And in case you think this is just opinion/spin itself, check this out:
https://www.texastribune.org/2017/11/01/russian-facebook-pag...
There are foreign powers coughRUSSIAcough actively trying to disrupt/damage/destroy our democratic institutions. Considering the ongoing investigations by Mueller we still do not know if POTUS is a puppet, through threat of blackmail or evidence of dirty laundry, to Russian agents.
This a real thing. This is important.
Over 40 CIA working as 'journalists' and on the JFK assassination story in 1973. How many are CIA reporters today?
https://www.archives.gov/files/research/jfk/releases/docid-3...
e.g.
https://theintercept.com/2014/09/04/former-l-times-reporter-...
If you've read the Podesta emails you'll know how close the MSM and DNC are.
I don't doubt the RNC has the same type of relationships.
The word "hypornormalization" was created by a soviet thinker to describe the soviet world in the 1980s:
Nobody really believed in Communism anymore and everyone could tell everything is getting worse. The party leaders, factory managers, and government bureaucrats were all thieves who were telling ever more preposterous lies to the people about the state of the economy and the society. Nobody believed the lies, but they also couldn't perceive any alternative arrangement of affairs so they didn't know how to do anything except proceed as if they did believe the lies.
He then traces the rise of perception management, the rise of the banks and neoliberalism, and machinations in the middle east, along with the career of Donald Trump, and threads them all together as Curtis tends to do, to make the case that we are currently in a period of hypernormalization in the west.
What's interesting is that he makes the case that Trump is the perfect man for this time and place, being a phony made-for-TV businessman whose entire career is the triumph of perception over reality, and the movie was made in 2016: Trump wasn't even president yet.
As with all Curtis' stuff I only believe maybe 90% of it. The stuff on the middle east is the weakest. He's guilty of doing the same thing he accuses our political class of doing: oversimplifying things to the extent that he risks fictionalizing them. But it's an extremely interesting look at the current state of the western world.
Oh yeah and Russia features heavily in it, not just in the cautionary tale of the USSR, but at the same time Curtis is emphatic in emphasizing that the post-truth world wasn't conjured up in some Kremlin propaganda office. We've been working on building a post-truth world for ourselves for the past several decades.
Wow, that pretty much describes exactly what happened in this[1] article in which coastal "third way" centrist consultants to the Democratic party interview midwesterners to figure out why they voted for Trump instead of Clinton and completely omit almost everything they are told in their final report which they carefully craft to reaffirm their preconceived worldview.
[1]: https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2017/10/on-safa...
Most importantly, aiding and abetting covert influence should be a punishable crime. Current tech environment, where tech gaints simply saying they hadn't noticed is not an acceptable answer.
When you are a tech gaint, with power to influence so many people at once, you have the responsibility to be transparent.
With great power comes great responsibility. Not faux remorse after the fact.
https://www.thedailybeast.com/jenna-abrams-russias-clown-tro...
https://www.texastribune.org/2017/11/03/russian-facebook-pag...
When I personally talk about Russia, I just point out that this happened. This being the rise of fake news, etc.
We should remember it was the United States and her allies that normalized this behavior. We should take a few lessons from this, when we do something unethical or questionable these tactics are going to be normalized and other countries are going to use them.
Another example is Trump ordering an attack on a sovereign nation without that nation asking or any resolution passing in US Congress or the UNSC.
We need to understand that this is the age we live in, and that we need to work around fixing these issues. Not blaming others or trying to reverse technological processes.
Russia didn't win the election for Trump, but you are kidding yourself if you believe it didn't play a factor. US democracy has a lot of work to do, but Putin is an ex-KGB strongman who assassinates his opponents and annexes neighbors. It's pretty obvious how he operates.
Then we have the DNC very literally and provably rigging the primaries in favor of Clinton.
You know what? I hate Trump. But give me a break. This Russia trash is just all a distraction. Trump blatantly supports unconstitutional programs like domestic surveillance and gitmo--this should be enough to impeach him alone for supporting an undermining of the US constitution and American's rights.
The fact that they need to rely on this Russia story which requires a number of shifting standards and "just trust us's", rather than in-the-open undemocratic authoritarianism here in the US, is probably a testament to failures of the human mind's ability to think in terms of, and stand up for, liberty.
I have been to Germany and Japan and the people are unbeleivably friendly and wonderful. What on earth is wrong with people that they can be coaxed into the evil dreams of tyrants--conflicts, authoritarianism--and is it happening again? Are we so different or special that we really think tyranny cant happen to us when we are going through the same patterns of history?
Probably, if we could just adjust the human factor of 'susceptability to sell their liberties and fall in line behind authority figures for short-sighted self-interest,' we would live in a much better world.
1 - https://theintercept.com/2017/09/28/yet-another-major-russia...
See, statements like this are a part of the problem. Obama did these things too and noone cared. Given that why should anyone believe anything anyone says? And into that vacuum, a new kind of influence emerges, one that is not about policies but just about "my team winning".
Probably if we could just adjust human susceptability to sell their liberties and fall in line behind authority figures we would live in a much better world.
That only happens if you are realistic about what's going on instead of holding ideological political views. That's your solution.
There are lots of good reasons to oppose and impech Trump. Something is wrong if you can ignore the authoritarianism, corruption, and unconstitutionality that exists here in the US--that both parties support, which is why they won't use them as reasons to impeach Trump--and you have been coaxed into a need to make a reach for a dubious conflict-stirring story of half-truths and shifting standards.
You should ask yourself who the parties are that win after every election, no matter Republican or Democrat, and what they stand to gain or lose. Why you, instead, follow the machinations and war cry of authoritarians that have lost all credibility is probably a testament to the human bias to follow authority figures.
You cited a source which debunked the Russian hacking claims, but there's been a lot of evidence of Russian media influence (which is an obviously exploitable weakness).
This didn't have anything to do with Trump. You're reading a lot into what I'm saying.
Sometimes macroeconomists model concepts in the framework of households. Here is an analogy to help express where I am coming from: let's say every month your homeowners association has an election. For as long as anyone can ever remember, George and Barry win every time. Over the years they have installed security cameras inside your house, created conflicts with neighboring towns which profit their businesses and kill some of our children, and they have not done a very good job of taking care of the neighborhood.
Along comes Don. There are lots of good reasons to hate Don, but George and Barry start a campaign to get him out which involves Ted, an adversary from an entirely different, trashy neighborhood, who passed fliers around with fake information in hopes that Barry wouldnt be elected again.
I'm sitting in HOA meeting wondering why no one has brought up the security cameras inside my house, the fact that my best friend died due to George and Barry, JP & Morgan--who don't even live here--are getting a lot of our money for some reason, Barry's team is rigging the election process, and our neighborhood's health and environment is deteriorating. This was just a small start to a long list of terrible problems.
But George and Barry are running the meeting and Ted is the focus.
such responses are often vacuous, if not intellectually dishonest. it's can seem like an effort to divert or sidetrack an argument or conversation with blatantly fallacious responses.
No you don't get it. I am not American, but if I was, I would prefer Democrats, at least program-wise. And yet, I share the OP's opinion.
Here's the thing - before social media (which are much more open to public than traditional ones), the general intellectual idea was that more openness in democracy, despite its apparent weaknesses, actually makes the whole thing strong. So for example, military budgets were much more open in the U.S. than in the USSR; this openness could be considered a flaw from the strictly military POV, however, it actually makes everything more efficient because it doesn't let people in power cover more corruption. And so on, you could find many other examples.
However, recently (in the past 20 years), the liberals (in the U.S., you don't have mainstream left, so please don't call them that) have rejected the idea that openness makes the society stronger. And the outcry about social media is just a manifestation of that belief.
Now, the action depends on this belief. If you believe that openness is bad for society, you will favor the censorship of social media, and, taken to the logical conclusion, a very controlled society like Russia or China.
However, if you don't believe that openness is bad, then the proper reaction to existence of social media is to have more openness from the side of the government (and also perhaps industry). In other words, maybe people (on social media) are anxious for information (and so they fill the void with speculation), but the government is still keeping too much for themselves, much more than the social media would allow to be shared. But it will take some time to catch up, because of course existing bureaucrats are used to have their ways.
Just an example. If the U.S. government agencies truly believes that Russian manipulated the election, why don't they just share all the evidence openly, as soon as possible? Why don't they call specific sock-puppets out as being known to be Russian hackers? The reason why not is because institutionally, they are still living in the old paradigm, where secret service operations couldn't be in much public light, because historically, there was no good platform to disseminate this information (citizens couldn't easily use or cross-check it but it was valuable for the foreign actors). Of course, there might be more cynical reasons why is it that way.. but hopefully you get the point.
FWIW I would have voted Democrat both times.
But blaming new media for the losses is a huge, disingenuous cop out.
Looking next time, at how tough a third term is to get might work better. Making sure that the candidate has few ties to the previous, or both previous administrations from the same party might help more.
Tyler Cowen has a good article about it on Bloomberg:
https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-11-01/facebook-...
And she just flat out cheated, in a way that was so easily discerned (even before this week's statements from Donna Brazille) that it almost definitely cost her tons of votes. As an individual she is by far the most responsible for Trump, especially considering that her campaign even sought to prop up Trump early in the race! And worst of all, she opted out of a landslide win by picking Tim Kaine instead of Sanders as VP.
I have no particular problem with investigating connections between Trump and Russia, but even if the worst of the allegations are true they 1) are about on par with Clinton's behavior in the election and 2) would barely make my top 20 list of appalling revelations regarding American politics. Americans need to step back and get some perspective -- as if the US doesn't do exactly the same or worse in almost every other country on earth.
clinton was also under fbi investigation, had wikileaks slow-dripping internal documents, and had a divided party (which clintonites didn't seem all that concerned about at the time).
> But apparently a few hackers around the place were vastly better than them.
Yes, yes, this is entirely possible. Do you know how? People working during the campaign still do things very much by hand in ways they don't scale. They walk around canvasing etc. A hacker spins up 20 new AWS instances and have a semi-direct access to your brain.
Now that HRC lost the fault now lies allegedly with social media and evil foreigners.
It's like people blaming comic books, TV, rock music and video games for what they see as the failings of youth.
Acknowledging that the Democrats chose poor candidates in Gore and Clinton and that winning three Presidential terms in a row is hard is apparently harder than blaming people for voting the 'wrong' way on some new media development.
Clinton spent 1.2Bn and had loads of young people working on media. They probably weren't just telling truths about Trump. But apparently a few hackers around the place were vastly better than them.