News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by drx on Thursday July 29, 2010 @11:18PM (#1560160)
Minute trading introduces very high levels of liquidity to the market.

Your thinking represents a common fallacy: "I cannot immediately see any benefit to X, therefore X is pointless / should be abolished".

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by _delirium on Thursday July 29, 2010 @11:27PM (#1560175)
However it also adds high levels of volatility and self-organizing behavior (i.e. trends that feed on other trends, not on underlying signals). One might add another fallacy: "The market does X, therefore X is good".
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by drx on Thursday July 29, 2010 @11:33PM (#1560183)
I didn't say it was good, I said that discarding something merely because you see a drawback and no benefits is foolish.

You are right about the feedback loops though.

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by parallax7d on Friday July 30, 2010 @10:27AM (#1561191)
I would posit that discarding something because you see drawbacks and no benefits is logical.

Prescribing what someone you've never met knows or doesn't know would be, if not foolish, presumptuous.

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by neilk on Friday July 30, 2010 @12:13AM (#1560258)
I'm not an expert, but how does HFT increase liquidity?

One definition of liquidity is when you can sell something without affecting the price much. Most people on Wall Street will tell you their job somehow increases liquidity -- connecting buyers and sellers in more and more efficient ways.

HFT seems different. It is comparable to front-running other people's orders. Someone tries to buy an item for $1.00, and the HFT algorithm tries to grab the item first and resell it to our original buyer (and other people in the market) for just a tiny bit more.

From my perspective it's effectively a sort of tax, like a bridge toll. It seems to me like this has to make every transaction affect the price more, not less. How does this increase efficiency or liquidity?

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by noname123 on Friday July 30, 2010 @12:37AM (#1560286)
You right. But I'll give you the counter-argument.

In the stock market, just like the real estate/auto market, there are never just true buyers and sellers; there are also brokers and dealers who keep a inventory of goods, so that they can sell to non-discriminating retail customers who just want the goods right now. Their expertise and self-interests in turns, affects the price of the good in the whole entire market.

The stock market once have had traditional broker-dealers that controlled the spread of a stock. That is, dealers are willing to buy stocks from impatient traders who are willing to sell at a market order at a price that is set by the dealer; the dealers then in turn, later sell their inventory at an artificially inflated price to impatient traders who are willing buy the stock at a market at the price named by the dealer.

Traditional dealers, in order to tack on the risk of carrying their inventory of stocks (after all, a stock could theoretically drop to zero before they could sell the whole lot), keep the spread of the stock big (they are willing to buy low and sell high) at the expense of retail investors.

HFT, due to their high-tech platform and high execution speed tightens this spread because they don't carry as high a risk of inventory; because their execution speed is in timescale of micro-seconds; so essentially, in the timeframe of seconds, they buy a position and then sell that position subsequently and not really carry that position through for the market to affect the value of that position.

This in theory is good for retail investors as they actually end up paying less for their stocks. But with good technology, you could also use it for bad. With fast computers and sophisticated algorithms, HFT traders could learn how to game the traders and big funds that they are suppose to server - just like a regular car or real estate dealer.

If you know where the consumer demand is, you could buy up all of the supply ahead of time and artificially inflate the price to make people pay more. If you know that your competitors are replicating your every move, you could deceive them by making a small trade against your true intention, have them jump on the bandwagon and swiftly punish them by executing your true big trade afterwords. The possibilities are endless.

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by yummyfajitas on Friday July 30, 2010 @01:28AM (#1560341)
Someone tries to buy an item for $1.00, and the HFT algorithm tries to grab the item first and resell it to our original buyer (and other people in the market) for just a tiny bit more.

No. The matching engine will match first the highest priced order, and in the case of orders at the same price, whichever order was placed first. You can't jump ahead in the queue, no matter how fast your algorithm is [1].

[1] This statement only applies to US equities/futures/derivatives markets. I think it might be possible in Canadian markets under some limited circumstances.

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by anonymousDan on Friday July 30, 2010 @08:20AM (#1560855)
Can I ask you how this is physically laid out? Is there just a big centralized computer at the exchange with two input queues, one for buys and one for sells? What if I want to place an order at the best price across multiple different exchanges?
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by yummyfajitas on Friday July 30, 2010 @08:38AM (#1560887)
It's basically what you think; a computer system keeps a queue of buy and sell orders, sorted by price/time (i.e., best price wins, if prices is equal, earliest order wins). It then matches trades by popping the top of the queue. If you place an order on INET which can be filled at a better price on ARCA, then INET routes your order to ARCA and you are charged a small routing fee. This is required by RegNMS.

(There is a "don't route me" flag if you don't want to be routed. In that case, your order will simply go unfilled - exchanges can't match you at a price worse than the best price available on all exchanges.)

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by anonymousDan on Friday July 30, 2010 @05:02PM (#1562603)
But how are prices synchronized between exchanges (if at all)? i.e. say the best chance for my order being filled is at ARCA, but I submit it at INET. Does the fact that it will most likely get routed to ARCA via INET imply there is a greater chance of the order not filling than if the order had been submitted to ARCA directly?
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by artsrc on Friday July 30, 2010 @03:08PM (#1562228)
Current price $100. Firm puts in order to buy at any price up to $110. The HFC algorithm puts small volume sells to work out that they are doing that, then sell to them at $109.99. They then turn around and fill their position at any lower prices. If the HFC was not there the limit order would be filled more slowly at lower prices.
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by jaekwon on Friday August 06, 2010 @08:13AM (#1580811)
at no point is the stock any more "liquid" from the perspective of the firm.
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by cturner on Friday July 30, 2010 @02:52AM (#1560458)

    HFT seems different. It is comparable to front-running other people's orders
I think you're confusing HFT (which is a broad term) with flash trading.
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by yummyfajitas on Friday July 30, 2010 @08:32AM (#1560879)
Mechanics of flash trading: say the best ask price on INET is 100, the best ask price on ARCA is 99. If you place an order buy at 99 on INET, INET is legally obligated to route your order to ARCA (since ARCA has the NBBO). You will pay 99/share + commission + routing fee, with the fees paid to ARCA.

If INET were to flash your order, they give some HFT firm the opportunity to sell you shares at 99. The HFT firm can accept or reject - if they accept, you pay 99/share + commission and INET gets the commission.

That's a completely different game than front running. It has other issues, like being potentially unfair to ARCA and traders who can't afford flash orders, but it isn't front running.

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by abstractbill on Thursday July 29, 2010 @11:26PM (#1560172)
Is more liquidity always better? (It's an honest question - I have no idea myself).
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by silverlake on Thursday July 29, 2010 @11:49PM (#1560212)
Liquidity means you can easily find a buyer or seller. In what circumstance would this not be a good thing? You get minimal markups (bid/ask spread), you can get in and out of trades quickly, and you can easily determine the market value of your securities. Housing is totally illiquid: there's a big broker fee, it takes a while to sell your house, and you can only guess at its true value by comparing to recent sales of similar houses. There's some weird cases in global markets where liquidity allegedly causes problems.
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by Retric on Friday July 30, 2010 @10:27AM (#1561192)
Edit: The more trades made independent of stocks fundamentals the lower the signal to noise ratio.

Both negative AND positive feedback loops independent of underlying value are bad.

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by drx on Thursday July 29, 2010 @11:36PM (#1560191)
Good question. I would imagine not, especially from the point of view of someone who can exploit an illiquidity.
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by sambe on Friday July 30, 2010 @05:27AM (#1560631)
Good answer. Arguably, in a simplistic sense more liquidity is always better for the functioning of the market. But if we have a lot of "false" liquidity that perhaps encourages people to make optimistic assumptions, and that liquidity can go away... like it did a few weeks ago (or during a crisis...). Maybe some people can profit from this, especially if they have the ability to front-run?
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by mailanay on Thursday July 29, 2010 @11:33PM (#1560185)
Imagine liquidity as tank full of fuel in your car. The possibilities of going with a full tank are endless. More fuel than tank's holding capacity is pretty much useless.
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by yummyfajitas on Friday July 30, 2010 @01:33AM (#1560354)
No, imagine liquidity as a keg of beer. If you drink some, it tastes great. If you drink some more, you feel dizzy, and eventually you wake up with a really ugly girl in your bed.

When using analogies, some explanation is helpful.

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by artsrc on Friday July 30, 2010 @03:37PM (#1562313)
If there are 10 people who want move to street x, having 14 sellers all selling identical apartments, at identical prices is no different than having 50 people selling identical apartments at identical prices or 200.

The difference with HFC is they don't provide any actual liquidity that matters. They don't hold the apartments across different move in dates.

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by anamax on Friday July 30, 2010 @12:06AM (#1560243)
> More fuel than tank's holding capacity is pretty much useless.

And what, exactly, is the "tank's holding capacity" for liquidity?

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by gloob on Friday July 30, 2010 @11:11AM (#1561341)
Whatever number happens to mesh with the poster's predetermined position on the matter. If they think that HFT isn't "real work"[0], they'll set the level low. If they're a free-market fetishist, they'll say the tank is indefinitely large.

Metaphors are rarely a useful approach to understanding something.

[0] An amusing position for a programmer to take, considering we make completely intangible stuff while spending hours a day sitting on our asses, but one that a lot of people on this site seem to hold.

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by artsrc on Friday July 30, 2010 @08:31PM (#1562981)
The volume real market participants want to buy or sell.
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by anamax on Monday August 02, 2010 @02:33PM (#1568538)
> The volume real market participants want to buy or sell.

What is the definition of "real market participant"?

For example, are day-traders real market participants? If not, why not?

How about me? (I rebalance every few months, maybe.)

Note that day traders and I have exactly the same goal - make money. How many people trade for other reasons?

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by artsrc on Monday August 09, 2010 @12:42AM (#1587027)
If you can think of a better term than "real participant" please let me know.

If your job is to record or settle trades, be a day trader with no overnight position, track share holdings, etc. then you are a part of the machinery of this capital market, but you are not one of the participants who provides, or consumes capital. You are part of the cost structure.

The real participants are those who actions reflect beyond the casino itself, and out into the economy beyond.

The purpose of share markets is to provide capital. Long term capital for companies to invest, and in return to provide long term profits for those providing that capital.

If you are providing or consuming capital, even for one day, you are to some extent a real participant.

I think it is fine for people to make money, brokers to charge a fee for a trade, day trading, advising on diversification, etc.. But we should understand that these are costs associated with this system of providing capital/investing.

You sound like you provide capital and participate as an investor.

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by Maro on Friday July 30, 2010 @03:34AM (#1560504)
You can't possibly argue that doing billions of trades a minute has anything to do with real-life liquidity. By real-life, I mean liquidity that's relevant to a bank's customer, eg. a private citizen who possibly even owns a trading account. And that's the only kind of liquidity I care about. It's just a game to extract money from the economy without doing real work.
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by artsrc on Friday July 30, 2010 @03:53PM (#1562367)
It is real work, it just provides no real net value.
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by nradov on Friday July 30, 2010 @01:34AM (#1560355)
Everyone understands that high liquidity is beneficial: it lowers the cost of capital thus allowing businesses to expand. But have researchers ever quantified the liquidity premium reduction provided by HFT versus the economic rents extracted by the traders? Depending on the ratio, society might actually be better off with a little less liquidity.
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by thailandstartup on Friday July 30, 2010 @05:06AM (#1560612)
I think that we do overpay for this liquidity. Both in terms of economic rents extracted, and the wasted resources poured into the competition. I wonder if there might be a way to keep most of the liquidity but at a fraction of the cost
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by dman on Friday July 30, 2010 @01:43AM (#1560371)
Except that when the liquidity is most needed it disappears. Example the market fall on May 6th of this year. http://www.minyanville.com/businessmarkets/articles/apple-mi...
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by SkyMarshal on Friday July 30, 2010 @02:24AM (#1560424)
I don't recall us having significant liquidity problems prior to HFT, except during crisis, and as the recent one shows, we had liquidity problems even with HFT then.

I'm not buying the argument that 'HFT' provides any meaningful additional liquidity.

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by jbooth on Thursday July 29, 2010 @11:43PM (#1560200)
So?

Let's say all subsecond trading is abolished tomorrow, and rather than a smooth curve, all asset prices step at 1-second intervals.

What value was destroyed there?

If none, what value are these guys creating? None?

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by anamax on Friday July 30, 2010 @12:08AM (#1560248)
> Let's say all subsecond trading is abolished tomorrow, and rather than a smooth curve, all asset prices step at 1-second intervals.

That will tend to expand the bid-ask spread. That hurts both buyer and seller.

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by artsrc on Friday July 30, 2010 @03:46PM (#1562340)
The typical trading range for the day is $100 to $110.

Scenario 1:

So someone offers (is willing to sell) a limit order at $100. Buyer bids at $110. They wait until the other order appears and cross according to some market rules (perhaps at $100, $105 or $110), no-one else gets anything.

Scenario 2:

HFC works out the trading is in range $100 to $110, puts bids in at $104, offers at $106, and makes $2. The sellers gets $104, the buyer pays $106 and both are better off than scenario 1?

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by jbooth on Friday July 30, 2010 @10:08AM (#1561142)
Even at subsecond intervals?

(I'll note that the bid/ask spread becomes effectively zero every time an actual trade happens -- what if it actually reflected market prices rather than a bunch of video games competing against each other?).

Does it hurt the buyer and seller more than the little nibbles these guys are taking to smooth out that curve?

I see a lot of paychecks being cut in this industry and I don't see the value being created. Looks like highway robbery to me.

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by anamax on Friday July 30, 2010 @04:48PM (#1562572)
> Does it hurt the buyer and seller more than the little nibbles these guys are taking to smooth out that curve?

Why are you assuming that the buyer and seller are hurt?

> I see a lot of paychecks being cut in this industry and I don't see the value being created. Looks like highway robbery to me.

I don't see the value in smurfs, but don't think that they're "highway robbery".

Liquidity, on the other hand, has huge value. Disagree? Try to sell an illiquid asset.

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by chopsueyar on Friday July 30, 2010 @07:35AM (#1560773)
So a decrease in liquidity will cause an increase in volatility?
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by gsmaverick on Friday July 30, 2010 @10:22AM (#1561179)
Possibly, but the biggest difference would be the increase in the bid/ask spread.
Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by jbooth on Friday July 30, 2010 @11:15AM (#1561355)
I don't see why high-frequency trading contracts that spread.

If they overlap very briefly (say, across different markets) and nobody else has noticed yet, a trading program jumps in and arbs the difference. That increases the spread.

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by yummyfajitas on Friday July 30, 2010 @01:32PM (#1561870)
If they overlap very briefly (say, across different markets) and nobody else has noticed yet, a trading program jumps in and arbs the difference.

Utter nonsense. In the case of crossed markets it is illegal to trade. Trading under these circumstances would violate RegNMS and most matching engines will reject orders that would cross the markets.

HFT firms reduce the spread due to competition. If the spread is $0.03 (say $9.97 and $10.00), I can do one of two things to be at the top of the order book and be the first to trade. I can either place my order first, or I can place an order at a higher price. If I'm the fastest, I have the earliest order at price $9.97 and I get filled first in the event of a trade. In this case, I make $0.03/share. If I'm not the fastest, I can still get to the top of the book by placing an order at $9.98. This reduces the spread to $0.02, and I can only make $0.02/share.

Re:High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay by artsrc on Friday July 30, 2010 @03:29PM (#1562291)
I can see an obvious cost to X, after many years no-one has produced any evidence of value to X, therefore X should be abolished, if it can be done at reasonable cost.

Investors providing capital should not care what time of day their trade goes through because it will settle at the same time anyway. So this 'liquidity' is worthless.

The purpose of shares is to raise capital for productive investment, in return for income to long term investors who provide the capital.

Both non-computerized traders, and computerized HFC traders have an obvious cost, they extract return from the markets that would otherwise go to investors. This reduces the returns for investors.

What if we create an exchange where market participants submit orders which are crossed once a day? You establish a fair matching system and clearing price algorithm. In that environment there is less money going to minute traders and so there would be better returns for investors.