News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is poverty self-perpetuating? by yummyfajitas on Sunday April 06, 2008 @03:08PM (#156324)
I know a little bit. The relationship isn't very close.

Gamblers tend to derive utility from gambling, i.e. the act of gambling gives them a rush. The extreme case of this is video games. I'll never win any money by purchasing a Wii (like the lottery, I lose with probability close/equal to 1). But I will derive more happiness from playing Wii sports than I will from the money I spent on it. Similarly, gamblers enjoy playing the game, and this gives gambling positive utility (for them).

However, the argument Karelis seems to be making is that the marginal utility of increased income is zero (for some income range which constitutes poverty). People don't tend to do actions with zero marginal utility, so they don't try to increase their income. Basically, earning $15k/year doesn't make you any happier than $10k/year, so why bother to increase your income?

(Note: he actually claims that "economics doesn't apply to the poor", which is either stupidity or hyperbole. )

One interesting policy implication of his model (if it is true, which I doubt): taxing the poor is good policy. If a poor person is no happier at 15k/year than at 10k/year, then we should tax all poor people making $15k/year at 33%. It won't make them any more unhappy, whereas taxing a richer person will. It also suggests that any wealth transfers to the poor that dont solve all their problems are wasted (welfare is "all or nothing").

Re:Is poverty self-perpetuating? by DmitriLebedev on Sunday April 06, 2008 @03:41PM (#156355)
I'm wondering what kind of utility function is needed to make such a strange MU function...

As far as dents on the car are concerned, let me write what conventional microeconomy says. Here is the function to estimate the choices.

U = sum(F(x(t))/(1+r)^t) by t from 1 to infinity (or life expectation), where F(x) is a momentary utility function, r is "perceptual" discounting rate (sorry, don't know the English term), which means that F(x) next year is 1+r times less nice than having it now.

If you don't repair the car, x(t) will be constant, let's say X. If you do, first period it is x(0) = Y < X, but since t=1 x(t) = Z > X.

The problem is that F(Y) has more weight than F(Z)'s. The more r is, the greater the difference and more probable the first choice will win. The problem of poor people is that (1) their r is much more than that of middle class, and they don't value the future, (2) their F(x) (perception of what is good) is different.

Re:Is poverty self-perpetuating? by yummyfajitas on Sunday April 06, 2008 @04:10PM (#156383)
I think the authors ideas are less about time discounting, and more about non-linear relations in quantity of problems.

The authors example is a man who's car has many dents. Utility might behave like U(0 dents) = 1, U(1 dent) = 1/2, U(n >= 2 dents)=0. If a car has 5 dents, the marginal utility of repairing one dent is 0 (U(5)=U(4)), so the owner does nothing.

Of course, in real life, most utility functions behave in the opposite way. Going from homeless to a studio apt? Major gains in utility. Going from a studio to 1 bdrm? Nice, but not as fantastic.

Re:Is poverty self-perpetuating? by mattmaroon on Sunday April 06, 2008 @11:03PM (#156626)
The diminishing marginal utility of money would imply that the difference between $10k and $15k is quite large. Much larger than the difference, say, between $100k and $150k.
Re:Is poverty self-perpetuating? by yummyfajitas on Monday April 07, 2008 @07:32AM (#156798)
You are quite right, utility is usually steep near 0, and flattens out toward the top.

I was simply pointing out that if the author is right, the difference between 10k and 15k would be very small (indeed, quite possibly smaller than that between 100k and 150k).

In fact, I'd suggest that diminishing returns explains American "poverty" much better than flat utility curves. 45% of the poor own their own home, 95% are not overcrowded, 75% own a car (30% own 2 cars), nearly all have a TV (25% a big screen). Virtually no one is starving, over 70% of those the USDA classifies as "hungry" are obese. The typical poor family is also supported by 16 hours/week of work. It's quite possible that poverty is explained simply by a low marginal gain from increased work (the poor already hit the point of diminishing returns).

All numbers are taken from here (http://www.heritage.org/Research/Welfare/bg1713.cfm), who in turn stole them from the census. See also this chart http://www.heritage.org/Research/Family/images/Chart1.gif of working hours for poor families.

Re:Is poverty self-perpetuating? by mattmaroon on Monday April 07, 2008 @04:44PM (#157179)
I've actually gone from $10k to $15k once (technically $12 to $17) and it was humongous.