And while you're at it: have you ever written code that switched stacks? You might have had to if you wrote a userland threading library, or if you wrote an exception handling system, or a coroutine library. This stuff you're critiquing this guy on the Cygwin list about: are you an expert?
I saw your Reddit comments; I believe you're a competent WinAPI C programmer. What I want to know is, do you actually know assembly? Or just have a lot of opinions about it?
You can insist until your face turns blue that you've never seen a stack segment register changed. The fact remains the Intel standard reference states that the stack segment register can be changed and is used in stack operations. The difference between you and me is that I code defensively to handle the published standard contract so as not to worry about some corner cases coming up in some compiler implementation while you ignore the published standard and base decision solely on what you have seen. That's fine, to each their own. I just find the cavalier attitude surprising coming from a supposed security expert.
It's obvious that you don't have anything constructive to say and arguing purely for argument sake. That's the end of this discussion.
I'm convinced you can code, but I'm equally convinced that you had no business berating someone else for asking questions about how Cygwin handles its stack, because you don't know either. Don't pile on to people.
I specifically wrote the return address of main() was messed up in his code and that was what not working. Please point out what is wrong with that assessment. You are bringing up far fetched ideas and arguments that I didn't mention. Stop putting words in my mouth.
Ok, I made a mistake with the register name. It's ESS:ESP instead of EBP:ESP. I meant he forgot to set up the stack segment register. The stack segment is most likely different from the heap segment. Switching the ESP but not the ESS is asking for trouble.
I will NOT tell you how to implement a portable native-stack. That's not my intention. What I have done is pointing out exactly what were not working in his code. You are the one failing on reading comprehension and making wild assumption and arguing in different directions.