News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Q&A: Douglas Hofstadter on why AI is far from intelligent by justinpombrio on Sunday October 22, 2017 @01:07AM (#15525248)
> My counter-hypothesis is this: Computers, compared to humans, will always be more data-hungry (i.e. worse at making general decisions without huge amounts of data) and more data-capable (i.e. better at making decisions with it).

Counterexample:

AlphaGo Zero is currently the best Go player in the world. (It beat AlphaGo, and AlphaGo beat humans.) AlphaGo Zero learned to play Go entirely by playing itself; it was given no training set at all.

Re:Q&A: Douglas Hofstadter on why AI is far from intelligent by k_sh on Sunday October 22, 2017 @03:23AM (#15525600)
It's still more data-hungry, though. AlphaGo can play many millions of rounds against itself in the time it takes a human to play one round.

Humans are many magnitudes more efficient at improving a skill, computers just appear to do it better sometimes because they can move faster.

Re:Q&A: Douglas Hofstadter on why AI is far from intelligent by jdietrich on Sunday October 22, 2017 @03:48AM (#15525664)
>Humans are many magnitudes more efficient at improving a skill

In the case of go, most definitely not. AlphaGo Zero achieved world-beating performance in just three days, running on four TPUs. Becoming a world class player cost somewhere in the region of 150kWh.

A fairly sedentary human requires about 2.5kWh of food per day. Achieving mastery of go takes at least 10 years of full-time study, so we're looking at a bare minimum of ~9000kWh. That excludes the energy inputs to make that food (often orders of magnitude higher) and the multitude of other energy inputs required to keep a human being healthy and sane.