News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by TAForObvReasons on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:17PM (#15553769)
Side projects are for software what a portfolio is for other creative industries. You don't hire a designer sight unseen -- usually you ask for a sample. It makes perfect sense to expect the same of technology.
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by sidlls on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:20PM (#15553807)
Only if you believe software development is neither engineering nor science, and is purely creative.

It isn't, though, and demanding a portfolio is almost as terrible a practice as Cracking the Coding Interview style interviews.

Re:I have no side code projects to show you by kodablah on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:27PM (#15553879)
> Only if you believe software development is neither engineering nor science, and is purely creative.

I have to believe it "is neither engineering nor science, and is purely creative"? Only those extremes? I believe it is some of all 3 and I don't think requesting (i.e. not "demanding") a portfolio or prior work is any more unreasonable than not asking for it.

Re:I have no side code projects to show you by sidlls on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:31PM (#15553922)
Fine, then you must believe it's mostly creative. Far more than you think it's engineering or science. Otherwise a portfolio would simply be at best an interesting conversation piece and not at all indicative of ability.
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by detaro on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:33PM (#15553957)
Why do you think a portfolio can't tell you about someones engineering abilities? Can engineering not be judged by looking at source (and potentially surrounding documents)? What would be missing for you to do that?
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by TAForObvReasons on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:34PM (#15553967)
In traditional engineering disciplines like civil engineering, organizing bodies and licensure communicate competency, applicability, and ethical awareness. Software development has no industry-wide equivalent. There are small certifications for Cisco et al but for the general practice there's no standard.
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by vonmoltke on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @07:39PM (#15555244)
This frequently comes up in discussions like this. Licensure is a joke with respect to demonstrating competency. Yes, the initial hurdle is high. However, once you are licensed it's hard to lose it. I would never rely on licensure as a measure of competency or currency.

On top of that, many electrical and mechanical engineers are not licensed because they don't need to be. (Everybody likes to jump to the civils in these discussions and forget about us, since civils are basically required to be licensed.). EEs and MEs don't get put through the same bullshit that this industry puts developers through.

Re:I have no side code projects to show you by sidlls on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:39PM (#15554037)
This is true, and I regard that as a reflection of the immaturity of this industry.
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by Jach on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:14PM (#15554336)
I hear this a lot but I think it's deeper than that, such that letting the industry age isn't going to lead to the same end. The issue is the very one that is in this thread: programming is at a weird intersection between art, science, math, and engineering. Credentials and licensing matter a lot less than simple output. You can gain a ton of experience in the field even if you're stranded on an island with no internet and just a solar powered laptop capable of executing new code. Even without a computer you can still work like a mathematician and propose problems, even creative problems with no engineering applications, and then solve by coming up with and writing down algorithms for a computer you don't have. You can imagine arbitrary business details that get in the way of a clean program and force you to start thinking in architecture and system design.

Demanding a portfolio isn't a great hiring strategy simply because a lot of people's best work isn't out in the open. Who would demand a portfolio from someone like Mike Acton? It'd be enough to know what he's worked on and talk to him. And at the same time requiring a licensing proxy is no help either, he never went to college AFAIK and that'd probably be a minimum requirement for most actual licensing proposals.

Re:I have no side code projects to show you by web007 on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:42PM (#15554062)
Software development is all of those things. You need the engineering experience to know what to do. You need the science to know ways to / not to do things. And you need the creativity to put them together.

Is your "portfolio piece" spaghetti code or well-thought-out modules? Is it doing something recursively that shouldn't be? Do you have elegant code or brute-force solutions? Is it write-only?

All of these can be seen in a portfolio or side project if you choose to look.

Re:I have no side code projects to show you by dozzie on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @06:58PM (#15555017)
> Only if you believe software development is neither engineering nor science, and is purely creative.

It's certainly not a science, and it's very rarely engineering. About the creativity, it's a craft. There is some creativity baked in, but about the same amount as for mechanics or carpentry.

Re:I have no side code projects to show you by TheSpiceIsLife on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @07:00PM (#15555025)
Maybe software development should be considered a trade?
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by dozzie on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @07:26PM (#15555173)
Certainly. And it should be taught like trades were for centuries: with apprenticeships.
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by bad_user on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:43PM (#15554084)
Architecture isn't purely creative either, having overlap with engineering. You ask architects for a portfolio too.
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by sidlls on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:51PM (#15554140)
That's more like asking them for a resume. A portfolio of side projects isn't remotely the same thing.
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by vacri on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:35PM (#15554485)
Software development is a craft, not fully art and not fully engineering. It definitely is not science.
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by ng12 on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:32PM (#15553945)
I can take a 10 minute look at a designer's portfolio and get reasonably accurate insight into their style and abilities.

Do you think a 10 minute scan of an arbitrary GitHub account is the same? I say decidedly not.

Re:I have no side code projects to show you by southphillyman on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:43PM (#15554080)
This is what I don't get about this requirement. I guess you can quickly see if a developer uses design patterns, writes tests and how easy the code is to understand. I don't think that's necessarily mind blowing though and you could still get stuck with an individual who checks all those boxes and still sucks.
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by jhummel on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:12PM (#15554318)
You are thinking about this in terms of one applicant. When you get 200 applications it's very useful to be able to quickly weed out people who are obviously not a fit.
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by delphinius81 on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @07:20PM (#15555138)
You can also just throw out applicant number 26 and up. You most likely have a few solid candidates in the first 25 worth a phone call. And if not, look at 26 through 50. No reason to look through all 200 at once.
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by always_good on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:01PM (#15554230)
I don't see why it needs to be a silver bullet.

For example, an applicant that goes through the trouble of writing a thoughtful, reasonable README for every one of their projects signals a positive quality.

When comparing two candidates, that's certainly something to consider.

Re:I have no side code projects to show you by notzorbo3 on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:39PM (#15554028)
Why not? Can you elaborate? Because 10 minutes with a Github account is enough for me to decide whether I'd hire someone or not.
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by sotojuan on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:58PM (#15554206)
Why? A lot of people (if not most) treat their non-work GitHub as a place to host random experiments and projects. Unless one plans to publish projects for others to use, no one should be forced to have perfect code for a one off idea if they don't want to.

There are a lot of great engineers with empty or "bad" Github profiles.

Re:I have no side code projects to show you by notzorbo3 on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:05PM (#15554261)
When I look at a developer's Github profile I know that:

1. They care enough to have a Github profile

2. I can see their actual interests.

3. I know they're interested in random experiments

4. I can see if and how they treat their projects. Are they dedicated maintainers, or do they just fire off one-shot projects without ever deciding to maintain them?

And a whole lot more. A person who maintains a single shell script project with diligence is worth more to me than a thousand developers with bullshit lisp and haskell repositories.

Yes, there's a bunch of great engineers with empty or bad github profiles out there. But those engineers aren't showing me that they're great engineers. The ones with a single or few well-maintained projects do.

Re:I have no side code projects to show you by hackinthebochs on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @07:25PM (#15555168)
I highly doubt there's any reliable signal in any of these points. Someone is only going to maintain a shell script if it has users or it continues to be useful to them. But that fact is not significant regarding ability to deliver quality code. Not maintaining a project on github simply signals that the code isn't useful enough to anyone to maintain it.

Many people have their favored hiring "hacks", and they almost never actually signal for the things they purport to. It's way too easy to fall into confirmation bias or overstate one's ability to judge others.

Re:I have no side code projects to show you by sotojuan on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:13PM (#15554331)
That's fair, thanks for explaining. To me it's fine to treat it as a huge bonus if the engineer can maintain a long lasting project with diligence.

I just know a lot of people find side projects fun because they can let loose a bit and try out random stuff that may not be their "best" code.

Re:I have no side code projects to show you by notzorbo3 on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:21PM (#15554387)
>I just know a lot of people find side projects fun because they can let loose a bit and try out random stuff that may not be their "best" code.

This is still a huge asset. It's important for a person to want to grow and learn new stuff. When it comes to hiring a person, there's a whole lot of stuff that's important. Maintaining a long lasting project is one of them. Having an interested in fun side projects, also. It doesn't have to be good code. In fact, I have my fair share of "this project is not maintained and should not be used in production code" repositories. That's just shorthand for "this code sucks".

Re:I have no side code projects to show you by ryandrake on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @11:26PM (#15556140)
It's funny to see all these comments about people's side projects being "loose" and "experimental". I have a few side projects, and they tend to be very clean, well-organized, polished, because code that you write professionally for a company tends to end up being the opposite: rushed, hacked together because deadlines, full of compromises, and littered with legacy crap that the business can't get rid of.
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by watwut on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:31PM (#15554465)
Just out of curiosity, how many hours a week all the people you hired worked for their previous employers and for how long?
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by ng12 on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:52PM (#15554158)
I mean, what am I supposed to look at? Unless it's obviously poorly written (e.g. no consistent style) how do you judge it?

Perhaps more tellingly I've interviewed people with seemingly impressive GitHub accounts who were just terrible. That experience leads me to believe it's easy to set up a GitHub that "looks good" without having the chops to back it up.

Re:I have no side code projects to show you by oldboyFX on Thursday October 26, 2017 @06:17AM (#15557641)
> I can take a 10 minute look at a designer's portfolio and get reasonably accurate insight into their style and abilities.

You can't because design isn't about style, it's not art. It's about solving problems and increasing your employers profit.

Re:I have no side code projects to show you by pjc50 on Thursday October 26, 2017 @05:13AM (#15557422)
Normally people's portfolio would include their actual commercial work; it's just the way copyright has turned out in software means we can't do that.

Perhaps the best solution would be a unionized right to proper credit to developers like in the film industry.

Re:I have no side code projects to show you by walshemj on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:32PM (#15553946)
But creatives are allowed to put work done for others on their show real this is not true for professional jobs
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by pault on Thursday October 26, 2017 @09:19AM (#15558522)
I agree, but the problem with this is that visual design is publicly available, and most professional code is locked behind IP and copyright laws. I can't bring my employer's code base to an interview with another company without risking a heap of legal trouble.
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by hughes on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:31PM (#15553935)
What if we consider software candidates like tradespeople? How do electricians and welders demonstrate their ability in an interview?
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by TAForObvReasons on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:36PM (#15553986)
For electricians and welders, there are licenses / certification. Obtaining the license / certification demonstrates the baseline competency
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by ketzu on Thursday October 26, 2017 @02:23AM (#15556806)
Isn't this like a college degree?
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by ztoben on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:37PM (#15554005)
Work history, references, general questions and maybe some whiteboarding. Honestly just a regular interview.
Re:I have no side code projects to show you by weberc2 on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:48PM (#15554120)
Software development is certainly more creative than electrical or welding work, and thus certifications are more meaningful. In software engineering, what certifications you have or what languages you're familiar with is a comparably poor predictor of your success on a given project.