As you say, though, an end-to-end retelling of LoTR doesn't make much sense.
They left out the "Scouring of the Shire" which was one of the key chapters of the book that illustrated the main point of the entire story.
I'm still bitter.
I'll see your bitter, and raise you a curmudgeoning.
I feel like this story would be a good mini-series or standalone movie.
Mine too! I also understand why it was cut, but it really ruined the movies for me.
I love the books, but even I will admit they're are fairly dry with large, long-winded descriptions. Peter Jackson did a brilliant job with the movies, and I'm really not sure what could be done better or even differently (outside of a fan-fiction TV series).
But that's not a problem for a TV series, which is why GoT --- despite being categorically worse source material! --- is in the aggregate stronger than the LoTR films, even if you leave out the execrable Hobbit movies.
Sounds quite faithful to me. The books are plodding, most of the characters are fairly simple, and there's entire chapters that describe rolling hills and lush forests...to say nothing of the songs.
I don't know - I've never thought to myself "I've had enough Tolkien stories represented in film". I'd love to see another representation.
I don't know - that was pretty much my reaction to the Hobbit movies - which were pretty dreadful. I didn't even bother seeing the 3rd one.
Tolkien did, however, create a very detailed and very rich world. There's plenty of backdrop there on which to write new stories whether or not they hew to anything specific that's already been written in that universe. On the other hand, there are plenty of rich worlds that authors have built over time. And most of them don't carry the baggage and weight of expectations that anything associated with Tolkien inevitably would.
ADDED: As noted elsewhere, the rights to other Tolkien works would have to be obtained.
What I meant is I'm not tired of the Tolkien universe and would welcome more. That's not to say I enjoyed the hobbit series whatsoever. For instance, I'd love to see another director try their hand at a Hobbit series on television. At least then I could pretend the Jackson-led Hobbit series didn't exist.
I watched season 1 a lot closer than 2 or 3, but it doesn't seem like they are doing a much world building as they tell each tale.
I don't want to spoil anything but there are multiple characters that exist in both, though obviously younger since season 2 takes place some thirty years before season 1. Some of it is subtle but very interesting once you realize it. I don't want to hint at it more so as not to spoil it.
In effect each season stands alone, you're correct that there's not much world building.
But many important things were cut from the books to make time. Tom Bombadil comes to mind. The many sorties and battles in the Two Towers were truncated.
And most importantly, as another commenter mentioned, the freeing of the Shire, which is integral to the entire premise of a hero's journey - that the hero must return to his homeland and share the hard won gifts with his community - was cut.
There's plenty in the books to warrant a series. Game of Thrones does ~9 hours per book and still had to cut characters and plot points. <2 hours per novel is pretty much always a huge compromise.
The books in ASOIAF are longer thsn those in LotR, there's more books, and ASOIAF books have a higher density of action vs. description. Yes, there were some elements cut from LotR in the Peter Jackson movies, so maybe you've got two short seasons of material.
I suppose this is still risky if they mess it up big time, but they've already got a built in audience of tens (hundreds?) of millions. The story has been proven (obviously), so if they do it in a slightly different way while adhering to the books perhaps it's a slam dunk, according to their research.
The crucial thing about this is that it is a pitch by the Tolkien estate rather than to them. Christopher Tolkien hated the Peter Jackson movies [...snip...]
I was an avid reader of Tolkien as a teenager and the movies were a disappointment to me as well. Too much spectacle and derring-do, whilst I always enjoyed the construction of the world and the inner lives & secrets of the characters. The omissions made were sometimes grotesque: the removal of Tom Bombadil alone made the mockery of the books. Skipping the entire homecoming chapter of the hero's journey ("the scouring of the shire") is a common complaint and a travesty of storytelling.
However, Christopher Tolkien is the ultimate Tolkien purist, after a lifetime of curating his father's work. In the few interviews he gives he's clearly dismayed by any deviation from the original intent. I suspect he'd likely be unhappy with any TV adaptation as well.
Like many other Tolkien fans I'd much rather see an adaptation of The Silmarillion, which if anything is the more epic book of tales.
Anyone who goes to a theater looking for a completely faithful and literal adaptation of a beloved book is almost certainly going to be disappointed.
Would you help me understand why the scene was so important for you?
Honestly this seems like a late-to-the-party attempted at catch up.
https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/411971-i-cordially-dislike-...
https://www.goodreads.com/work/quotes/2964059-letters-of-j-r...
I would have continued the series if I thought his writing were any good, in spite of the clearly repressed sexuality he was indulging himself in.
What value would they even really add?
At least with the Game of Thrones, it was the first time it was adapted to television.
In the case of LoTR, there's already been a big budget production that won a ton of Oscars.
This seems very strange to me. Usually these studios want to try new ideas and less conservative. This smacks of a typical Hollywood studio problem, just regurgitating existing franchises into new mediums.