But I found that they simply didn't update their guides nearly often enough to be useful.
Wirecutter's modern twist on CR's formula -- maintaining a frequently updated leaderboard in popular product categories, plus information on deals -- just winds up being more useful to me.
It also seems like Wirecutter has more relevant experts writing their articles. Maybe that's because they're actually better experts; maybe it just seems that way because WC articles begin with the author/authors stating their credentials and experience.
I don't necessarily fault CR but I with the hundreds of models released all slightly similar but different (I hear partly to prevent price-matching across stores) it must be as impossible to review for CR as it is for consumers to keep track of.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13909365
Typical cartel-like, profit-boosting activity of oligopolies which appliance market seems to be with a handful of companies owning most brands.
It can be a bit behind on the far changing stuff like electronics, and it can be pricey.
But I've never found them lacking in quality and detail.
I've also used your strategy of reading the bad reviews on Amazon!