News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by amelius on Saturday November 04, 2017 @07:35PM (#15627400)
“Can you delete your profile completely?”

I want the ability to continuously erase everything I do on Facebook, except for the last N days, where N is a fixed number chosen by me.

Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by JoshMnem on Saturday November 04, 2017 @11:28PM (#15628060)
Why post anything on that site at all? I recommend deleting all of your content and then deleting the account.

For some people, it may require a period of restructuring your life around other services before completing the process though. Here is one recipe for getting away:

First, get a browser extension that blocks the newsfeed. This will help reduce some of the psychological manipulations.

Delete all of their apps from your phone and other devices, including Facebook, Facebook Messenger, WhatsApp, Instagram, and Onavo.

Turn off all notifications from Facebook. If they don't stop sending notifications, start marking the emails as spam.

Download all of your FB data.

Start joining other, distributed communities to start replacing your online social life with something better: meetup groups, forums, IRC/Gitter/Slack/etc.

Whenever someone sends you a message on Facebook, immediately move the conversation to email or text message and tell them to use email or SMS to contact you, since you are moving all conversations off of Facebook in preparation for leaving the site.

Start deleting all posts, comments, and photos on the site. It can take a while, even with a script.

Don't post anything new on Facebook. Start a blog (using something like Metalsmith, Hugo, Hexo + Github Pages or Netlify) if you have an urge to post things online.

By that point, the pull of Facebook will have faded, and it should be pretty easy to leave the site and not look back.

Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by muxator on Sunday November 05, 2017 @03:26AM (#15628677)
Doesn't it sound scaringly similar to an advice on how to free yourself from drug or alcohol dependency?

How to prevent to get there in the first place? If of any help, I can testify that life post-facebook is as colorful as one would expect.

Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by camillomiller on Sunday November 05, 2017 @02:55AM (#15628606)
Oh I’d love ti do that, but it would harm both my social and professional life in ways I can’t really afford. I do feel captive, with only myself to blame.
Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by JoshMnem on Sunday November 05, 2017 @03:42AM (#15628714)
> Oh I’d love ti do that, but it would harm both my social and professional life in ways I can’t really afford.

That's what I thought until I did it. It's a big illusion in most cases. Start the process now, and you should be able to reach a point where it won't be as difficult, even if it takes a couple of years.

I suspect that many (most?) people who believe that leaving Facebook will hurt their professional lives actually hurt their professional lives more by spending so many hours on Facebook.

The average person apparently spends 50 minutes per day on Facebook. That is over 300 hours per year. Many people spend much more than 50 minutes per day on Facebook. 2.5 hours per day, 7 days per week, is almost equivalent to a part-time job. There are much more effective ways to improve social and professional life with 50+ minutes per day to work on them.

I recommend keeping track of time spent on Facebook (including reading links visited via Facebook). Compare what you learned there vs. what you would learn from spending the same amount of time reading books, taking an online course, working, or meeting people in-person instead. Or multiply that number of hours by your hourly rate...

Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by camillomiller on Sunday November 05, 2017 @01:01PM (#15630634)
>I suspect that many (most?) people who believe that leaving Facebook will hurt their professional lives actually hurt their professional lives more by spending so many hours on Facebook.

Boy, does that ring true...

Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by nradov on Sunday November 05, 2017 @06:09PM (#15632335)
You can delete old posts whenever you like. There's a tool to automate that, although I haven't tried it.

https://github.com/chander/social-network-cleaner

Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by darklajid on Monday November 06, 2017 @12:59AM (#15633686)
I don't think that's what the GP was talking about. This tool "deletes posts" using Selenium and the UI.

Which most certainly doesn't delete anything, just marks it as "deleted" in the huge FB stores.

Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by gozur88 on Sunday November 05, 2017 @01:15AM (#15628259)
I want to keep other people from posting my picture.
Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by jacquesm on Sunday November 05, 2017 @04:16AM (#15628772)
Simple rule: want to remain friends/in touch/family with me? No pictures posted on FB.
Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by majewsky on Sunday November 05, 2017 @08:02AM (#15629196)
How do you enforce that without a Facebook account?
Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by jacquesm on Sunday November 05, 2017 @06:08PM (#15632329)
Look for people aiming a lens in my direction.
Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by gozur88 on Sunday November 05, 2017 @11:54AM (#15630230)
I don't want it badly enough to cut off my friends and family.

But it bothers me. Even if you don't have an account a determined researcher can learn entirely too much about you if the people around you use the service.

Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by jacquesm on Sunday November 05, 2017 @04:15AM (#15628770)
Which means a whole pile of other entities will have scraped your data in that window.
Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by amelius on Sunday November 05, 2017 @08:31AM (#15629291)
I don't think that's very likely, since they would do that right now given the value of personal data.
Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by TaylorAlexander on Saturday November 04, 2017 @09:13PM (#15627676)
I wonder why we use these services if we aren’t satisfied with how they work.
Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by PhasmaFelis on Saturday November 04, 2017 @11:21PM (#15628041)
Facebook does one thing that no other service can duplicate: it has all of my friends on it.
Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by KGIII on Sunday November 05, 2017 @12:49AM (#15628200)
I have mine in my email address book. It works like it has for a number of decades, more or less.
Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by PhasmaFelis on Sunday November 05, 2017 @01:17AM (#15628262)
Facebook has a very different use case than email.
Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by KGIII on Sunday November 05, 2017 @11:33AM (#15630116)
Sending messages to friends and family?
Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by PhasmaFelis on Sunday November 05, 2017 @06:16PM (#15632371)
Keeping up with how your friend group is doing, and having an ongoing group conversation about it, without needing to maintain mailing lists and Reply All and spam people with the implied urgency of email.

Social media exists for a reason. It's not just email for stupid people.

Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by JoshMnem on Saturday November 04, 2017 @11:31PM (#15628065)
Arguably, that's one of the problems with Facebook. Not all of one's contacts should be in the same conversations together.
Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by throwawaysml on Sunday November 05, 2017 @12:48AM (#15628197)
Didn't Google try to solve that with circles. I never used Facebook or any other "social network", so I'm probably unaware of some details, but I read about circles when Google+ came out and it sounded like a solution for exactly this problem.
Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by JoshMnem on Sunday November 05, 2017 @01:11AM (#15628247)
I think they got the idea of circles from Diaspora.

The WWW works best when used as intended: decentralized communities that encourage people to be creators rather than consumers.

Instead of Facebook, participate in independent online communities around your interests (for example, forums).

Instead of chat apps that attempt to envelop everyone you've ever met into monolithic walled gardens, use SMS and email.

Instead of Medium, learn how to create your own independent blog with something like Metalsmith, Hugo, or Hexo.

Etc.

Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by closeparen on Sunday November 05, 2017 @02:58AM (#15628616)
>Instead of Facebook, participate in independent online communities around your interests (for example, forums).

Replacing your actual social network with anonymous internet strangers leaves you in a much worse position on the axes on which people usually criticize Facebook. Facebook may be a poor substitute for meatspace interaction with your actual community, but your connecting with your actual community is surely more important than connecting with internet strangers.

>Instead of chat apps that attempt to envelop everyone you've ever met into monolithic walled gardens, use SMS and email.

SMS is a spectacularly low-quality monolithic walled garden. Email is federated in theory but in practice is almost always Google. Both systems have the uniquely privacy-hostile property of being in cleartext by default and in the overwhelming majority of real-world usage.

Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by JoshMnem on Sunday November 05, 2017 @03:48AM (#15628729)
I was an adult before most people were on the Internet. People don't need sites like Facebook to connect with their communities.

Strangers are only strangers until you start communicating with them. Most people I know these days were first met through the Internet.

I suspect that most people use webmail (HTTPS), and many people don't use Gmail. I can switch my number to another carrier and people can still reach me at the same number, so it isn't exactly a walled garden. I think it's a stretch to argue that Facebook is better than email from a privacy standpoint.

Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by dTal on Sunday November 05, 2017 @11:30AM (#15630098)
>SMS is a spectacularly low-quality monolithic walled garden

How do you figure? I can communicate with SMS to anyone in the world, on any mobile provider. Seems pretty federated to me.

Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by closeparen on Sunday November 05, 2017 @03:14PM (#15631323)
Ever tried to get an SS7 connection?

Sure, you can rent access from Twilio, in the same way that you can rent access from Facebook. It’s extremely unlikely that you could ever become a full participant in either network.

Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by dTal on Monday November 06, 2017 @06:30PM (#15639919)
Okay, so there's a high barrier to entry. It's pretty hard to become an ISP too. That doesn't make either a walled garden.

It's not so much about whether I personally could federate with the network, as it is about whether some reasonably large number of other entities could. I don't have exact numbers, but it seems there are 1000+ phone providers worldwide.

Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by JoshMnem on Sunday November 05, 2017 @04:49PM (#15631848)
SMS isn't perfect, but it isn't really comparable to Facebook's chains.
Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by throwawaysml on Sunday November 05, 2017 @01:26AM (#15628282)
It's ironic since there are more content creators now if we count all the users of the silos.

My theory is that it's all about convenience and network effects. So if a fully decentralized IPFS based/alike social network would come out with mobile apps and was marketed as the way to communicate, it could have success. The big fault such projects make is to stress the technical merits and forget to play the psych-advertising game.

I've seen non-technical people have the most number of messenger apps on their phones, and some even advocated the security of their favorite messenger. Technical folks seem to be harder to persuade to join a messenger network to communicate with a new person in their life.

So I want to say once we will have a couple more high profile data breaches and centralized SPOF downtimes, people will care about security and availability, though history doesn't support they would.

Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by JoshMnem on Sunday November 05, 2017 @01:31AM (#15628398)
Creating isn't just about "content". Posting vapid updates and linking to articles that other people wrote isn't really creating anything. For most people, posting on social media is consumption, not creation. The Internet is on its way to becoming TV 2.0.

There are at least two ways to perceive the world: as an "architect" or as a "consumer". The Internet/WWW should teach people how to be architects, but it's failing in many ways.

Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by TheSpiceIsLife on Sunday November 05, 2017 @07:50AM (#15629163)
I've never understood this.

We can't all do the same thing. We can all be sandwich makers.

The internet is teaching people to do all sorts of things other than be architects.

Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by JoshMnem on Sunday November 05, 2017 @04:54PM (#15631883)
I think that not everyone can be a large-scale architect, but those numbers can be increased.

People can be taught to at least think like architects in order to make better choices in life and understand when and how they are being manipulated by malevolent architects.

Also, one doesn't need to build million-user products to architect small changes in local communities.

An analogy: not everyone can be a good philosopher, but they should at least read philosophical ideas and be aware of them as they make decisions in life. Collective intelligence/wisdom can increased, even if most individuals are not professional philosophers.

Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by crush-n-spread on Saturday November 04, 2017 @09:32PM (#15627726)
network effects, and convenience.
Re:Can Germany Fix Facebook? by TheSpiceIsLife on Sunday November 05, 2017 @07:45AM (#15629151)
Nothing's perfect.

I'm not really satisfied with how anything works in my life, but many things are good enough or I've learned to accept the trade-offs.