News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by chubot on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @10:59PM (#15649829)
Another way to look at it: the absolute amount of money you save matters, especially if you're young. It's better to make a lot and save a lot. And I don't think it's too hard to save money with a $160K salary, unless you have kids.

That is, the salary to expenses ratio isn't the only thing to look at.

For example, if you save 10% of your money in SF and make $150K, that's $15K a year in savings. If you save 14% of your money in Austin and make $100K, that's $14K a year in savings.

Even though you went through 90% of your salary in SF and only 86% in Austin, living in SF is better, because you saved more money in absolute terms. You can move elsewhere and take advantage of that savings.

If you only care about money, the ideal strategy is probably to move to SF in your 20's, make a high salary, and then move out of SF. A lot of people these days don't have kids until their 30's. (Anecdotally that seems to be what a lot of people have done in the past decade -- move out of the Bay Area when they want to have kids.)

This also doesn't account for the fact that SF has more "outliers" and more choices. You might be pleasantly surprised by the kind of job you can get or the kind of money you can make in SF. In most cities (certainly not all), you probably won't be surprised. The job market is what it is.

(I'm assuming something about their methodology here, feel free to correct me if I'm wrong.)

Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by loeg on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @11:53PM (#15649984)
Your numbers are just not in the right ballpark. The pay gap between SF and Austin is not as large as your figures, and the COLA gap is far larger.

I think an Austin engineer making the average $110k can save more even in absolute terms than the SF engineer making the average $134k.

The median rent for a SF 1BR is $3370, or $40,440/yr[0]. The median rent for an Austin 1BR is $1150, or only $13,800/yr[1]. Rent alone ($26,640) has already consumed the entire difference between the $134k and $110k salary.

Next, factor in local taxes. California has income tax; on $134k of single income, that's another $9,450. Texas has none. Federal taxes will also be higher for the nominally higher SF wage.

There are other COLA factors this simple analysis doesn't even consider. But Austin comes out far ahead on rent and income tax alone.

[0]: https://sf.curbed.com/2017/6/20/15841068/rent-report-sf-2017...

[1]: https://austin.curbed.com/2016/4/28/11532748/austin-rent-cos...

[2]: https://smartasset.com/taxes/california-tax-calculator

Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by komaromy on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @12:02AM (#15650010)
If the goal is saving money in your 20s, having a 1BR is kind of absurd. You can live in a multi-bedroom apartment/house in SF for much less than that.
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by loeg on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @12:04AM (#15650017)
Having a 1BR as a young, single professional with a six figure salary isn't totally absurd, even if you're trying to save some money. And costs in Austin scale down with lifestyle, too.
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by megaman22 on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @12:15AM (#15650049)
I'd say it's absurd to be living in shared space like a college student in your mid to late twenties, especially if you're pulling down six figures.

Move somewhere else, where half that income will buy you a house with 2000 sqft and an acre or two of land...

Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by sidlls on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @12:26AM (#15650083)
And little or no job security or career mobility.
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by nilkn on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @12:47AM (#15650159)
I'd say Austin is actually a pretty good place to be a software developer. Texas has several other big cities, including Houston, which have reasonable opportunities as well.
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by lwhalen on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @12:39AM (#15650129)
Remote work is totally a thing, and IME most places pay +/- 10% of 'coastal' wages.
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by loeg on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:35PM (#15666039)
SF simply isn't the only city with tech job security or mobility.
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by liberte82 on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @10:26AM (#15653314)
Really depends on your lifestyle, don't you think? Plenty of people are happy with a 1 bedroom if it lets them live in the heart of a city they love. Different people have different priorities.
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by komaromy on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @12:15AM (#15650050)
I don't think it's an unreasonable decision to make. It's just one of the least productive things you can do if trying to save money.

I'm paying $1400/month for a 17.5'x10' room in a popular part of the city. That's almost $2k/month saved by having roommates.

Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by nilkn on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @12:57AM (#15650187)
Living conditions have a large impact on productivity and general mental wellbeing. For introverts, I think there's an argument to be made that splurging a bit on more space for yourself could lead to better performance in many areas of life. It's hard to put a dollar figure on that. For extroverts, this may be less true.

I feel like I should point out that in most of the country, including large cities, it's hard to even spend $2k/month on any apartment, let alone save that much by opting to have roommates.

Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by liberte82 on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @10:38AM (#15653469)
I'd agree that having roommates can be made news for a strong introvert, but I don't think the amount of physical space you have is necessarily all that important. It's more whether you can have time to yourself.
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by loeg on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:40PM (#15666068)
> It's just one of the least productive things you can do if trying to save money.

... in SF.

In most other cities with many tech employers, NYC excepted, living with roommates instead of in a 1BR isn't going to save you $2k/mo. Median 1BR in Austin or Seattle is less than $2k/mo. Yes, housing is still your biggest cost, but it's so much cheaper than SF, and the taxes are lower than California. The marginal savings you can get by reducing your standard of living aren't as huge as in SF.

Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by vorotato on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:45PM (#15666091)
For the same price you could live in a nicer whole apartment, in most of america. I pay $1200/month for 1664 sqft in a nice townhome, with a garage, next to a park, as a software developer with plenty of opportunities and no I'm not going to tell you where I live or else you'll all move here lol.
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by tdb7893 on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @10:33AM (#15653409)
It depends on where you live. In places with lower rents it seems more common for young professionals to live alone (most people I know live alone or only with a significant other)
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by chubot on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @01:36AM (#15650304)
Yeah it's possible that's true for those two cities at this particular time -- I haven't run the numbers. But you can apply the argument for Austin too.

If you're living in Iowa or Wyoming, Austin probably seems like it has a high cost of living. You could probably find an apartment for $300 or $400 a month in a lot of small towns. But it's probably better to move to Austin, make more, and save more, if you have a job offer.

I would say that if you are young and in tech, you should apply for jobs all over the country, including in SF. Don't worry about the cost of living. That's focusing on the downside rather than the upside.

But if you are older and have more expenses, and less variance in what your salary will be, then you might want to run the numbers, and not bother applying to some places.

FWIW I've lived in SF for 15 years and I've never paid close to $3370. I did pay $2600 once for huge place, and now I pay less than that. But even if I paid $3370 I would still save a ton of money. It's all relative.

One bedrooms are also the worst market, precisely because people are moving in and out a lot. I've known people with very nice 2 BR apartments in desirable areas splitting it at $1500 a piece. Although granted this was several years ago and the market may have changed.

I think it got insane in 2013-2014, hopefully it's a bit better now. There are also places to live outside the city that are less expensive.

-----

Also, two asymmetries to consider:

1) There's no hard upper limit on the amount you make, but there is a hard cap on how much you can save.

2) If you live in an expensive area like SF, you can move back to your hometown at any time. But the converse isn't true, because at a certain point the expenses will probably be intimidating.

Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by loeg on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:48PM (#15666113)
> If you're living in Iowa or Wyoming, Austin probably seems like it has a high cost of living. You could probably find an apartment for $300 or $400 a month in a lot of small towns. But it's probably better to move to Austin, make more, and save more, if you have a job offer.

Yeah, but again, you'd have to run the numbers at this specific point in time. And I suspect Wyoming would not come out ahead (at this point in time), unlike Austin.

> Don't worry about the cost of living. That's focusing on the downside rather than the upside.

This is total nonsense. Anything you can save while young has the biggest impact on your future fortunes and ability to retire, or retire early. Compare job offers by net income — after taxes and after housing and utility expenses.

> FWIW I've lived in SF for 15 years and I've never paid close to $3370.

That is the median rent figure for 2017, not the prior 15 years. If you managed to find a rent-controlled apartment years ago, you may pay a below-market rate.

> 1) There's no hard upper limit on the amount you make, but there is a hard cap on how much you can save.

Can you explain what you mean by either of these clauses? Income will be limited by basic supply/demand economics of your skillset and ability to impress employers. Savings are a function of income and spending. Neither of these are set in stone.

> 2) If you live in an expensive area like SF, you can move back to your hometown at any time. But the converse isn't true, because at a certain point the expenses will probably be intimidating.

The expenses of SF are intimidating from the get-go! As a young college graduate with no savings, moving to SF is even riskier than for someone older with a modest emergency fund to cover gaps between jobs.

Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by chubot on Friday November 10, 2017 @04:50AM (#15668913)
Anything you can save while young has the biggest impact on your future fortunes and ability to retire, or retire early

I think this is where we're not agreeing. My point is that focusing on the upside is more important than focusing on the downside. Making more allows you to save more.

I don't think retiring by cutting costs is a great goal, especially for someone with decades left to live.

But you may disagree and that's OK. I don't have any interest in convincing people to move to the Bay Area!

I think I'm one of the more pessimistic and conservative people in Silicon Valley, but still I believe in focusing on the upside, and I believe in a dynamic world where things that are true now won't be true in 5 years.

The decision-making process that I intuit from your posts seems like more of a static model of the world. For a young person, your skillset can and must change! You can learn things that will earn you more money!

Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by loeg on Friday November 10, 2017 @12:34PM (#15671446)
> I think this is where we're not agreeing. My point is that focusing on the upside is more important than focusing on the downside. Making more allows you to save more.

I don't think focusing on income and ignoring costs is a good approach to saving money, or life. Both are important. We can agree that focusing only on cost and ignoring income is totally foolish.

> I don't think retiring by cutting costs is a great goal, especially for someone with decades left to live.

The alternative is working longer to save up a bigger nest egg that can support a higher level of spending. That trade-off between working longer and lowering costs is fully a personal choice. To be clear, I'm not taking a stance on which of those choices other people "should" make.

> The decision-making process that I intuit from your posts seems like more of a static model of the world.

I think you're reading in something that isn't there.

Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by STRiDEX on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @12:35AM (#15650111)
None of my engineering friends are paying over 2.4k for an apartment in sf. Most have roommates. I moved in with my gf last year in a studio w/ garage for $1900 (glen park). If someone is paying 3k+, I'm not sure who it is or why. Thats insane.

However, taxes are very high here.

Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by intev on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @01:18AM (#15650251)
If you want a one bedroom apartment in SOMA or Mission you pretty much have to pay more than 3k. A lot of people are saving costs by staying in larger "mansions" and splitting the rent, but 3k+ is absolutely standard and I know many people paying that.
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by thatswrong0 on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @01:25AM (#15650273)
Right, but that’s not required.

You can live in the Mission with a roommate or a few and save a lot of money. I have a bunch of friends splitting a nice Glen Park apartment for $1500 each and its right next to BART. I personally pay $1750 a month with a few roommates and I love my situation, and I’m also close to BART.

You have absolutely no right to complain about rent unless you’ve done.. literally anything but nothing to pay less than those absurd amounts. You don’t need to live in a luxury SOMA apartment to exist in SF.

Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by jordanb on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @11:58PM (#15649999)
I've heard this argument before and it's predicated on a set of assumptions about savings rate that may not hold true.

It's easy to come up with a plausible set of numbers where the absolute savings are better in Austin even allowing for it being a greater percentage of income.

Beyond that though, I would submit two other caveats:

1. If you were to become involuntarily unemployed in San Francisco for any length of time then you will find your burn rate is still the SF burn rate and not the Austin burn rate.

2. Spending your twenties in a Gold Rush town with the intent to move to some other more rooted town later means you don't put any roots (professional or otherwise) down in that other town. You may find yourself with no connections and no relevant experience when it's time to move back to Grand Rapids.

Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by shostack on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @12:06AM (#15650022)
1. Short of an economic downturn (which would likely impact Austin as well), if you lose a job in SF, depending on your field that is not super concerning given the available jobs and steep competition. So yes you might have a higher burn rate, but presumably you have less risk in the form of more available jobs.

2. Roots are subjective and depending on your line of work may not be as important to have locally vs. distributed. That's just professionally speaking. Personally, not everyone needs that same kind of community connection.

These obviously vary based on quite a few factors, but I don't think it is really black and white.

Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by econner on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @12:10AM (#15650032)
But hopefully you struck gold. Or you just stay in SF I guess.
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by yourapostasy on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @11:46PM (#15649961)
> ...move out of the Bay Area when they want to have kids...

This is fascinating to me, because if demographers' prognostications are to be believed, then future growth economies (on the multiple-decades-scale) are heavily represented by new middle-class families, in Asia and Africa, and to a lesser extent the Middle East and South America. So not only is the Bay Area ecosystem doubling down on its geographic centrism into a non-growth geography, it is tripling down on a bet that a non-family-oriented HQ culture (where the majority of unicorn companies consider the majority of their staff "who matter" to be located) will innovate sufficiently to penetrate and hold family-oriented heavy-growth markets of the future.

Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by asveikau on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @01:09AM (#15650223)
By the way, I have first hand experience that raising kids in SF is quite good apart from some financial questions. There is a lot of community in places like playgrounds etc. More so than in some other places I have been. The average kid my kids meet is far kinder and more socially aware than what I grew up with, for example. So when people say SF is geared exclusively towards childless 20 somethings, don't believe them. Of course the financial picture continues to be challenging for many people, but many would be surprised at what a great place it can be for kids.
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by chubot on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @01:42AM (#15650320)
Are your kids in school yet? I am pro-San Francisco, and don't have kids. But my neighbors do, and told me about the school lottery.

While I understand the logic, it sounds awfully inconvenient. SF is already annoying to drive around, I can't imagine dropping off and picking up a kid to/from a random location in the city during rush hour. That seem like a good way to kill a lot of your day.

Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by asveikau on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @01:36PM (#15655451)
Yes, the lottery sucks and creates traffic problems. Even if you don't have kids, make note of days when there is no school, your work commute will be much easier on those.
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by miranda_rights on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @12:08AM (#15650029)
Is this before/after taxes? The problem is if you live in SF vs Austin, the sales taxes are similar but California's income tax will take 10-15k off the top. After that, you have to think about cost of rent. I'm currently debating between moving to SF vs Austin and would end up spending ~30k a year for rent and utilities. For a similar, or slightly nicer, place in Austin, I'd spend ~12k. The difference there, ignoring cost of living of other things, is ~30k. Beyond that, (based on my anecdotal offers in both cities), the differences in salaries between the 2 cities are smaller than 50% (closer to 30% before tax, which seems to match the data in the article, if not still larger). By that point, you have approximately the same amount of money left over in either city.

Granted, in Austin, you'd probably need a car unless you live/work downtown or near the campus so there are trade-offs but I don't think it's as simple as directly comparing percentages.

Even after all this, I'm definitely considering moving to SF since I think it'd be better for my career in the long term but I'm not fooling myself about the money I'd be making. Seattle seems to be the sweet spot for that (no income tax, good tech, cheaper housing than SF).

EDIT: sales tax -> income tax

Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by Jesus_Jones on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @12:23AM (#15650073)
Seattle has a sales tax, I think you mean no income tax is what we have in Washington state. But there's discussion of having a capital gains tax, so we can reduce the regressive sales taxes on poor folks. It's a scary time, better stay in SF :-)
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @01:49AM (#15650346)
California has a capital gains tax, I think.
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by Jesus_Jones on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @06:52PM (#15658351)
What I was trying to get across is that Washington state doesn't have income tax or capital gains, we only have sales tax and home owners taxes. California has all of those, I believe.
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by hkmurakami on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @04:55AM (#15650982)
California treats capital gains as ordinary income.
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @09:10AM (#15652518)
Even worse.
Re:San Francisco is one of the worst-paying places in the US... by hkmurakami on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @01:36PM (#15655449)
yes agreed.