With Bitcoin, it's as if you had thousands of tiny checking accounts, every time you received money created a new one, and you could withdraw each account only once, and always for the full value (if you wanted to use only part of an account, you had to send the rest to a new account).
Compared to checking accounts; I can't just generate a thousand checking accounts that don't belong to any identity and generate a transaction history that appears to show many transactions occurred between hundreds of parties.
It's still not as good as mixing with other Bitcoin of alternate origin (if I only have the tainted coins at the beginning, I will still have 1000 accounts with only all of the same tainted coins when I am done, and a careful analysis will show that these 1000 addresses were funded entirely by the original tainted coins). But each seller cannot be expected to perform this careful analysis, and as you are able to exchange known tainted coins for clean coins and mix them, you can increase the uncertainty that a legitimate transaction is taking place that is separate from the one that originally generated your ownership of the tainted coins.