Re:The Exercise Pill
by yathern on Thursday November 02, 2017 @03:26PM
(#15613449)
Congrats on the gains! Though of course you are just an anecdote. But I'm curious how much of this muscle mass loss is due to biological changes vs lifestyle changes.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Exercise Pill
by chrisseaton on Thursday November 02, 2017 @03:27PM
(#15613459)
Well it does say 'all of us', so a single anecdote does disprove it. I think the original commentator was pointing out the sloppy writing.
Yeah. The article's sentence also fails to account for people dying, who lose much more than 8% of muscle mass, and really stupid robots reading the article, who lose none of their muscle mass, but will have trouble understanding that, sometimes, language is ambiguous and requires a modicum of contextual reasoning, or else every sentence would require dozens of qualifications and would read like a regulation on insurance law.
Re:The Exercise Pill
by jaggederest on Thursday November 02, 2017 @04:17PM
(#15613869)
"There may exist at least one person who may have lost muscle mass over time."
I think my exercise and physiology textbook stated an age related decline in muscle mass happens in everyone after about 40 without a concerted program of strength training to stave it off.
Re:The Exercise Pill
by imoldfella on Thursday November 02, 2017 @05:25PM
(#15614424)
That certainly sounds more credible. I encourage all the HN'ers north of 40 to try weightlifting. We have members older than myself seeing good results.