News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Clojure 1.2 RC1 by sigzero on Friday July 30, 2010 @01:10PM (#1561795)
I have a question on Clojure in general. Is it Lisp people that are flocking to it or is it trending amongst other developers as well?
Re:Clojure 1.2 RC1 by phren0logy on Friday July 30, 2010 @01:41PM (#1561907)
I was previously using Python for most of my work, but I have been moving more and more to Clojure. It has been discussed before, but some of the functional flavor of Python left me looking for more. I briefly looked at CL, Scheme, and Haskell, and each had clear upsides but none really got me excited.

When I found Clojure, I felt it was more readable, had access to many interesting libraries, and had performance that was as good or better than Python in many cases. The ease of concurrency/parallelism is also very slick, and I suspect it will come in handy to me down the road in our multi-core future. The rise of Incanter, an R-like statistical package, pretty much sealed the deal.

The biggest headache has been the need to work with Java's build systems (not because they suck but because I have no interest in learning them beyond what's required for Clojure).

Re:Clojure 1.2 RC1 by grinnbearit on Saturday July 31, 2010 @10:29AM (#1563753)
Re:Clojure 1.2 RC1 by mark_l_watson on Friday July 30, 2010 @01:23PM (#1561843)
I think it is both old-time Lisp'ers and JVM platform programmers looking for something more agile than Java.

I have been using Clojure for my work for several months and for me some of the big wins are:

1. easy to use existing Java libraries

2. lots of nice language features like destructuring, etc.

3. nice integration with Java and/or Scala projects with IntelliJ

4. fairly good runtime performance

And, a few hassles:

1. error stack traces have relatively little value.

2. The Clojure team is doing great work, but I still feel that the platform is not quite there yet compared with Java, Common Lisp, Haskell, etc.

I am in a patient mood in regards to Clojure: I use it for some things now, and expect my percentage use of Clojure over other languages will steadily increase over the next few years.

Re:Clojure 1.2 RC1 by icey on Friday July 30, 2010 @01:42PM (#1561912)
I use Clojure for a few odds and ends on a fairly regular basis now, but not having a Java background was a definite hurdle for me when I was starting to learn it. It was sometimes tough to tell if the problems I was having were Clojure related or Java related. The entire CLASSPATH paradigm was an issue for me until I realized what was going on.
Re:Clojure 1.2 RC1 by sigzero on Friday July 30, 2010 @02:05PM (#1562005)
Reading that "state of clojure" link below they know about the stack traces:

"Poor / incomprehensible error messages and stack traces are far and away the most common complaint."

Re:Clojure 1.2 RC1 by prototype56 on Friday July 30, 2010 @04:28PM (#1562499)
Do you mind telling what are the few things that you used clojure for ?
Re:Clojure 1.2 RC1 by mark_l_watson on Saturday July 31, 2010 @09:38AM (#1563699)
For my current work task, I am using it for information extraction from Freebase which requires a lot of JSON manipulation. I was using Ruby but Clojure use is preferred at CompassLabs (both languages are well suited for Freebase data hacking).

I mostly use Java for Hadoop machine learning work, but I may transition to Clojure in the next few weeks (my CTO has suggested this).

Earlier this year, I added Clojure examples to my last book on the Semantic Web.

Re:Clojure 1.2 RC1 by pavelludiq on Friday July 30, 2010 @01:35PM (#1561884)
The state of clojure survey has some data:

http://muckandbrass.com/web/display/~cemerick/2010/06/07/Res...

So mostly java, ruby and python people, and relatively few lispers.

Re:Clojure 1.2 RC1 by dpritchett on Friday July 30, 2010 @03:45PM (#1562334)
I compared those numbers to the TIOBE popularity of other languages and found that Ada and Scala developers are 7x more likely than their C# brethren to be interested in Clojure:

http://www.sharingatwork.com/2010/07/likelihood-a-user-of-on...

Re:Clojure 1.2 RC1 by TwoSheds on Friday July 30, 2010 @01:39PM (#1561900)
There was a survey about this (among other things): State of Clojure:

http://muckandbrass.com/web/display/~cemerick/2010/06/07/Res...

Quite a few Ruby and Python people trying Clojure out (much more than Lispers).

Re:Clojure 1.2 RC1 by nickik on Friday July 30, 2010 @09:50PM (#1563062)
You are misled. There where not that many lispers in the first place so where should the come from? 5% come from Common Lisp guess how many Common lispers switched to scala. I don't know either but I don't belief that its more that 5%.