Re:USS McCain collision ultimately caused by UI confusion
by theyregreat on Thursday November 02, 2017 @06:31PM
(#15614911)
That is super dumb and dangerous. They should just flip the inputs on one end.
EDIT (since some people obviously don’t understand the problem): ... so that each set of controls is always correct for the respective side on which it is located. No switch is necessary.
Re:USS McCain collision ultimately caused by UI confusion
by scott_karana on Friday November 03, 2017 @11:59AM
(#15620141)
Even better, make the stations operable from either side. Then the yokes always orient in reality, and it's just the frame of reference of the pilot that changes.
Eg, if you're facing the dock, and push forward, you'll hit the dock. Take the other side and point your body to sea. Intuitive.
Re:USS McCain collision ultimately caused by UI confusion
by nicwolff on Thursday November 02, 2017 @06:48PM
(#15615047)
No, they just have a big button by each wheel marked "MAKE THIS THE BOW".
Re:USS McCain collision ultimately caused by UI confusion
by LeifCarrotson on Friday November 03, 2017 @09:28AM
(#15619009)
When would you ever not press that button?
Re:USS McCain collision ultimately caused by UI confusion
by theyregreat on Thursday November 02, 2017 @07:02PM
(#15615165)
You’re bikeshedding on a switch versus a button, still an extra, unnecessary step to forget. Same problem. You failed. Try again.
I know of a ferry that a local warf built that had two bridges, and a combined throttle and rudder in each.
The thing is that when moving from one bridge to the other, the crew had to flip a switch to indicate what direction was forward. And quite often they forgot.
End result was a long history of damaged because ferry would ram the pier when the crew was actually attempting to move away from it.