News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by PascLeRasc on Monday November 06, 2017 @05:18PM (#15639502)
I'm graduating with my BS in EE next month and I've been applying to lots of places working on battery technology since it's incredibly interesting to me, but I have no idea how anyone becomes a "specialist" in that field. Everything I've learned has been outside of class, and there aren't any offered in my department or in Materials Science or Chemistry, and a few of my friends at top-tier schools like CMU and Purdue have said the same thing. It seems so critical for everything from energy grids during natural disasters to environmentally friendly material sourcing/disposal. I hope schools start focusing on it.
Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by DigitalJack on Monday November 06, 2017 @05:23PM (#15639529)
I’m an EE doing asic design. Everything I do for a living I learned outside of school. Aside from the basics like reading/maths etc.
Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by throwaway613834 on Monday November 06, 2017 @05:42PM (#15639652)
Huh, this is hard to swallow. What digital EE courses did you take in school?
Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by DigitalJack on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:10PM (#15639808)
Fair point, I had one class called logic design. It was my favorite, although I hated breadboarding 7400 logic.

The class was mainly Boolean algebra with some flip flops thrown in at some point. If I recall correctly that was my sophomore year.

There was next to no digital in my courses. Heavy on math and analog circuits. I think that one class on digital logic was it.

Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by saym on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @02:11AM (#15641550)
Take me back to K-maps and XOR gates. At the time I remember struggling with them, but now I look back on the experience fondly.
Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by throwaway613834 on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:40PM (#15639957)
> Fair point, I had one class called logic design. The class was mainly Boolean algebra with some flip flops thrown in at some point.

Yeah that explains it. :-) So nothing about writing Verilog, feedback pipelining, adder design, clock skew, and stuff like that? Because those are the kinds of things I'd expect in a digital logic course (if one were available) and I would be shocked if you didn't need to know those concepts for a job in ASIC design.

Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by DigitalJack on Monday November 06, 2017 @07:02PM (#15640085)
Nope. Well, I’m sure we learned simple adders, again...Boolean algebra.

Everything else I learned on the job. If I had gone into board design, I’m sure a lot more would have been relevant.

Many places the chip designer is also the board designer, but sadly that is not the case here.

Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by psykotic on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @04:22AM (#15641979)
CE/EE departments sometimes offer an undergraduate VLSI intro course where you learn the theory from a textbook like Weste and Harris and get to design and tape-out your own chip via the Cadence or Synopsys tools and then fab it through an MPW service like MOSIS or CMP. So, it's certainly possible to learn some hands-on chip design fundamentals in school, but if your department doesn't offer it, you're pretty much out of luck. You could do your own extracurricular MPW run of a small design for maybe a thousand dollars, but you'll be stuck with SCMOS cell libraries and free tools like Magic or Electric, which aren't representative of industry.
Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by PascLeRasc on Monday November 06, 2017 @07:17PM (#15640137)
We've got all that in an Advanced Digital Design course, but you have to be pretty far down a class path to take it so most students don't.
Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by throwaway613834 on Monday November 06, 2017 @08:05PM (#15640344)
> We've got all that in an Advanced Digital Design course, but you have to be pretty far down a class path to take it

How far down? I wouldn't expect it to be popular but I also wouldn't expect it to have a long prereq chain (a sophomore-level course on computer architecture seems enough?)... it doesn't seem like analog which is where you actually need a long prereq chain to get anywhere.

> so most students don't

Most students... in EE? Or most students planning to do digital design after graduation?

Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by DigitalJack on Monday November 06, 2017 @07:35PM (#15640218)
Honestly I’m jealous of what is taught these days.

But until the stuff I was being taught became practical (because it paid for dinner), I wasn’t really able to retain much once I had finished a class. So I don’t think it would have mattered time much if I had learned about clock skew in college. I’d have forgotten about its importance the next semester anyway.

Information without relevance is hard to maintain.

Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by PascLeRasc on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:30PM (#15639917)
Digital logic was also one of my favorite classes. Really fun to think about some of the problems.
Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by ktta on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:07PM (#15639779)
I've had the same thing said to me by my professor about FPGAs. You can't really find much about current EE practices because companies just don't give them away or blog like the software guys do.

Textbooks tend to be very general (also old) and don't focus on the tooling used which is the bulk of the work you have to do.

Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by egwor on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:25PM (#15639889)
Tooling changes (very) regularly. Learning concepts and techniques is far better for the long term since many of those techniques/concepts can be applied to new situations.
Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by throwaway613834 on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:41PM (#15639964)
Also skeptical of this one. Tooling seems kind of beside the point? It's like arguing that your school taught you Python and that didn't prepare you for Java (or whatever).
Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by DigitalJack on Monday November 06, 2017 @07:09PM (#15640109)
Tooling is most definitely not beside the point. And if your focus is backend, that is what you spend most of your time on.
Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by throwaway613834 on Monday November 06, 2017 @08:24PM (#15640412)
> Tooling is most definitely not beside the point. And if your focus is backend, that is what you spend most of your time on.

The question isn't what you spend your time on though. It's what is worth spending time teaching/learning in school. You also spend all your time using a mouse and keyboard but (hopefully) you don't take courses to learn how to use the mouse and the keyboard in school. If most people could pick it up in a short period of time on the job then it doesn't seem a worthwhile use of time to teach in a course.

Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by ktta on Monday November 06, 2017 @07:07PM (#15640098)
Bulk of the work is done in simulation and verification with FPGAs.
Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by DigitalJack on Monday November 06, 2017 @07:12PM (#15640118)
This is true, but those tools doesn’t change that often at a given company. VCS and questa probably cover 99% of the fpga market.
Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by ktta on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @12:11AM (#15641206)
That's exactly my point. You don't get access to those tools in school unless you are in an excellent graduate program AFAIK if that.

The simulation I can do in Vivado is apparently nothing compared to the scale those tools take it to. I've talked to someone in the industry that they told me Vivado's simulation is only okay for beginner projects.

Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by akgerber on Monday November 06, 2017 @05:49PM (#15639682)
My sister's path was getting an unrelated Ph.D. in chemistry, getting a postdoc at Lawrence Berkeley Lab in battery chemistry, and then getting a job at a startup in the field that's commercializing and extending its founder's university research. That company appears to hire chemists, ChemEs, and MechEs/industrial engineers right now.
Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by erikb on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @07:15AM (#15642731)
Honestly most of the job is learned at the job. Then additionally comes reading papers, blogs and HN to extend the area of theoretical knowledge. Don't underestimate the power of pure crunching on experiment after experiment for 60h/week for 2-3 years though. If you want to become better, find a job in a company serious about battery development and then work your ass off.
Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by amelius on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @05:09AM (#15642145)
Are you sure it is interesting from a career perspective? It seems that battery tech is a pretty mature field since it hasn't gone anywhere in the last decades despite huge commercial interests. Of course, things might change and probably they will somewhere in the future, but my guess is that patents will make it a winner-takes-all situation.
Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by PeachPlum on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:05PM (#15639758)
You will find jobs at different levels, from Intern to Researcher

https://www.linkedin.com/jobs/search/?keywords=battery&locat...

Once you know who does the work, target them as a goal.

Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by dsfyu404ed on Monday November 06, 2017 @05:20PM (#15639513)
>I hope schools start focusing on it.

Be careful what you wish for.

Right now you stand to make a lot of money. If schools start cranking out undergrads who know what you know you won't be very valuable.

edit: looks like I struck a nerve.

Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by PascLeRasc on Monday November 06, 2017 @05:39PM (#15639636)
1) I know nothing and 2) that's not the worst thing in the world if we have genius engineers making batteries better.
Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by swagasaurus-rex on Monday November 06, 2017 @05:45PM (#15639666)
This advice isn't useful because you don't know the market conditions of the future. It's like saying in 1992 "Don't become a programmer, we just had an economic bust, it's overvalued"
Re:Tesla's head of battery engineering exits by dsfyu404ed on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:17PM (#15639850)
It's not advice nor does it depend on the market conditions in the future. Boom or bust it's better to have a skill set that is in higher demand than supply.