0xbear on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @11:54PM (#15659976)
Well, he wouldn’t go there if Intel wouldn’t give him what he wanted, whatever that might be.
Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by MengerSponge on Thursday November 09, 2017 @12:24AM (#15660094)
And if it's not corporate structure, maybe it's a boat.

More power to him.

Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by WhitneyLand on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @08:49PM (#15659074)
And if you were at an auction, would you review Warren Buffett’s bid to ensure he doesn’t leave with the item you want?

I know AMD has access to some resources, but If Intel decided he was a strategic hire, the game was over before it started. It’s not just that they are richer, it’s worth spending more to them because you could argue it ties into their most important long term IP battles in related areas like massively parallel computing, ML, etc.

Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by eganist on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @09:35PM (#15659326)
Strategic hiring should fail against survivalistic retention, but I may be an idealist. I'd think in practice hiring for growth would fail against retaining to survive.
Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by DigitalJack on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @11:49PM (#15659945)
There is a point where the cost of rentention would ensure a failure to survive.

At that point you have to just cut the line.

Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by rasz on Thursday November 09, 2017 @09:53AM (#15662845)
Buffet doesnt do auctions
Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by mmgutz on Thursday November 09, 2017 @01:20AM (#15660284)
AMD GPUs haven't faired well against Nvidia for some time. AMD GPUS use 1.5X more power to keep pace. The recently released Vega GPUs are underwhelming. I don't think Nvidia is too concerned about him going to Intel. AMD needed a shakeup in that division anyway.
Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by fulafel on Thursday November 09, 2017 @01:33AM (#15660338)
Why do you think power consumption by itself is a pain point for AMD?

Gaming customers don't care because it's only consuming more when actually playing - 500 hours played in a year times 0.1 eur/usd per kwh says you only save 50 eur or usd per year per 1000 watts reduction on power consumption, so it's like 2.5 eur or usd per year for a 50W difference. Cryptocurrency miners have voted with their wallets and gone AMD. There are some 24/7 HPC GPGPU users who put weight on power consumption but it is a small market segment.

Of course lower power consumption lets you do all kinds of useful engineering decisions within the product, so lowering it would make the product faster or cheaper, but that is already accounted for in the direct cost and performance numbers of the current product.

Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by freeflight on Thursday November 09, 2017 @02:20AM (#15660520)
In the high-end gamers do care very much about power consumption and especially cooling. Even in the mid-range it's something that can sway the buying decision from AMD to Nvidia, especially when the higher power consumption doesn't come with a performance lead.

With cryptominers I'm not sure they are actually "voting" for anything, to me it rather looks like they are buying up pretty much all the decent mid to high range cards in bulk, regardless of brand, it's more about availability.

Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by Tuna-Fish on Thursday November 09, 2017 @06:38AM (#15661577)
For the mass market, heat/power matters a lot. The most successful GPU of recent years was the GeForce 750 Ti. It was notable for being a GPU that did not require an external power connector that could be plugged into basically any pre-built computer with crappy integrated graphics for a major upgrade, without having to improve cooling or the PSU. This is the segment where most of the revenue is made in GPUs, and it's where AMD is really hurting.

Right now, if you are building a new computer and get to make all your own component selections, a Vega 56 card at MSRP can be a really good deal, at that segment AMD GPUs are really competitive except at the very top -- you might pay a little more in the PSU and your power bill, but the sticker price of the GPU will make up for that. However, if, like >90% of gamers, you don't make all your own component decisions and don't have the power budget, the NVidia 1050Ti reigns supreme. The best competition AMD can muster against it in the "no external power connector" segment are some RX560 models. This is in itself a terrible marketing decision as it prevents the kind of word of mouth "just buy a 750Ti" advertising that worked really well for nVidia, on top of the fact that in the segment the AMD cards just do much less well than the nVidia ones.

Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by paulmd on Thursday November 09, 2017 @02:11PM (#15664986)
You're overstating some of this. Some 750 Tis actually do need an external power connector, and the high-end/enthusiast market actually doesn't care about power consumption as long as the performance justifies it.

If Vega were smoking a 1080 Ti then you wouldn't hear any grumbling at all. It's when you get into a situation where Vega is pulling more power than a 1080 Ti and delivering performance that's barely above a 1070 in many titles that people start to get queasy about it.

PCGH just put out their new benchmark charts and the only Vega part that can even match the 1080 on average is the 64 Liquid Cooled version, which is roughly a $650 product at the moment. You're paying 1080 Ti money for a 1080 that pulls twice as much power as a 1080, which is a pretty unappealing on the whole. The only real value argument AMD has been able to make is FreeSync, but it can't really make up for that kind of performance/value deficit.

http://www.pcgameshardware.de/Grafikkarten-Grafikkarte-97980...

Another little-discussed disadvantage is that Vega is a delicate little flower, even moreso than Fiji was. Even most board partners that normally allow you to keep your warranty while using a waterblock have decided that Vega is just too delicate to have users taking the cooler off. You put a waterblock on, you lose your warranty. Many stores are not allowing returns for them either and I suspect this is a factor (along with generally immature drivers and other problems resulting in generally low user satisfaction).

Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by slededit on Thursday November 09, 2017 @11:13PM (#15667901)
The no return policies started with the current cryptomining boom. Most stores I've seen with them apply it to both nvidia and amd.
Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by pizza234 on Thursday November 09, 2017 @03:26AM (#15660769)
High-end gamers are not representative of the audience.

In the mid-range (/general audience) it's true heat can sway the buying decision, and in fact, everything that comes along with heat (for example, space occupation) is taken into account in the price.

Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by loup-vaillant on Thursday November 09, 2017 @11:16AM (#15663592)
Crypto currency miners don't use GPU. They use ASICs, which are about 6 orders of magnitudes more efficient, energy wise.

Indeed, they're not voting for anything.

Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by jkoll on Thursday November 09, 2017 @12:21PM (#15664103)
Please tell me where to buy one of these Ethereum ASICs.
Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by loup-vaillant on Thursday November 09, 2017 @01:51PM (#15664806)
I kinda assumed Bitcoin, since that's where most (almost all?) of the computation is happening.

And if Ethereum gets any significant traction, the ASICs will come. That's pretty much inevitable. Heck, I bet ASIC would be worth the investment even for Argon2d hashes —even though that one was designed for modern stock hardware.

Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by freeflight on Friday November 10, 2017 @06:32AM (#15669231)
> And if Ethereum gets any significant traction

You mean like a $30 billion market cap? [0]

Afaik not all blockchain implementations profit from ASIC hardware, some even actively discourage ASCI use by making ASCI hardware use not efficient, like Monero [1], could be that Ethererum does something similar.

[0] https://cryptocoincharts.info/coins/info

[1] https://monero.stackexchange.com/questions/47/is-monero-amen...

Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by JetSetWilly on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:55AM (#15661152)
A 300 watt cpu is enormously bulky and makes an enormous racket. I remember when I upgraded to a maxwell-based (then pascal) GPU, it was a revelation. It no longer sounded like a hair dryer when gaming and no longer was my PC getting annoyingly toasty.

Gamers care about noise and heat very much.

Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by barrkel on Thursday November 09, 2017 @01:44AM (#15660379)
More power means more cooling which means more noise.
Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by ndesaulniers on Thursday November 09, 2017 @01:49AM (#15660406)
I'd imagine gamers being a significantly smaller market than HPC/cloud where power consumption directly correlates to Total Cost of Ownership.

> There are some 24/7 HPC GPGPU users who put weight on power consumption but it is a small market segment.

Ugh latest estimates on machine learning are something like $40B by 2024.

Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by nl on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:46AM (#15661118)
Gaming is roughly double the size of data centre and professional visualisation sales combined for NVidia. I’d imagine the difference is even larger for AMD.

See https://wccftech.com/nvidia-second-quarter-2017-fy-18-analys...

Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by ndesaulniers on Thursday November 09, 2017 @12:30PM (#15664183)
Today. See my point about 2024.
Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by joefourier on Thursday November 09, 2017 @02:22PM (#15665083)
For video games maybe, but for high-performance computing, Vega is incredible bang-for-buck especially in FP16, where a $500 Vega 64 gives you 25+ TFLOPs while a $6000 Quadro with GP100 gives you 20 TFLOPS (other NVidia cards do FP16 at 1/64th the speed of FP32, making it largely pointless).
Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by sigi45 on Thursday November 09, 2017 @07:23AM (#15661803)
In this position and pay grade, i think he wouldn't even be allowed to work for intel if amd would have said no.
Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by shmerl on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @06:45PM (#15658305)
Yeah, that's kind of weird, at the time when AMD need to invest more effort in their GPUs to get ahead to Nvidia.
Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by 0xbear on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @11:56PM (#15659990)
If they are playing this smart, there should be a bench of people, nearly as experienced, and willing to bust their ass twice as hard for half as much.
Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by marcosdumay on Thursday November 09, 2017 @12:59PM (#15664391)
Somehow, companies never play this smart. Maybe at very R&D laden companies things are different, so I wouldn't bet against AMD, but wouldn't bet on them either.
Re:Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri a... by desuvader on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @09:25PM (#15659269)
Nothing some hot OTC options can't solve (hah!) - AMD definitely got played.

I am short AMD, long NVDA. Keep an eye open on ER tomorrow.