News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by eljimmy on Thursday October 19, 2017 @11:05AM (#15508520)
You're looking at the features rather than the true value of these apps, the users. Snapchat has the biggest reach into the most impressionable market, teenagers. That's why it is valuable.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by azernik on Thursday October 19, 2017 @11:17AM (#15508617)
That's actually kind of grandparent's point - if your only "innovation" is managing to market to a slightly different set of users, you have no moat, and a big company with some engineer-hours to spend can duplicate what you've done for every market segment you haven't reached yet.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by libraryatnight on Thursday October 19, 2017 @12:29PM (#15509321)
My interactions with teenagers makes me wonder though if Snapchat actually has a reach into that market. Right now their reach is providing a tool that teenagers enjoy, mostly because things disappear and their parents don't see it. As soon as they start to attempt to leverage that reach in anyway that seems obvious, or if that reach infringes on the core experience, I'll bet they're on to the next thing and we're left with something else that was once valuable "because of the users!"
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by riot504 on Thursday October 19, 2017 @12:07PM (#15509107)
Snapchat is valuable from a monetary perspective, but actual real value is little to none. No one is going in 10 years will say Snapchat changed our lives or progressed society's knowledge. People will look back wondering why it made a handful people beyond wealthy.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by srtjstjsj on Thursday October 19, 2017 @04:55PM (#15511478)
no one forces people to use snapchat. people use it because it adds value. maybe it's not better than AIM or whatever, but it is still valuable.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by Retric on Thursday October 19, 2017 @05:15PM (#15511614)
Considering AIM just got shut down, that's a rather poor long term outlook.

Which I think is the point. To be a new billion dollar company (vs pump and dump) you need to either make 100's of millions in profit for a few short, but profitable years. Or, have steady profits and steady growth over a very long time scale.

Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by s73ver_ on Thursday October 19, 2017 @12:33PM (#15509350)
Yeah, but to be honest, that's true of the vast majority of companies, tech or non.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by alexanderstears on Thursday October 19, 2017 @04:35PM (#15511340)
You're not wrong, but the 'frightful 5' were all transformative for society. The point is that the big companies quash non-transformative small companies.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by riot504 on Thursday October 19, 2017 @05:25PM (#15511677)
True, but the vast majority of small companies (~24 for Snapchat) don't make people multi-millionaires by providing so little to society.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by smsm42 on Thursday October 19, 2017 @12:49PM (#15509471)
Teenagers grow up, and the next crop of teenagers would use not Snapchat but QuickBlah or FastYap or something else. There is no inherent advantage to Snapchat, it's just luck that they happened to be the one there. It's like finding a suitcase with money on the street - valuable, but not sustainable.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by nerpderp83 on Thursday October 19, 2017 @02:39PM (#15510447)
Where can I get in on FastYap? Does it also have a coin?
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by sogen on Thursday October 19, 2017 @05:56PM (#15511874)
let me show you the ICO whitepaper, done in LaTeX
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by code_sloth on Thursday October 19, 2017 @11:29AM (#15508729)
The same teenagers also don't have much spending power now. And besides, teen trends change pretty quickly, so their main targets are teens it does not bode well.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by eljimmy on Thursday October 19, 2017 @12:47PM (#15509450)
Well, as these teenagers grow older, their market segment then becomes young adults.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by usrusr on Thursday October 19, 2017 @05:19PM (#15511637)
That is the key transition. Once they start greying, users will perceive any new platform as unwelcome change. But until then, you have to eventually give them better reasons for staying than just "this is younger and wilder than that other thing".

Facebook's ticket for growing up in lockstep with their core user generation was coordination and communication for loosely coupled groups with some real life connection. People who move into a new development, the "parent cohort" around a daycare class, new hires who joined a company at roughly the same time and so on. All that is young adult stuff that fits well with what Facebook offers.

Nonpermanent asynchronous video messaging? If interpersonal exchange is always a blend between information propagation and entertainment, Snapchat seems dangerously lopsided towards entertainment. That is good for getting people excited (quick growth), but probably not so good for long term retention. MySpace was similar.

Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by avip on Thursday October 19, 2017 @02:06PM (#15510131)
Sonar and YikYak also had lots of users. Until one day they didn't. I think op is spot on - snapchat is destined to end in the same list.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by eljimmy on Thursday October 19, 2017 @05:32PM (#15511714)
YikYak was a bit different in that it was anonymous (initially). When you don't know anything about your users, it must be tough to monetize them.

They had a really rapid decline, eh?

Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by rhizome on Thursday October 19, 2017 @11:59AM (#15509025)
That's why it is valuable.

Changing "impressionable" to "manipulable" makes this point clearer.