Re:The Sticky, Untold Story of Cinnabon
by khedoros1 on Friday November 03, 2017 @02:50AM
(#15617134)
Either you can say that consuming addictive substances isn't a choice, or you can tax people for their choices. I don't see how you could have both.
The idea of choice as free will untethered to outside influences is clearly nonsense. However, people do respond to external stimuli when making decisions. Translation: the machine that is my brain considers things like cost when following the laws of physics and chemistry down a deterministic path.
In other words, taxes can influence behavior, regardless of the role of "choice".
Should we legislate against exercise too, which can cause death when done to extremes? We should also outlaw extreme dieting, due to similar health effects. We also might want to enforce a bit of overeating since somewhat overweight people live longer.
Re:The Sticky, Untold Story of Cinnabon
by toomuchtodo on Thursday November 02, 2017 @10:26PM
(#15616258)
I didn't say legislate; my workplace health insurance plan charges me less if they detect I'm using the gym plan they pay for and my blood tests show I'm not smoking. I have the option of paying more per month if I don't want to participate in these wellness activities.
Internalize the economic externalities. You can lead an unhealthy life if you want, but you should pay for it.
Re:The Sticky, Untold Story of Cinnabon
by noarchy on Thursday November 02, 2017 @11:06PM
(#15616407)
>I didn't say legislate;
Are you sure? You also said:
>While I’d advocate outlawing tobacco, I think products based on sugar should carry a hefty tax to fund healthcare costs and dissuade their consumption.
Were you talking about costs related to private insurance, or government-imposed taxes?
Re:The Sticky, Untold Story of Cinnabon
by toomuchtodo on Thursday November 02, 2017 @11:11PM
(#15616420)
> Were you talking about costs related to private insurance, or government-imposed taxes?
To be clear, I'm for both, as I believe that government should provide a single payer system and activities that make you unhealthy and have an excessive cost to treat should be taxed to fund those treatments.
Fair enough, I just wanted it to be clear that you are for some kind of legislation (or other government involvement) in this matter.
Re:The Sticky, Untold Story of Cinnabon
by solotronics on Friday November 03, 2017 @01:14AM
(#15616853)
the difference being 99 people die from being too fat for every one that dies from exercising too much
If numbers are a concern, we should outlaw having sex with multiple partners, as that spreads enormous amounts of disease and leads to many unwanted pregnancies and abortions.
Please don’t say “you made the choice” when talking about substance abuse, regardless of the substance. While I’d advocate outlawing tobacco, I think products based on sugar should carry a hefty tax to fund healthcare costs and dissuade their consumption.
https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/brainwaves/is-sugar-rea...