News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by njarboe on Friday October 27, 2017 @06:29PM (#15572723)
I am never sure what to think of these claims when Social Security and Medicare (both employer and employee parts) taxes aren't counted as income taxes. Seems a bit deceiving not to include those taxes as income taxes as they are based on a percent of your income (and only a part of your income if you make over about $100k for Social Security).
Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by lisper on Friday October 27, 2017 @07:10PM (#15572989)
> Seems a bit deceiving

It's more than a bit deceiving. It's part of a systematic disinformation campaign. It goes hand-in-hand with the outrageous lie that the estate tax harms family farmers.

But cutting taxes on the rich is indefensible on the merits, so deception is the only option if you're rich and you don't want to pay taxes.

Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by refurb on Friday October 27, 2017 @08:12PM (#15573269)
The percentage of taxes paid by the highest income earners is lower when you include all taxes, but still pretty significant.[1] These numbers do not include state taxes, only federal.

Income percentile - % individual income tax paid - % all taxes paid

Top 10% - 83.4% - 65%

Top 5% - 69.4% - 53%

Top 0.01% - 26.4% - 19.2%

Note that anyone in the bottom 50% actually has a negative income tax contribution since they get tax credits.

For the top 0.01% of income earners, the average total tax rate is 46.3%. Much higher than I originally thought.

[1]https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/tax-policy/tax-anal...

Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by njarboe on Saturday October 28, 2017 @03:14AM (#15574302)
I don't see capital gains on that chart. Is it part of income? I think most rich people grow their wealth with capital gains that are only taxed when realized and even then are taxed at a lower rate than regular income.
Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by cjlars on Saturday October 28, 2017 @05:10PM (#15576772)
Read the footnotes, it's lumped into individual income taxes.
Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by alexasmyths on Friday October 27, 2017 @08:14PM (#15573282)
" It's part of a systematic disinformation campaign. "

Oh, no, I'm sorry but it's the other way around.

The 'mass lie' is on the employer payroll tax side of the equation.

An employer payroll tax is for all purposes the same thing as an employee tax, but it's 'hidden' (i.e. you don't see it as a deduction) - but it's equally as oppressive.

Politicians love it because they can increase it without any visibility and no uproar.

It's about 30% in Sweden.

Also - up to ~50% income tax.

And then 25% VAT.

Can you imagine if Google had to take 30% of your salary off the top before they paid you?

And then you're effective rate wast 10% higher (like 40%?).

And then everything you bought was 25% taxed?

And the other form of 'hidden tax' - in many places, prices have to be quoted with VAT to hide the 'hit' they take.

Admittedly you get healthcare for that.

It's very reasonable to call this confiscation of wealth.

If you're a professional, you're giving by far and away most of your earnings to the government to have them manage it on your behalf.

Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by metaphor on Friday October 27, 2017 @07:33PM (#15573102)
> and only a part of your income if you make over about $100k for Social Security

More precisely, 6.2% on a wage base limit of $127,200 for calendar year 2017, which amounts to $7,886.40 per person; 1.45% for Medicare without a cap, and an additional 0.9% withholding in excess of $200,000.

For the unindoctrinated, the IRS publishes these (and other related) details under Notice 1036[1] every year circa December.

[1] https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-notice-1036

Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by njarboe on Friday October 27, 2017 @07:41PM (#15573138)
Plus, I believe, the employer part which is another 6.2% on a wage base limit of $127,200. A bit hidden away so you don't think about it too much.
Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by metaphor on Friday October 27, 2017 @07:54PM (#15573191)
Yeah, employer pays the same 6.2% and 1.45%, respectively...except for the additional 0.9% Medicare conditional, which is withheld from the employee only. The self-employed effectively pay double out of pocket.
Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by walshemj on Friday October 27, 2017 @06:35PM (#15572775)
One loop hole that should be closed in the USA is the $1 salary which many SV founders and board members do to avoid paying social security.
Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by maxerickson on Friday October 27, 2017 @06:47PM (#15572838)
Are they that petty that payroll taxes are really part of the calculation?

(It's ~$10,000-$15,000 for valley salaries... https://www.ssa.gov/oact/cola/cbb.html )

Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by lovich on Saturday October 28, 2017 @02:14AM (#15574179)
Yes they are that petty. Steve Jobs parked in handicapped parking spots because he couldn't be bothered to walk as far as normal people. Zuckerberg rolled up to Hawaii, bought some land, and tried to sue all the locals off of the rights they had enjoyed for generations before he showed up. Bill Gates, for all the good he does now, was a giant dick to everyone he did business with at every chance he got. The super rich are the pettiest people on the planet because unlike regular people, they don't deal with the consequences.

If an average person starts doing everything they technically are allowed to do, they will be shunned socially. When that happens, beyond feeling bad, you lose your support network and can get into serious trouble in life. The rich don't have that problem. They don't need to rely on the good will of others to watch their kids, or to give them time off to go handle bank issues or medical problems.

Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by maxerickson on Saturday October 28, 2017 @07:20AM (#15574759)
You are describing anti-social behaviors, not really addressing my question. Do you think that keeping $15,000 out of the Social Security system is an animating reason for them to take the non salaries?

I think it is more like a few hundred thousand dollars not really being a relevant amount of money to someone with hundreds of millions of dollars of stock on the line and the symbolism being useful.

Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by kthejoker2 on Wednesday November 01, 2017 @02:39PM (#15604212)
The symbolism of paying your taxes is also useful. Possibly only exceeded by the actual benefits of the government revenue.
Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by walshemj on Saturday October 28, 2017 @10:41AM (#15575278)
Its the perception that they are doing petty tax avoidance doesn't make their ethics look very good and those on average salaries will see rich people avoiding $15k in a negative light
Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by cjlars on Saturday October 28, 2017 @05:07PM (#15576766)
Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by gnicholas on Friday October 27, 2017 @06:33PM (#15572753)
True, but you also get paid back based on your Social Security payments (should you live so long). To the extent that it's a forced-savings program, it isn't exactly an income tax.
Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by maxerickson on Friday October 27, 2017 @06:50PM (#15572861)
The government has borrowed and spent the entire trust fund. There are no savings, it's funded year to year from taxes.

(the left hand of the government says it has $2.8 trillion and the right hand of the government thinks that is a cool story https://www.ssa.gov/oact/TRSUM/index.html )

Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by gozur88 on Friday October 27, 2017 @07:39PM (#15573131)
This is true, but on the other hand it hardly makes sense for the government to save and borrow at the same time.
Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by maxerickson on Friday October 27, 2017 @08:08PM (#15573253)
Oh, I'm not trying to sensationalize it, I just think it is fair to peak at the actual cash flows when people start talking about Social Security as a savings program.
Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by mikeash on Friday October 27, 2017 @10:11PM (#15573617)
It’s money that’s taken from me by the government whether I want to or not. The fact that it goes into a separate bucket used for a particular program doesn’t somehow make it not a tax.

Especially since it’s very much not a forced savings program. If it were, we’d pass on the remainder to our heirs if we died early, and we’d run out of money if we lived too long. It’s more like a forced annuity.

Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by SilasX on Friday October 27, 2017 @06:52PM (#15572883)
As a retirement savings vehicle, it has a pitiful rate of return, and the payouts may decrease, or taxes thereon increase, before you retire, since they're only "invested" in extremely low yielding, not-legally-enforceable bonds.
Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by pyronik on Friday October 27, 2017 @10:54PM (#15573749)
People presumably benefit from those directly in old age, should we count how much people spend in groceries too?
Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by jbuzbee on Friday October 27, 2017 @06:33PM (#15572750)
They aren't counted because basically they're forced savings. Typically everything you put into SS you'll get back. Lower income folks end up getting more back than they put in. And the same for Medicare. It's a forced insurance payment of sorts.
Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by r00fus on Friday October 27, 2017 @06:37PM (#15572784)
Not while the general fund is allowed to steal from SS and then declare it as "debt".

The vast majority of the US debt is owed to SS recipients.

Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by wpietri on Friday October 27, 2017 @06:49PM (#15572853)
Are you sure? From what I can tell, it's not close. Total debt is $19.4T; intergovernmental debt is $5.4T: https://www.treasurydirect.gov/govt/reports/pd/mspd/2016/opd...

And given that the total trust fund appears to be $2.8T, I'm not sure how it could hold the majority of the debt: https://ycharts.com/indicators/us_oldage_and_survivors_insur...

Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by r00fus on Friday October 27, 2017 @07:18PM (#15573028)
Who owns the US Nation Debt [1]. I stand corrected, the vast majority is owed not just to Social Security, but to retirees in general (though SS is the largest debt holder).

[1] https://www.thebalance.com/who-owns-the-u-s-national-debt-33...

Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by wpietri on Saturday October 28, 2017 @11:10AM (#15575360)
Again, I would like you to show your numbers, because I am not seeing the vast majority being owed to retirees, either.
Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by Steko on Friday October 27, 2017 @06:44PM (#15572823)
No, the truth is they aren't counted because correctly counting them would undermine the bullshit conclusion they're pushing.
Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by ovao on Friday October 27, 2017 @07:09PM (#15572984)
To count Social Security and Medicare withholding as part of federal income taxes would be incorrect, as neither are income taxes (they are payroll taxes.)

I think to correctly frame what proportion any income group (or wealth group) pays, you have to look not just as federal income taxes, but at all taxes.

Re:Study shows the top 0.01% of Scandinavian households unde... by Steko on Friday October 27, 2017 @07:23PM (#15573049)
I think you are arguing past me on the first part. They are "payroll taxes", yes. And there is a "US federal income tax" of which they are not, yes. Technically they do also fit the definition of what an income tax is (wikt:"A tax levied on earned and unearned income"; wikipedia "Retirement oriented taxes, such as Social Security or national insurance, also are a type of income tax, though not generally referred to as such").

More to the point, and I think we agree here, the deception is by framing the discussion only about the "us federal income tax" when that is only 60% of the total federal income/payroll taxes collected. If you tell people that the top 1% makes 22% of the money and pays 40% of federal income taxes it makes them sound oppressed. If you tell people that the top 1% makes 22% of the money, has 35% of wealth and pays 25% of federal income and payroll taxes, the oppression disappears.