The question is whether you really derive ~50k/yr of value in tuition that these waivers cover as a PhD student. I think I took like five classes my entire career in grad school. Hardly seems worth the ~250k that I was "granted" by the university.
False. The IRS states that the EITC only applies to those over age 25 if you do not have a qualifying child (many graduate students fail both). Also, some graduate students fail the most basic tests for EITC-eligibility since they do not have "earned income" despite having taxable income.
Another thing is that the tuition being added to AGI means every single graduate student will be ineligible for the EITC just on AGI grounds.
Anyway the plan uses it to fund corporate tax cuts so your hypotheticals don't really apply -- we have a concrete bill to discuss.
See: https://www.irs.gov/credits-deductions/individuals/earned-in...
https://www.irs.gov/credits-deductions/individuals/earned-in...
As to the plan to use the tax break to fund corporate tax cuts, it depends on economic conclusions that are beyond my understanding. I tend to be of the mind that we shouldn't tax corporations at all, and focus on taxing individuals.
Balancing it out in other members of the lower income class doesn't really help, IMO. You are penalizing people who are underprivileged for trying to improve their lot in life and move into a higher class with one of the best means possible: higher educational attainment.
It's obscene.
P.S. your point about taxation of corporations is interesting too: corporates shouldn't be considered people for purposes of taxation but can participate in political activity and speech (political donations) using rights of individuals. Nice deal, if you can get it.
No, it's utilitarianism. A tax break that disproportionately benefits the educated and well-off shouldn't be preserved just because a small minority of the people it benefits are not well off. Better to eliminate it in favor of a tax break that primarily goes to disadvantaged people.
> You are penalizing people who are underprivileged for trying to improve their lot in life and move into a higher class with one of the best means possible: higher educational attainment.
Someone who has gotten into graduate school necessarily has an undergraduate degree, and probably can make a decent living. At that point, it's better to focus government money on people who aren't so lucky.
> corporates shouldn't be considered people for purposes of taxation but can participate in political activity and speech (political donations) using rights of individuals.
The "people" thing is a red herring. "People" shouldn't lose their free speech rights just because they act in concert through a corporation. That has no bearing on whether "people" are more appropriately taxed at the corporate level or the individual one. The latter is a purely utilitarian concern. I don't think there is anything morally wrong with taxing corporations, I just think it's not worth the hassle given how easy it is for corporations to move to low-tax countries.
Still, good luck to the US remaining a scientific leader with this change.
Universities compete for research talent. Won't they simply adjust their fee and stipend structures to accommodate this change?
Universities compete with each other for research talent, but they also compete with private industry for graduating BS/BA students. If the amount of money flowing to higher education in general is reduced, it may be harder for graduate schools to compete for the best students against private industry, even though they continue to compete as best they can with each other.
I know the idea it should be is a popular perception among tax lawyers and economists, but our system of government does not put tax lawyers and economists in charge, and that's on purpose.
The reality is that tax policy exists to create specific outcomes in society--either by funding public expenditures, or by creating incentives to shape private expenditures. Politics is how we set and prioritize social outcomes. Tax policy comes out of a political process.
So as you evaluate a change in tax policy, you need to start with what you like and want in society. There's a lot to recommend graduate education, and in particular STEM graduate education (which tends to get the most tuition reimbursement). You don't detect gravity waves, find a vaccine for cervical cancer, or increase solar panel efficiencies without a lot of highly educated people. You don't attract the world's greatest minds without a prestigious, well-funded, and diverse higher education system.
Outcome-oriented thinking helps avoid unnecessary blinders about the scope of the tax system. We don't have to choose between STEM grad students and the EITC. There's a whole huge world of other tax policies out there we can think about.
It's somewhat difficult to find high-quality statistics on graduate students in the United States, but I tried to look up some information for context. The following is not an random collection:
It appears that more than a third of doctoral students in the United States are not US citizens (compared to 7% of the overall population). Perhaps a slight majority (~52--53%) of doctoral students are female. Graduate students are also slightly more likely to be non-white than the general population. The majority are under 32 (of course).
But viewed in that light, maybe they're not so defensible. While a small minority of graduate students may come from the lowest income backgrounds, on average they're highly educated and privileged. So in essence, it's a tax break for among the most advantaged people. Why is that "fair?"