Re:Does the appendix serve a purpose in any animal? (2001)
by Lordarminius on Thursday October 26, 2017 @11:40AM
(#15559887)
>
From a structure-function perspective, the human vermiform appendix is simpy the terminus of the tiniae coli ...
Are you an anatomist/pathologist ? Your post brings back memories of my med school years :) I tend to agree with you - the appendix may be a vestigial organ in the sense that it has a common derivation and serves an immunologic purpose in evolutionary relatives, but we can posit that it may never have done so in man
Re:Does the appendix serve a purpose in any animal? (2001)
by AstralStorm on Thursday October 26, 2017 @12:13PM
(#15560222)
You cam posit so and you would be very wrong. See first reply.
Also look up side effects of appendectomy on pubmed to see what functions it has.
Re:Does the appendix serve a purpose in any animal? (2001)
by mywittyname on Thursday October 26, 2017 @03:30PM
(#15562206)
Care to provide a link? I did a search but the only results I found specified stump appendicitis (infection of any leftover bits) and bowel obstructions.
Re:Does the appendix serve a purpose in any animal? (2001)
by killjoywashere on Thursday October 26, 2017 @01:39PM
(#15561188)
Pathologist.
At a histologic level, there is nothing special about the appendix. The cell types in the appendix are found throughout the colon: colonic epithelium, smooth muscle, lymphoid tissue, vessels, nerves.
I think the term "vestigal" is being misinterpreted by many as a suggestion that it had some more important function earlier in evolution. I rather doubt it. They assert that an appendix hasn't been described in some species. Ok, but have you positively described the absence of tiniae coli as well?
The association with the Bursa of Fabricius may hold water, because the bursa apparently develops from the avian hindgut, however, unlike birds, when we amputate the appendix of a baby human, it doesn't develop an immune deficiency. Also, the bursa seems to be further down the gut than that appendix, although I have not done a careful examination.