Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by starkfist on Thursday July 29, 2010 @12:13PM
(#1558044)
I'm not sure they do anymore, but elite colleges and elite prep schools used to have a hillbilly quota. In this sense they are biased against poor whites, and they know it, so they provide(d) an "affirmative action" program for some of them. My father was born and raised in a town of about 1000 in Montana and received full-ride scholarships to Philips Andover and Princeton, which he believed were mostly due to this quota. He turned both down because he was into football, and eventually received a full-ride scholarship to play college football.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by hugh3 on Thursday July 29, 2010 @12:36PM
(#1558119)
I doubt they do any more. America's "elite" seem to have lost all respect for America's poor whites; they're "rednecks" and "white trash" who live in "trailers" or "McMansions" and shop at Wal-Mart and watch NASCAR and blah blah stereotype stereotype. If you're a poor non-white you're a victim of society, but if you're poor and white you're an ignorant hick. Poor whites are pretty much the only group upon whom it is socially acceptable to look down, nowadays.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by starkfist on Thursday July 29, 2010 @12:44PM
(#1558149)
I don't believe America's "elite" really ever had any "respect" for poor whites, per se. My family has a Scandinavian background and I went to a college which emphasized this cultural history, so we had to take a history classes about things like the plight of Norwegian immigrants in the 1860s. The elite english corporatists who employed poor scandinavian whites to build railroads and whatnot mostly viewed them as stupid but hard working laborers who chewed tobacco, drank too much and spoke a hilarious sing-song germanic language. I actually think this stereotype still exists a bit in places where there are still vestiges of WASP culture. When I lived in Boston my employers, who were local Brahmins always called me "hard working" which was a euphemism for "stupid, but gets the job done." (In contrast, they called their Harvard educated employees "clever")
When it comes to receiving the hillbilly quota scholarship, my grandparents happened to be poor and living in the middle of nowhere but also had advanced degrees in mathematics and religion and were employed as schoolteachers.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by credo on Thursday July 29, 2010 @02:11PM
(#1558550)
This seems to be a fairly popular view among people who see "reverse racism" in America, however I think it is mistaken to assume that poor blacks have it easy and that the so-called "elite" only look down upon poor whites.
Btw several powerful establishment figures seem to think of "rednecks" as far more important than the so-called "elite". Sarah Palin and mother politicians use Redneck jokes to endear themselves and identify themselves with their core constituencies. It is hard to imagine someone like Obama or Deval or some other mainstream black politician use n-word jokes for political benefit or to describe themselves.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by dgabriel on Thursday July 29, 2010 @12:41PM
(#1558138)
That is not an accurate characterization of how the institutions themselves see poor whites. You may find some outspoken idiot students who hold these beliefs, but you'll find outspoken idiots who think lots of foolish things.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by kenjackson on Thursday July 29, 2010 @11:58AM
(#1557997)
The book seems to say a fairly obvious point, which is:
If you attempt to diversify by socioeconomic status (including race), those that are overrepresented be SES and race will appear to be penalized. This is due to the fact that admission to elite colleges is a zero sum game. There are X number of spots. If you somehow diversify to get Z more members of group A then there will be Z less spots to go around.
Not really rocket science.
To me the two big questions really are:
1) Are race and SES the right things to seek diversity, if anything at all? This is oft debated.
2) Is merit the right measuring stick for admission in general? This is rarely debated.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by yalurker on Thursday July 29, 2010 @12:48PM
(#1558174)
You've missed the point. The "fairly obvious point" would be that ALL whites are disadvantaged by providing a certain quota or advantage to non-white applicants, but that's not the point here.
The significance of the recent research is that low-income, rural, red-state whites face discrimination relative to high-income, urban, blue-state whites. That is, given two white students of equal merit, the admission is more likely to go to the one born in Manhattan than the one born in Iowa.
The tragic thing is that apparently this is new information to some people, when everyone in the midwest has known this for years. I was valedictorian of my high school, had very high standardized test scores and a dozen extra-curricular activities with leadership roles.... but I didn't even both to apply for any Ivy/prestigious schools because I knew being from a small town in the midwest I had no chance. How's that for institutionalized discrimination (or bias inherent in the system)?
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by dgabriel on Thursday July 29, 2010 @12:55PM
(#1558201)
This isn't new, and has little to do with diversity programs. Frankly, it's not the unqualified poor minority students keeping you out, it's the unqualified wealthy legacy students. That group is almost certain to gain admittance to a prestigious school, while the minority group member has to fight just as hard as you did.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by eli on Thursday July 29, 2010 @12:36PM
(#1558120)
But (at least the intent) is to penalize the overrepresented groups because they have already benefited from being born at the right place to the right parents at the right time. That's why there are they're overrepresented in application numbers. The point is to counteract bias already present in the application and evaluation process.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by ams6110 on Thursday July 29, 2010 @12:19PM
(#1558072)
How much are SAT prep classes worth anymore? 30 years ago maybe, but today thanks to government requirements, kids go through yearly or twice-yearly standardized testing from elementary to high school. A significant amount of instructional time is spent on practice tests and strategies. How much more is a high school junior going to learn about these tests in a prep course?
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by eli on Thursday July 29, 2010 @12:25PM
(#1558086)
Sure, it's debatable. AFAIK, the only people who have paid for studies of the classes are the companies that produce the classes. And those studies, of course, show a significant improvement.
There's no debating that SAT scores are highly correlated to income. And there's very little evidence that SAT scores are reliable predictors of college success.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by sprout on Thursday July 29, 2010 @12:42PM
(#1558142)
The thing is, there is a substantial bias that aids poor people in general, not in the admission process, but in the process of actually going to school.
Even though the private colleges have price tags up in the $40k+ range, the average middle-class family will end up paying around $20k, and truly poor people generally pay as much if not less than they would for a state school.
The admission process is a crapshoot, and I don't really see any reason to whine about arbitrary stuff like this. They have to rule some people out, it's mostly random once you get past a certain point, and even if it isn't, I don't think it's particularly harmful. Not everyone can get in.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by eli on Thursday July 29, 2010 @12:16PM
(#1558057)
I agree that class should be more important than race in making these decisions, but it's also true that, on average, poor minorities have more disadvantages and more to overcome than poor whites.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by tcskeptic on Thursday July 29, 2010 @12:26PM
(#1558091)
That is an interesting assertion, what is it based on? My experience working for a year in Appalachia (late 90s) tells me that rural poor whites have a pretty rough time of it, my experience tutoring in Cabrini Green (when it was still enormous, early 90s) taught me that poor minorities have it terrible as well.
I have no idea how to compare the disadvantages each has to overcome, let alone quantify one set vs. another. I think the experience of the rural poor in this country is often overlooked compared to the inner city. They are in my experience both utterly pathological societies, I cannot imagine having the sustained discipline to escape either one.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by starkfist on Thursday July 29, 2010 @01:11PM
(#1558263)
In my experience, non-white vs. non-white racism is the most popular form of racism in the world today. It's long been uncouth for whites to hate blacks, but it's ok for blacks to hate mexicans, or chinese to hate koreans, or koreans to hate everybody.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by rick888 on Thursday July 29, 2010 @01:22PM
(#1558325)
"That's because you are not a minority, and of course you don't see it on a daily basis. Out of curiosity, what sort of racism have you experienced?"
Right. There's so much racism in the US. Every job I have ever had has had a mix of different races among its employees (not to mention the president of the United States).
I've experienced racism first-hand as someone who is a non-minority. A couple of years ago, I went to a big boy in Atlanta, Georgia. The majority of the staff and patrons were black. It took them 45 minutes to an hour to get my food (people that clearly were there after me got their food much earlier). I also got a lot of stares.
If this was the reverse, Al Sharpton would have been picketing outside to get the waitress fired.
When will it end? I'm wondering when the minorities in this country will end their self-segregation.
What I want in this country is equality (everyone has an equal shot at getting into things like universities IE: no extra points on the SATs/quotas based on race), but I don't think this will ever happen.
It's also funny that Greek organizations are allowed to have entire fraternities based on race (asian, african-american, etc), but if a caucasian frat was founded, it would be considered racist. This isn't equality.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by wan23 on Thursday July 29, 2010 @05:19PM
(#1559292)
Without addressing your points specifically, you sound angry about the situation of race in America. Many people of all races have issues with the status quo. Some people express it directly, like for example taking longer to get your food. In America, it's safe to say that if you cross racial boundaries enough, you'll eventually run into some racism no matter what race you are. So yes, there is much racism in America, and you've seen it yourself.
Only problem is, it's asymmetrical. You experienced it at a restaurant. Other likely places for someone like you might be at the laundromat, at school, at a party, at the post office. But it's unlikely at places like, at the bank, at a job interview (for a good job - not McDonalds), driving down the highway, etc. Because even though in America anyone can be racist, the people in positions that matter are more often white.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by protomyth on Thursday July 29, 2010 @04:24PM
(#1559106)
I'm white, my biological father is Native American (Chippewa) and I grew up on a Sioux rez (an FYI Chippewa and Sioux / Dakota / Lakota are not friends). It doesn't matter what color your skin is if you grow up in an area where you are not the majority.
I really find people who make a judgement based on a datum to be in error most of the time. You are <insert category here> so you have never truly experienced <insert social problem here>.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by endtime on Thursday July 29, 2010 @01:08PM
(#1558250)
A couple examples that come to mind are being referred to as a "white bastard" by a black woman on the street in Philly, simply for walking past her; and various anti-Semitism from black people preaching on the street in New York. I haven't personally interacted with any members of the Nation of Islam, but they're also racists.
Also, my experience has been that Asian immigrants often dislike black people.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by codva on Thursday July 29, 2010 @12:37PM
(#1558122)
The 4H example in the article was odd. If you are president of 4H and want to go into some sort of agricultural field, what they hell are you going to do at Harvard or Yale anyway? You aren't even applying to those schools. You are going to a large land grant university, where the top agricultural programs are located. In a sense the deans at these elite colleges are correct. The odds of the 4H President being happy at Harvard are probably quite low.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by yalurker on Thursday July 29, 2010 @12:55PM
(#1558200)
And why the heck would a kid in band go to Harvard? He should be getting in a van and going on tour. And why would a kid in the chess club go to Yale? He should be playing chess. And why would a kid on the baseball team...
The typical over-achieving student is going to be in dozens of activities, none of which necessarily correlate with their future career. Agriculture might seem really weird or foreign to you, but for much of America being in FFA/4H/Eagle Scouts/whatever is just as normal as band, chess or sports.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by william42 on Thursday July 29, 2010 @01:25PM
(#1558335)
Actually, I seriously doubt a good baseball player is going to be going to an Ivy League school, for a simple two-word reason. Athletic scholarships. Ivy League schools have none.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by codva on Thursday July 29, 2010 @01:29PM
(#1558353)
If the kid in band wants to be a touring rock musician, then he absolutely should get in the van and go on tour. Or maybe get a degree as a back up and then go on tour - but I probably wouldn't recommend spending Harvard money on that degree.
My daughter is an officer in 4H - a horse club. I'm quite familiar with the organization. My point was that for those kids that fit the stereotype that the authors were picking on, high achievers with interests that don't fit the "elite" school stereotype, the admissions folks may have a point. The Harvards of the worlds may not be the best school for those kids. It's not necessarily evidence of bigotry.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by starkfist on Thursday July 29, 2010 @01:04PM
(#1558233)
After re-reading the article I wonder if it is really coherent to have a category called "elite schools" to which one can apply these blanket observations.
I think you are right, an agriculturally inclined student probably would not feel like they fit in at Yale. However, Cornell is also an Ivy, and they have a serious agricultural sciences program.
The article also mentions ROTC. I was once a TA at MIT, and there were many ROTC students at MIT. I believe MIT is now not just considered an elite engineering school, but just an "elite" school like the Ivies. And, I don't think they discriminate against ROTC students.
Furthermore, if they aren't already, the elite American universities of the future are Stanford and NYU, which seem to have much different student preferences than the Ivies or even hardcore engineering schools like MIT and Harvard, even though they are all lumped in together.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by hga on Thursday July 29, 2010 @07:34PM
(#1559718)
MIT was not one of the 8 schools in that study, it doesn't discriminate against Asians.
It factors in the opportunities a student has and admits students who therefore appear to have less going for them (it uses other metrics, a big one is being project oriented). It has at least in times past actively recruited white working class male students from the Midwest because they were underrepresented.
MIT has a big advantage, for there are no legacies to speak of. Everyone has to pass one year of the calculus (first term is the AP BC curriculum) and one year of calculus based physics. So MIT admits nobody who can't do the work. Legacies will get a "second look" if they don't make the first cut, but that's all. (As it is, the raw odds of admission are 1/3 if MIT thinks you can do the work.) It doesn't take many students from the fancy prep schools (I don't think many apply, MIT never was part of the elite prep school to Ivy/Ivy imitator path). So it simply has a lot more room for working class students.
Anecdotally, it doesn't seem to discriminate against Christians or students who have made achievements in those institutions cited in the study where for the normal elite colleges their chances of admission drop by 60-5%. As you note, MIT has ROTC units (if you get an ROTC scholarship at e.g. Harvard you have to go to MIT for the classes and other activities...).
(BTW, Harvard is not a "hardcore engineering school" ^_^. Although they did try to assimilate MIT in the years before it moved to Cambridge, that even led to a street riot in 1904 or 5. Heck, Harvard is so unhardcore that the last time I checked (end of the '80s) all you had to do WRT math was to prove you could do algebra.)
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by codva on Thursday July 29, 2010 @01:19PM
(#1558303)
I didn't realize Cornell is a Ivy. Great school, but I'll bet it wasn't what the author's were referring to as elite. And I agree, the term elite in this sense is sort of meaningless.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by codva on Thursday July 29, 2010 @01:00PM
(#1558219)
4H is trying to become more relevant to urban and suburban kids. But it is overwhelmingly still agriculturally focused. If you are President of the 4H Robotics Club I doubt the dean of Engineering at Harvard is going to hold it against you. If you are president of a traditional 4H club the admissions folks at Harvard probably should wonder why you want to come there. If the rest of your application shows an interest and aptitude for math and engineering, you are probably fine. IMO, the authors of the article failed to show widespread discrimination against poor whites, and failed miserably with their chosen example of 4H and FFA. You might say they showed a certain elitist bigotry themselves, which is ironic given the point they are trying to make.
"When lower-class whites are matched with lower-class blacks and other non-whites the degree of the non-white advantage becomes astronomical: lower-class Asian applicants are seven times as likely to be accepted to the competitive private institutions as similarly qualified whites, lower-class Hispanic applicants eight times as likely, and lower-class blacks ten times as likely. These are enormous differences and reflect the fact that lower-class whites were rarely accepted to the private institutions Espenshade and Radford surveyed. Their diversity-enhancement value was obviously rated very low."
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by Mod_daniel on Thursday July 29, 2010 @04:59PM
(#1559242)
Really? A link to an article that opens with a quote from Kevin Macdonald? I knew that the comments for this one would probably be a minefield but this is absurd. Take the antisemitism elsewhere.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by jerf on Thursday July 29, 2010 @12:16PM
(#1558059)
So, because it's a conservative thinktank talking about the issue, poor whites are not in fact being discriminated against? I wish I could cancel issues just by getting a partisan organization to talk about it!
I mean, the point is simple math. If you have a certain number of people you are going to admit, and you give bonuses to certain groups, you are equally penalizing others. People shouldn't be permitted to pretend otherwise because that's disingenuous; if you're going to do that, do it forthrightly and honestly. The fact that it's a challenge to forthrightly and honestly say "We want to discriminate against poor white people" sounds like a feature to me, not a bug.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by eli on Thursday July 29, 2010 @12:29PM
(#1558104)
No, it is not that simple. The question isn't "Does a poor white applicant have the exact same odds as a poor black applicant?" The question was, "Are we biased against poor whites?"
If you believe, as many do, that there are fewer minority applicants because of institutional racism and therefore you decide to weight their applications higher is that biasing you selection process? Or is it cancelling out bias present elsewhere in the system?
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by chc on Thursday July 29, 2010 @03:52PM
(#1558996)
If A and B are two rivals that are the same modulo one factor, but A has worse odds than B, then we must conclude that the system has a bias against subjects with that particular set of properties. You may justify it as an attempt to cancel out some other bias, but it seems mathematically incontrovertible that a negative bias exists with a set of numbers like that.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by spamizbad on Thursday July 29, 2010 @12:35PM
(#1558116)
> So, because it's a conservative thinktank talking about the issue, poor whites are not in fact being discriminated against?
Actually, my beef is with Think Tanks in general - I don't care what ideology they ascribe to. I should have made that more clear.
Think tanks exist to produce content that promotes the views of various Washington factions. They are arbiters of neither fact nor truth. They're political campaigns for ideologies, except instead of stump speeches you get blog posts and various "white paper" studies. It's not intellectually wholesome content, and skates a very fine line between propaganda and "informational content."
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by jbooth on Thursday July 29, 2010 @01:04PM
(#1558231)
Well, the fact that it's a conservative thinktank doesn't mean that they're necessarily wrong.
But it does mean that anything that the publish on race will be feeding into the idea of white victimhood at the hands of minorities. You just have to look at the party registration by race -- obviously that's what they have to publish, whether it's correct or not.
Re:Are Elite Colleges Biased Against Poor Whites?
by hga on Thursday July 29, 2010 @07:45PM
(#1559746)
Ummm, you are aware the author is discussing and quoting this study http://www.amazon.com/Longer-Separate-Not-Yet-Equal/dp/06911... that was done by a couple of Princeton sociologists??? Is this a riff on "The devil can cite Scripture for his purpose"?
Whatever. It was the Princeton types who said "Excelling in career-oriented activities is associated with 60 or 65 percent lower odds of admission", that is, having a leadership position or having achieved something significant in e.g. 4h, FFA, JROTC was crippling for your admission chances.
Let me finish by quoted the final bit from the two eeeevil Manhattan Institute scholars (Neili is from Princeton as well and wrote the first of their two articles on this study):
"As Nieli wrote: "The lower-class whites proved to be all-around losers... Having money in the family greatly improved a white applicant's admissions chances, lack of money greatly reduced it." If you read the whole book, the prejudice of the elite schools against poor whites seems clear. As a political issue, this is a sure bet to gain ground."
America's ruling class likes to pretend it's a meritocracy but studies like this show it's anything but. And that's indeed going to continue to be a major political issue. Discrimination has ugly consequences.
When it comes to receiving the hillbilly quota scholarship, my grandparents happened to be poor and living in the middle of nowhere but also had advanced degrees in mathematics and religion and were employed as schoolteachers.
Btw several powerful establishment figures seem to think of "rednecks" as far more important than the so-called "elite". Sarah Palin and mother politicians use Redneck jokes to endear themselves and identify themselves with their core constituencies. It is hard to imagine someone like Obama or Deval or some other mainstream black politician use n-word jokes for political benefit or to describe themselves.
Good for you, but no one is assuming that.
If you attempt to diversify by socioeconomic status (including race), those that are overrepresented be SES and race will appear to be penalized. This is due to the fact that admission to elite colleges is a zero sum game. There are X number of spots. If you somehow diversify to get Z more members of group A then there will be Z less spots to go around.
Not really rocket science.
To me the two big questions really are: 1) Are race and SES the right things to seek diversity, if anything at all? This is oft debated. 2) Is merit the right measuring stick for admission in general? This is rarely debated.
The significance of the recent research is that low-income, rural, red-state whites face discrimination relative to high-income, urban, blue-state whites. That is, given two white students of equal merit, the admission is more likely to go to the one born in Manhattan than the one born in Iowa.
The tragic thing is that apparently this is new information to some people, when everyone in the midwest has known this for years. I was valedictorian of my high school, had very high standardized test scores and a dozen extra-curricular activities with leadership roles.... but I didn't even both to apply for any Ivy/prestigious schools because I knew being from a small town in the midwest I had no chance. How's that for institutionalized discrimination (or bias inherent in the system)?
There's no debating that SAT scores are highly correlated to income. And there's very little evidence that SAT scores are reliable predictors of college success.
Even though the private colleges have price tags up in the $40k+ range, the average middle-class family will end up paying around $20k, and truly poor people generally pay as much if not less than they would for a state school.
The admission process is a crapshoot, and I don't really see any reason to whine about arbitrary stuff like this. They have to rule some people out, it's mostly random once you get past a certain point, and even if it isn't, I don't think it's particularly harmful. Not everyone can get in.
I have no idea how to compare the disadvantages each has to overcome, let alone quantify one set vs. another. I think the experience of the rural poor in this country is often overlooked compared to the inner city. They are in my experience both utterly pathological societies, I cannot imagine having the sustained discipline to escape either one.
But there is still racism in this country and it overwhelmingly is against minorities.
The only racism I have ever experienced in the US has been from "minorities" (i.e. non-white people), usually directed toward white people.
Right. There's so much racism in the US. Every job I have ever had has had a mix of different races among its employees (not to mention the president of the United States).
I've experienced racism first-hand as someone who is a non-minority. A couple of years ago, I went to a big boy in Atlanta, Georgia. The majority of the staff and patrons were black. It took them 45 minutes to an hour to get my food (people that clearly were there after me got their food much earlier). I also got a lot of stares.
If this was the reverse, Al Sharpton would have been picketing outside to get the waitress fired.
When will it end? I'm wondering when the minorities in this country will end their self-segregation.
What I want in this country is equality (everyone has an equal shot at getting into things like universities IE: no extra points on the SATs/quotas based on race), but I don't think this will ever happen.
It's also funny that Greek organizations are allowed to have entire fraternities based on race (asian, african-american, etc), but if a caucasian frat was founded, it would be considered racist. This isn't equality.
Only problem is, it's asymmetrical. You experienced it at a restaurant. Other likely places for someone like you might be at the laundromat, at school, at a party, at the post office. But it's unlikely at places like, at the bank, at a job interview (for a good job - not McDonalds), driving down the highway, etc. Because even though in America anyone can be racist, the people in positions that matter are more often white.
I really find people who make a judgement based on a datum to be in error most of the time. You are <insert category here> so you have never truly experienced <insert social problem here>.
Also, my experience has been that Asian immigrants often dislike black people.
The typical over-achieving student is going to be in dozens of activities, none of which necessarily correlate with their future career. Agriculture might seem really weird or foreign to you, but for much of America being in FFA/4H/Eagle Scouts/whatever is just as normal as band, chess or sports.
My daughter is an officer in 4H - a horse club. I'm quite familiar with the organization. My point was that for those kids that fit the stereotype that the authors were picking on, high achievers with interests that don't fit the "elite" school stereotype, the admissions folks may have a point. The Harvards of the worlds may not be the best school for those kids. It's not necessarily evidence of bigotry.
They don't do biology at Harvard?
4H isn't specific to future farmers. (Heck, Future Farmers of America, aka, FFA, isn't specific to future farmers.)
If you're going to argue that a specific kind of discrimination is rational, shouldn't you actually know what you're talking about?
I think you are right, an agriculturally inclined student probably would not feel like they fit in at Yale. However, Cornell is also an Ivy, and they have a serious agricultural sciences program.
The article also mentions ROTC. I was once a TA at MIT, and there were many ROTC students at MIT. I believe MIT is now not just considered an elite engineering school, but just an "elite" school like the Ivies. And, I don't think they discriminate against ROTC students.
Furthermore, if they aren't already, the elite American universities of the future are Stanford and NYU, which seem to have much different student preferences than the Ivies or even hardcore engineering schools like MIT and Harvard, even though they are all lumped in together.
It factors in the opportunities a student has and admits students who therefore appear to have less going for them (it uses other metrics, a big one is being project oriented). It has at least in times past actively recruited white working class male students from the Midwest because they were underrepresented.
MIT has a big advantage, for there are no legacies to speak of. Everyone has to pass one year of the calculus (first term is the AP BC curriculum) and one year of calculus based physics. So MIT admits nobody who can't do the work. Legacies will get a "second look" if they don't make the first cut, but that's all. (As it is, the raw odds of admission are 1/3 if MIT thinks you can do the work.) It doesn't take many students from the fancy prep schools (I don't think many apply, MIT never was part of the elite prep school to Ivy/Ivy imitator path). So it simply has a lot more room for working class students.
Anecdotally, it doesn't seem to discriminate against Christians or students who have made achievements in those institutions cited in the study where for the normal elite colleges their chances of admission drop by 60-5%. As you note, MIT has ROTC units (if you get an ROTC scholarship at e.g. Harvard you have to go to MIT for the classes and other activities...).
(BTW, Harvard is not a "hardcore engineering school" ^_^. Although they did try to assimilate MIT in the years before it moved to Cambridge, that even led to a street riot in 1904 or 5. Heck, Harvard is so unhardcore that the last time I checked (end of the '80s) all you had to do WRT math was to prove you could do algebra.)
Also see this excellent article on the same subject: http://theoccidentalobserver.net/tooblog/?p=2923
"When lower-class whites are matched with lower-class blacks and other non-whites the degree of the non-white advantage becomes astronomical: lower-class Asian applicants are seven times as likely to be accepted to the competitive private institutions as similarly qualified whites, lower-class Hispanic applicants eight times as likely, and lower-class blacks ten times as likely. These are enormous differences and reflect the fact that lower-class whites were rarely accepted to the private institutions Espenshade and Radford surveyed. Their diversity-enhancement value was obviously rated very low."
I mean, the point is simple math. If you have a certain number of people you are going to admit, and you give bonuses to certain groups, you are equally penalizing others. People shouldn't be permitted to pretend otherwise because that's disingenuous; if you're going to do that, do it forthrightly and honestly. The fact that it's a challenge to forthrightly and honestly say "We want to discriminate against poor white people" sounds like a feature to me, not a bug.
If you believe, as many do, that there are fewer minority applicants because of institutional racism and therefore you decide to weight their applications higher is that biasing you selection process? Or is it cancelling out bias present elsewhere in the system?
Actually, my beef is with Think Tanks in general - I don't care what ideology they ascribe to. I should have made that more clear.
Think tanks exist to produce content that promotes the views of various Washington factions. They are arbiters of neither fact nor truth. They're political campaigns for ideologies, except instead of stump speeches you get blog posts and various "white paper" studies. It's not intellectually wholesome content, and skates a very fine line between propaganda and "informational content."
But it does mean that anything that the publish on race will be feeding into the idea of white victimhood at the hands of minorities. You just have to look at the party registration by race -- obviously that's what they have to publish, whether it's correct or not.
Whatever. It was the Princeton types who said "Excelling in career-oriented activities is associated with 60 or 65 percent lower odds of admission", that is, having a leadership position or having achieved something significant in e.g. 4h, FFA, JROTC was crippling for your admission chances.
Let me finish by quoted the final bit from the two eeeevil Manhattan Institute scholars (Neili is from Princeton as well and wrote the first of their two articles on this study):
"As Nieli wrote: "The lower-class whites proved to be all-around losers... Having money in the family greatly improved a white applicant's admissions chances, lack of money greatly reduced it." If you read the whole book, the prejudice of the elite schools against poor whites seems clear. As a political issue, this is a sure bet to gain ground."
America's ruling class likes to pretend it's a meritocracy but studies like this show it's anything but. And that's indeed going to continue to be a major political issue. Discrimination has ugly consequences.