News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The GOP Tax Plan Will Destroy Graduate Education by tanderson92 on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @04:57PM (#15648037)
> Repealing it to increase the earned-income tax credit would almost certainly be fair.

False. The IRS states that the EITC only applies to those over age 25 if you do not have a qualifying child (many graduate students fail both). Also, some graduate students fail the most basic tests for EITC-eligibility since they do not have "earned income" despite having taxable income.

Another thing is that the tuition being added to AGI means every single graduate student will be ineligible for the EITC just on AGI grounds.

Anyway the plan uses it to fund corporate tax cuts so your hypotheticals don't really apply -- we have a concrete bill to discuss.

See: https://www.irs.gov/credits-deductions/individuals/earned-in...

https://www.irs.gov/credits-deductions/individuals/earned-in...

Re:The GOP Tax Plan Will Destroy Graduate Education by rayiner on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @05:05PM (#15648104)
The fact that graduate students may not be eligible for the EITC is irrelevant. The point is that the people who are eligible for the EITC are statistically much more likely to be underprivileged than graduate students are (as a group).

As to the plan to use the tax break to fund corporate tax cuts, it depends on economic conclusions that are beyond my understanding. I tend to be of the mind that we shouldn't tax corporations at all, and focus on taxing individuals.

Re:The GOP Tax Plan Will Destroy Graduate Education by tanderson92 on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @05:18PM (#15648210)
Since you acknowledge the increases in the EITC are unhelpful to these underprivileged students you are then saying it is acceptable to raise taxes on the underprivileged portion of a largely privileged group because it's statistically hard to tease out the difference. That's...heartless?

Balancing it out in other members of the lower income class doesn't really help, IMO. You are penalizing people who are underprivileged for trying to improve their lot in life and move into a higher class with one of the best means possible: higher educational attainment.

It's obscene.

P.S. your point about taxation of corporations is interesting too: corporates shouldn't be considered people for purposes of taxation but can participate in political activity and speech (political donations) using rights of individuals. Nice deal, if you can get it.

Re:The GOP Tax Plan Will Destroy Graduate Education by rayiner on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @05:35PM (#15648334)
> Since you acknowledge the increases in the EITC are unhelpful to these underprivileged students you are then saying it is acceptable to raise taxes on the underprivileged portion of a largely privileged group because it's statistically hard to tease out the difference. That's...heartless?

No, it's utilitarianism. A tax break that disproportionately benefits the educated and well-off shouldn't be preserved just because a small minority of the people it benefits are not well off. Better to eliminate it in favor of a tax break that primarily goes to disadvantaged people.

> You are penalizing people who are underprivileged for trying to improve their lot in life and move into a higher class with one of the best means possible: higher educational attainment.

Someone who has gotten into graduate school necessarily has an undergraduate degree, and probably can make a decent living. At that point, it's better to focus government money on people who aren't so lucky.

> corporates shouldn't be considered people for purposes of taxation but can participate in political activity and speech (political donations) using rights of individuals.

The "people" thing is a red herring. "People" shouldn't lose their free speech rights just because they act in concert through a corporation. That has no bearing on whether "people" are more appropriately taxed at the corporate level or the individual one. The latter is a purely utilitarian concern. I don't think there is anything morally wrong with taxing corporations, I just think it's not worth the hassle given how easy it is for corporations to move to low-tax countries.

Re:The GOP Tax Plan Will Destroy Graduate Education by tanderson92 on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @05:43PM (#15648396)
Okay, I think I understand your position now and I agree it's self-consistent, even though I disagree.

Still, good luck to the US remaining a scientific leader with this change.

Re:The GOP Tax Plan Will Destroy Graduate Education by tptacek on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @06:26PM (#15648692)
Is your logic here that major research universities would maintain the same fee structure and allow less qualified wealthy students to assume the spots lost by students who can't afford the tax change?

Universities compete for research talent. Won't they simply adjust their fee and stipend structures to accommodate this change?

Re:The GOP Tax Plan Will Destroy Graduate Education by tanderson92 on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @06:57PM (#15648904)
I assume stasis in the rest of the ecosystem, yes. It's hard to predict exactly what the repercussions would be. Yes, it's unrealistic. What else can we do? Also, the GOP wouldn't have repealed this exemption in the bill if it didn't mean increased tax revenue, so the money has to come from somewhere. In the end it's a reduction in funding for higher education.

Universities compete with each other for research talent, but they also compete with private industry for graduating BS/BA students. If the amount of money flowing to higher education in general is reduced, it may be harder for graduate schools to compete for the best students against private industry, even though they continue to compete as best they can with each other.