News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by derekp7 on Thursday October 26, 2017 @02:43PM (#15561767)
I wonder why Chicago isn't more of a major destination for tech companies. The city is highly walkable, has excellent transportation infrastructure, and low cost nice housing is plentiful within an hour commute by train or car. You can get a nice house for less than 200k, apartment rent is around 600 - 1000 a month. In the city, there are a lot of old 3-4 story houses that have been converted to each floor being a rental unit, for about 1200.
Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by tomaha on Thursday October 26, 2017 @02:48PM (#15561821)
Because mostly only big companies choose their destination. For the rest it's where they live when they found the company. So if more people in Chicago found tech companies you'll get more tech companies. That's the reason SV is a self-feeding machine. People work at one of the many startups or big companies here, get experience, get money, and then part of them start their own companies. That's the circle that drives SV and because it gets stronger each time it's hard for any other city or region to really catch up.
Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by radiorental on Thursday October 26, 2017 @03:08PM (#15562025)
Your description made think of the slime mold map of the Tokyo transportation system [1] albeit with a different set of inputs.

As with any organic, self propelled, system.. it matures and growth turns to maintenance, and eventually decay. Is the general argument here that SV has become a victim of it's massive organic growth, has it eaten up one of it's resources (housing, healthy diversity, etc) to the point where another city/system can now flourish??

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GwKuFREOgmo

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by _RPM on Thursday October 26, 2017 @02:59PM (#15561938)
> So if more people in Chicago found tech companies you'll get more tech companies

Wait, really?

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by gumby on Thursday October 26, 2017 @03:15PM (#15562085)
I know it sounds tautological but makes sense in the context of the rest of the reply.
Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by logfromblammo on Thursday October 26, 2017 @04:14PM (#15562593)
Having lived in Chicago, I think it's probably because the city government is corrupt, the Cook county government is corrupt, the suburban county governments are corrupt, all their municipalities are corrupt, and the whole region is going bankrupt from it. People look at Detroit, and think Chicago may be next. They don't want to put their eggs in the same basket as a time bomb, or an egg-sucking weasel. The only thing that has saved it so far is that it is a nice, affordable place to live.

There are billboards on the state border encouraging people to live in Indiana (live in Gary?!) because Indiana isn't going bankrupt.

And it isn't just the obvious form of corruption that everyone can see and hate on, like Blagojevich trying to outright sell a vacant senate seat. It's also the subtle form that pays public employees slightly too much to do not quite enough, and then a pension that gives them even more for doing even less, while their replacement adds even more to the burden. You can't just fire all those people and take away their pensions, because then you can't provide municipal services to your residents, and that is more acutely painful than being slowly bled to death.

Edit:

In slight support of those billboards and some cousin posts, Indianapolis is one of the most affordable cities in the US for buying housing. And the pool for tech talent is largely untapped.

Public transit sucks, though. The city has a huge area and is almost completely flat, so it has taken extreme advantage of its ability to sprawl. Any sudden spike in growth will immediately lead to commuting nightmare traffic, all around the entire city.

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by tptacek on Friday October 27, 2017 @11:04AM (#15569052)
Public finance problems in Chicago are a product of unrealistic pension guarantees. You can call that "corruption", but by that definition many other major metros in the USA are equally "corrupt".

The Chicago and Illinois Democratic party machines are almost certainly corrupt (or just rife with corruption), like most single-party states. But it's not clear to me how this impacts ordinary life for citizens.

Indianapolis is fine. I generally think, if you're going to move to a Midwestern city with no critical mass of tech companies, you might just consider throwing a dart. There are more tech workers in Chicago than Indianapolis, but in no Midwestern city are you going to exhaust the supply.

We generally need to get away from the notion that the locale in which you start your company is make-or-break. What we don't need to do is suggest that there's a Midwestern Ur-city where everyone needs to go.

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by logfromblammo on Friday October 27, 2017 @03:21PM (#15571398)
By that measure, yes, I do think most of the major metros in the US are corrupt. It is a by-product of the loss of genuinely productive jobs in the country, and the rise of the "jobs" that had to replace them, because as a nation, the U.S. is violently allergic to any form of "unearned" welfare system. So the largest portion of the welfare system takes the form of pointless, overpaid, make-work government jobs. The military-industrial complex is similar, providing jobs for people leaving the military with no experience applicable towards ordinary businesses. It's welfare for veterans, but they have to work for it, so that's okay.

It impacts ordinary citizens by raising their taxes and making the siting of production facilities in that locale even less attractive to companies, which tends to compound the problem. Real jobs leave. Fake jobs spring up. Companies that offer real jobs get squeezed harder to pay for the fake jobs. When they finally reach a breaking point, they leave and take the jobs with them. Spiral further down and repeat.

This gets thrown around on HN a lot, but the root cause of the problem is the implicit and seemingly unassailable assumption that everyone has to work in order to eat. People actually get angry at the idea that someone might get the minimum portion of life's necessities without sweating on them first.

Until that is addressed, no city in the US is totally safe for a business founded to do productive work, and the safest cities are those where enough new businesses are founded to employ all the people who would otherwise be forced to do make-work jobs to survive. And I think that's why people want to found companies in places that are already considered to be friendly to startups. The tightness of the labor market is not a bug; it's a feature. It means that more of your taxes go to infrastructure and vital services, and less to stealth welfare.

The best place to start a business is one that doesn't need for you to start it there.

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by ng12 on Thursday October 26, 2017 @02:51PM (#15561853)
Because it doesn't have the people and that's all that really matters. SV is self-fulfilling at this point: talented programmers and entrepreneurs flock to the Bay because that's where the talented programmers and entrepreneurs are.

Yes, there are talented programmers in every metropolitan area but the Bay has significantly more of them than anywhere else.

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by vonmoltke on Thursday October 26, 2017 @03:12PM (#15562048)
Yet SV companies complain the loudest about having a hard time finding talent. In large part, I suspect, because of decreasing amounts of talent that want to put up with the area.
Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by TeMPOraL on Friday October 27, 2017 @01:31AM (#15565934)
I believe that's just selection bias. The media - especially the media most of us here are likely to read - focus on SV tech companies. Next to an article about SV startup complaining about lack of talent, you won't find an article about startup from Kraków, Poland complaining about the same, because who cares.

I.e. "loudest" isn't really the right word to describe the only group that is even allowed to speak publicly.

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by kmonsen on Thursday October 26, 2017 @04:18PM (#15562635)
People are having problems finding cheap talent. I lived in both bay area and NYC and in both places I would constantly get lowball offers.

You can get really good engineers in bay area, it just cost more than many are willing to pay.

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by vonmoltke on Thursday October 26, 2017 @04:58PM (#15562940)
True, but part of the reason talent is so expensive is because companies have to compete for it. I would not call a market where good people regularly pull down multiple offers one that is good for employers or one where talent is readily available.
Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by wolco on Thursday October 26, 2017 @03:14PM (#15562076)
Findig programmers is not the issue VC money and culture make the difference.
Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by CalChris on Thursday October 26, 2017 @03:38PM (#15562261)
University of Chicago isn't a bad school. I am, however, straining to think of another Chicago research university. But then compare it to Stanford+Cal+UCSF and it just isn't a fair fight.

An underrated advantage in SV is its top tier legal and capital talent. WSGR, Cooley, Fenwick, ... are outstanding. For VCs you can start with Sequoia at the top and work your way all the way down to angels. L+S did a demo in Andy Bechtolsheim's garage and walked away with a check for $250,000. That just ain't happening in Chicago.

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by tptacek on Friday October 27, 2017 @11:17AM (#15569196)
Chicago is one of the legal and finance centers of the entire country. Unlike SFBA, it's a trading center (it was the heart of the HFT phenomenon). Some of the largest law firms in the world are headquartered here.

What you're really trying to say is that there's no venture capital market here. That's true. (And, as a result, there's no real venture law here). Venture capital is a rounding error in the global financial markets. Don't extrapolate lack of VC to lack of capital.

Obviously, none of this is helpful for tech companies that want to raise a round in Chicago. If you plan on raising, you should probably at least start in SFBA or NYC.

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by CalChris on Friday October 27, 2017 @03:18PM (#15571373)
No, I'm not saying there's no VC in Chicago. But SV had about 2000 'funding rounds' in 2016. Chicago had about 200. SV just dominates VC and you need VC not just C to start companies.

http://static.crunchbase.com/reports/annual_2016_yf42a/crunc...

But this isn't the 70s+80s anymore when frankly you had to be in SV. Nowadays there are tremendous advantages to being here but you can be successful elsewhere. Instead, today SV competes for the market rather than owns its.

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by tptacek on Friday October 27, 2017 @03:23PM (#15571431)
We're actually saying the same thing: there is no serious community of VC funding in Chicago. I'm just saying that's not because Chicago isn't a capital/finance center.
Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by CalChris on Friday October 27, 2017 @04:21PM (#15571907)
Pretty much the same thing.

As for the topic, I think Thiel is a pompous twit. What I will say is that places like Chicago can be quite competitive by being less competitive and more organic. Here, it's I'm doing Snapchat meets Uber. Not quite Dot Com but awfully close. A YC side effect.

If you've got a real idea, it doesn't become real by being here despite here having huge advantages. Was Zuckerberg wrong for picking up his toys and moving to a rental in Palo Alto? Not really. But Xero isn't here. Hell, Xero isn't even American.

So it's kind've like Hollywood. For a few decades, they had tremendous advantages. Now Hollywood competes and other cities do production and location work. But Hollywood is still central to the industry and will be for the foreseeable future.

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by strange_quark on Thursday October 26, 2017 @05:14PM (#15563072)
UChicago is an excellent school, right up there with Stanford and the Ivys, and you're forgetting Northwestern, UIUC, Wisconsin - Madison, Michigan - Ann Arbor, Purdue, and plenty others.
Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by CalChris on Thursday October 26, 2017 @05:44PM (#15563339)
There's a good reason I've never met anyone from the University of Chicago in Silicon Valley. It doesn't have an engineering school. I have met two people from Moscow State University (quite a bit further, no?) in Silicon Valley. It does have an engineering school.
Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by closeparen on Friday October 27, 2017 @11:30AM (#15569348)
There are dozens of us! Dozens! As CS is under physical sciences rather than engineering, we come away with less differential equations experience than those in the engineering tradition, but also much more systems programming. I wouldn’t trade it for anything. Lots of people went to big tech companies - we may just have lower risk tolerance/entrepreneurialism than Stanford.

The graduate rankings for CS aren’t great, but the CS faculty are teachers first and researchers second; this may be to your advantage as an undergrad who is not eyeing a career in academia.

It has 5500 undergraduates, and until the last 5 years or so, less than 100 of them were CS students. So yeah, you won’t see as many of us out in the world as you will graduates of a school with 25k students.

It’s also a global institution in a cloister 7 miles/45+ CTA minutes from the nearest part of Chicago that white professionals set foot in (extremely segregated city); its effect on the city as a whole is going to be muted. People come from all over the world and then promptly disperse all over the world.

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by CalChris on Friday October 27, 2017 @01:14PM (#15570314)
I finally visited Chicago a few years ago. I probably can't handle your winters but otherwise, it's a great city, accent on city. My brother made sure he shot baskets on Obama's court. I sail, and unfortunately, we (family thing) got there about two weeks before the boats got put into the water; so no beer can racing for me.

I hope Chicago or Saint Louis gets Amazon's second HQ but not at too great a cost.

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by tptacek on Friday October 27, 2017 @11:06AM (#15569073)
It has a CS program, but it's not a great CS program. Aspiring engineers in Chicago tend to go to Champaign or Madison. UIC has a competent, serious research-university engineering program that is adequate to the region but not a standout on the national scale.

(Northwestern, the other top-tier Chicago school, does have an engineering program).

We should probably dispense with the notion that regions "need" engineering schools to feed a tech industry. That is probably not generally how it works. Portland has a thriving tech scene, but not many people travel for engineering school in Portland. Boston has world-class engineering schools, and an anemic tech scene.

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by tptacek on Saturday October 28, 2017 @04:55PM (#15576730)
I drove 'wglb to our Matasano reunion (which is amazing) yesterday night and he pointed out to me that UChicago has a seriously excellent theoretical computer science department; it's just not as competitive a applied science program.
Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by CalChris on Friday October 27, 2017 @01:09PM (#15570265)
My brother got his PhD in physics at Champaign. And of course, Chris Lattner did LLVM at Champaign (and then came to SV). Good school.
Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by wolf550e on Saturday October 28, 2017 @09:43AM (#15575110)
UIUC has a strong and famous CS department: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Department_of_Computer_Science...
Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by pcwalton on Friday October 27, 2017 @03:00PM (#15571207)
I graduated from University of Chicago. I'm here :)
Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by whatyoucantsay on Sunday October 29, 2017 @12:30PM (#15579920)
Chicago is amongst the bloodiest cities in the developed world. Last year over 700 people were murdered and over 3,000 were shot in Chicago. Most cases are never resolved.

In contrast, the entirety of Canada has about 500-600 homicides per year.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_in_Chicago#Murder_and_sh...

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by kodt on Thursday October 26, 2017 @02:48PM (#15561825)
>You can get a nice house for less than 200k

Gonna need a source on that one

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by arkem on Thursday October 26, 2017 @03:12PM (#15562049)
Doesn't seem too far fetched[1] if you read it as a nice house under 200k within an hour of Chicago.

I don't know enough about Chicago to know exactly how far our an hour's drive is or to know exactly what 'nice' means in this context but it seems like there are areas where the median price is quite a bit lower than 200k.

[1] https://www.trulia.com/local/chicago-il/type:home_prices_sal...

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by tptacek on Friday October 27, 2017 @11:07AM (#15569095)
Those are not generally places where a tech worker is going to buy a house. Let's just stick with "housing in Chicago is significantly cheaper than housing in SFBA or NYC".
Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by ryuker16 on Thursday October 26, 2017 @08:36PM (#15564579)
I work in tech here and I suspect it's becuase our early heavy hitters feel from grace: Motorola, Groupon, etc.

Imagine if Motorola was first to have a major smart phone get popular like the razr instead of Apple.

Seatlle has amazon and microsoft.....chicago has nothing comparable I think.

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by acchow on Thursday October 26, 2017 @03:01PM (#15561959)
> apartment rent is around 600 - 1000 a month

You can't really use this as an "advantage" since it disappears rapidly once it starts become a tech hub.

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by tptacek on Friday October 27, 2017 @10:59AM (#15569008)
It is extremely unlikely that any amount of tech investment in Chicago would make 1000/mo apartments hard to find. Chicago is enormous, and has underinvested, relatively low-density neighborhoods stretching for multiples of the dimensions of San Francisco.

Logan Square apartments would get more expensive, but the market would respond to that the way it did with Lincoln Park, Wicker Park, Bucktown, and Ukranian Village: by gentrifying westward into Humboldt Park, Hermosa, and Belmont-Cragin.

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by ryuker16 on Thursday October 26, 2017 @08:40PM (#15564595)
We have a lot of excess housing stock from the rust belt days and can build a lot more towers(not sitting on fault lines).
Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by patio11 on Friday October 27, 2017 @11:31AM (#15569360)
Tokyo waves hello and says, in a friendly but firm tone of voice, that the decision to not built up is political and not based on earthquake-resistant buildings being an engineering technology humanity lacks access to.
Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by Eire_Banshee on Thursday October 26, 2017 @03:07PM (#15562012)
Meh, it doesn't have the geographic limits that you get on the coast. The only geographical feature hemming in the city is the lake. You have essentially unlimited space to expand in all other directions. It would be hard to get skyrocketing rents outside of the immediate downtown area.

But mostly Chicago just sucks. Its all the shitty parts of the midwest without any of the good ones. What you really want is Indianapolis, Columbus, Minneapolis, Louisville, etc...

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by rayiner on Thursday October 26, 2017 @03:13PM (#15562065)
> But mostly Chicago just sucks. Its all the shitty parts of the midwest without any of the good ones. What you really want is Indianapolis, Columbus, Minneapolis, Louisville, etc...

Shameful Indianapolis trolling.

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by Eire_Banshee on Thursday October 26, 2017 @03:22PM (#15562142)
I stand by what I said.
Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by justin66 on Friday October 27, 2017 @01:18AM (#15565888)
> What you really want is Indianapolis, Columbus, Minneapolis, Louisville, etc...

There's something you don't hear every day.

Re:Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech... by jtmcmc on Thursday October 26, 2017 @02:46PM (#15561802)
terrible weather? lack of real feeder schools for tech entrepreneurialism ?