Not to mention that since the collapse of the Soviets, the F15 is perfectly competitive with anything it's likely to meet in the air in the foreseeable future.
That goes for all the other major Western fighters too. The ONLY reason we're buying Eurofighter Typhoons is contractual obligation. Tornadoes (more-or-less a British equivalent to the Tomcat) are still perfectly good. If there were worries about the airframes we should have simply spun the production lines back up and made more of the proven design.
Throwing expensive toys away if they work is bit silly, that's why phasing operational stuff out takes so long. Especially if you account for the need to retrain all your people, not just the pilots, but service crew as well.