I don't think focusing on income and ignoring costs is a good approach to saving money, or life. Both are important. We can agree that focusing only on cost and ignoring income is totally foolish.
> I don't think retiring by cutting costs is a great goal, especially for someone with decades left to live.
The alternative is working longer to save up a bigger nest egg that can support a higher level of spending. That trade-off between working longer and lowering costs is fully a personal choice. To be clear, I'm not taking a stance on which of those choices other people "should" make.
> The decision-making process that I intuit from your posts seems like more of a static model of the world.
I think you're reading in something that isn't there.
I think this is where we're not agreeing. My point is that focusing on the upside is more important than focusing on the downside. Making more allows you to save more.
I don't think retiring by cutting costs is a great goal, especially for someone with decades left to live.
But you may disagree and that's OK. I don't have any interest in convincing people to move to the Bay Area!
I think I'm one of the more pessimistic and conservative people in Silicon Valley, but still I believe in focusing on the upside, and I believe in a dynamic world where things that are true now won't be true in 5 years.
The decision-making process that I intuit from your posts seems like more of a static model of the world. For a young person, your skillset can and must change! You can learn things that will earn you more money!