Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by detaro on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @08:37AM
(#15498609)
Kind of, but if that's the form factor you want there isn't much in the way of alternatives as far as I know. (small tablet + external keyboard + one of those projects to run GNU/Linux userland on Android?)
And the linked sale price is 433 € with shipping to Germany from a location inside the EU (so no import duty), that's a bit better than your quoted price.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by dspillett on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @08:53AM
(#15498712)
Probably, but there is probably a market for it still.
Other options could be something like https://uk.gearbest.com/tv-box-mini-pc/pp_372953.html?wid=25 (much cheaper) with a bluetooth keyboard, I've seen people report success with Linux on certain ~7" tables (again much cheaper, just add bt keyboard and case).
If connectivity isn't an issue you don't even need Linux on the device directly: I've RDPd to Windows and SSHed to Linux from my phone before now. I've always got a machine on (or wakeable via WoL) somewhere that I can use. You can do the same from a tablet tethered to a phone. There are X servers for Android too, though I've not tried any of them yet (if I did it would only be to play, in reality if I need anything like that I'm breaking out the laptop or waiting until I have access to something else useful).
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by Zibri on Friday October 20, 2017 @03:40AM
(#15514140)
Not at all! I totally agree with you. There are small notebooks for about 100-200 USD from HP,DELL,LENOVO and a few others..way better than this GPD. And that keyboard is really horrible.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by jbeard4 on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @08:37AM
(#15498608)
I backed this project on Indiegogo, and the Windows 10 unit that I received does not implement sleep correctly, so the battery drains excessively while the unit is suspended with the lid closed. After about a day suspended, the battery is fully drained. This limits its usefulness as a mobile unit, as I have to power off the unit between uses. I emailed GPD support, but did not receive a response. They are a very small company.
Other than that, it's been a pretty nice device for development. One of the nice features is that it's so small, I don't have to stow it during airplane take-off and landing, and can continue programming throughout. The keyboard requires some getting used to, though.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by 0xcde4c3db on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @09:03AM
(#15498775)
> the Windows 10 unit that I received does not implement sleep correctly, so the battery drains excessively while the unit is suspended with the lid closed. After about a day suspended, the battery is fully drained
I saw similar behavior on a Windows 10 tablet recently. I suspect there's some issue between recent Windows 10 builds and the reference firmware for Cherry Trail.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by mmjaa on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @08:51AM
(#15498689)
I had the same issue with mine regarding suspend-mode, but since moving to Linux haven't had an issue with it at all. Great little machine, and wonderful to have a full-blown Linux workstation in this form factor.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by mmjaa on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @08:29AM
(#15498553)
I've been waiting for a Unibody-style Linux workstation since .. well, since the tiBook. And now that there is a viable contender for this space, I'm packing up my MacBook and getting ready to retire it: Linux is finally available on decent hardware.
(That said, I really look forward to the GPD Pocket II, if and when its available .. there are definite improvements that can be made, such as the keyboard layout..)
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by stuaxo on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @09:42AM
(#15499043)
Hopefully that will work out, but it is by the people who did the Spectrum Vega handheld, which has been a debacle.
With any luck the people doing that project didn't syphon the money out, but it's seeming unlikely at this time.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by MrMember on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @09:44AM
(#15499058)
I've been watching progress on the Gemini for a while, I hope they deliver close to what they promised. A full Linux computer in that form factor with a SIM slot that can also dual boot Android is like my dream device.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by mmjaa on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @08:30AM
(#15498559)
The keyboard is .. okay .. it does take some getting used to, and you will be cursing at it for at least a week, but if you get real work done on it you'll get over this issue after a bit of usage. Its really quite viable.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by mmjaa on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @09:49AM
(#15499106)
I have no problems remapping DEL/Backspace (like all keys in Linux - easily remapped) but what really keeps tripping me up is the CAPSLOCK/A situation .. I hope they fix that on the next release.
Over on /r/gpdpocket there is a thread discussing alternative layouts of the keyboard - so its quite possible that this will be community-optimised for the next release.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by digi_owl on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @10:04PM
(#15504947)
A decade ago i would have moved mountains to get hold of one of these, i have owned a eeepc 901, a Nokia 770, and a N800. But these days my first though goes to having to deal with the bikeshedding and musical chairs that is modern day Linux userspace, and can't help thinking it will be a big time sink for little gain...
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by mmjaa on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @08:25AM
(#15498517)
Its a hassle-free operation to install Linux from the provided .iso's, or use the community-provided images, so really .. there is no hassle, as you perceive it.
Linux runs great on it and as of 3 days ago the remaining issues (Wifi/Bluetooth) were resolved.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by wolframio on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @09:08AM
(#15498811)
Rumor is that Windows 10 installations on mobile devices are highly subsidized by Microsoft, which is why WIntel tablets are cheaper compared to same specs android equivalents.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by dharma1 on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @08:15AM
(#15498431)
Pixel C, with a keyboard cover, on paper would be a good device for Linux, it has a Tegra X1 which is a pretty decent SoC with a great GPU. You can even run some basic Tensorflow models on that GPU, it's the same as Jetson TX1.
Nvidia has Linux for Tegra, but not sure if the final hardware enablement was ever done for Pixel C.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by jhongy on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @08:27AM
(#15498530)
Baytrail tablets aren't so bad with Linux now either (they were a right pain when released). My t100ta runs Arch perfectly with everything working (well) other than the camera. It was cheap, the keyboard dock is decent, and it feels like a great natural successor to the original eeePC.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by cujic9 on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @08:00AM
(#15498350)
I've been looking for something like this for a while. The Asus C101 Chromebook with GnuRoot Debian for a chrooted Linux has done a satisfactory job. Small, light, reasonable keyboard, and flips into a tablet.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by mmjaa on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @08:26AM
(#15498523)
It runs Linux great, and is a wonderful device for the Linux user. I have no issues with UbuntuStudio (my distro of choice) on my GPD Pocket, so: no, you're not quite correct.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by mmjaa on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @08:27AM
(#15498529)
Plus, the 'hacked together' version is really just normal Ubuntu with a kernel configuration tweaked specifically for the GPD Pocket, and .. it RUNS GREAT! So, don't worry Linux newbies, this really is a wonderful little pocket Linux workstation ..
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by mmjaa on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @11:07AM
(#15499718)
You're confusing terminology to make it all seem bad and nasty, but really its not: Ubuntu is there, it runs great. Use nexus511's kernel to boot it, get proper support for the GPD Pockets' devices.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by KGIII on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @08:52AM
(#15498698)
Ah, nice. That's why I mentioned that the article indicated that.
I'm actually in the market for a small device that runs Linux and is officially supported. I'm going to head back out on the road and I'm thinking that a smaller device that fits in a backpack would be nice and I generally avoid Windows.
The price isn't too bad. If I lose it, I won't much care. That's a definite bonus. So, this will be on my list. Thanks for correcting the article.
Edit: Just so I know, what criteria are you using for 'official?'
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by otabdeveloper1 on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @09:57AM
(#15499152)
A manufacturer's code dump with patches are not "official images". (If you've ever had a device with such so-called "support" then you already know that these images have critical show-stopping bugs and are unsupported and never updated.)
It's only an "official image" if it comes from Ubuntu's website or from a kernerl compiled from sources from kernel.org.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by mschuster91 on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @07:26AM
(#15498214)
Looks nice - but can it play Youtube without having to close everything else on the system?
I've been badly burned by "netbooks" powered by Atom CPUs... nice battery life but forget opening Facebook or Youtube, and the ultra low screen resolution doesn't help either when web sites are designed for FullHD+ monitors.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by morganvachon on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @07:37AM
(#15498254)
> "Looks nice - but can it play Youtube without having to close everything else on the system? I've been badly burned by "netbooks" powered by Atom CPUs... nice battery life but forget opening Facebook or Youtube"
You should have no issues, the Atom used in these is not your 2010 PIII based Atom, it's a modern part that can handle the modern Web.
> "and the ultra low screen resolution doesn't help either when web sites are designed for FullHD+ monitors."
If 1920x1200 is "ultra low screen resolution" then what do you consider high res? The GPD has higher resolution than my 27" 1080p display, and I have to turn up magnification on that just to be able to read comfortably on most sites.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by opencl on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @07:59AM
(#15498342)
The early Atoms weren't P3 based, they were an original low-power design and actually quite a bit slower than the P3 at similar clockspeeds. Though a lot of the unpleasantness of using those machines was more from the extremely anemic GPU which has also improved considerably since then.
The P3 is slightly faster than the old Atom in spite of the lower clock, and the new one is over 2x as fast single threaded and over 7x as fast multithreaded.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by haikuginger on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @08:28AM
(#15498543)
> Though a lot of the unpleasantness of using those machines was more from the extremely anemic GPU which has also improved considerably since then.
Specifically, the GMA950 that didn't have hardware video decode for H.264, which was already the mainstream choice for any Internet video. Combined with the anemic in-order Bonnell core, it was dead on arrival for most uses involving any sort of video. Some netbooks even came with a separate Broadcom PCIe card whose only purpose was hardware video decode.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by morganvachon on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @11:29PM
(#15505273)
Actually they trace their lineage directly to the PIII. The original Atom was based on the Stealey line, which in turn was based on Pentium M, which in turn was based on the PIII design. Later Atom revisions left that legacy behind and became their own distinct process.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by marvy on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @08:21AM
(#15498486)
According to my calculations, you shouldn't need too much more than 25 to 50% magnification or so. Details and assumptions below:
I don't know how far you sit from the screen, nor which websites you typically visit, but unless I miscalculated, your screen resolution is roughly 82 pixels per inch. I also don't know what OS you run, but at least on Windows, things render by default at 96 pixels per inch. (I've heard that some other systems have smaller text than windows though.) Thus on Windows you should be seeing things about 18% larger than "true" size. (That is, things take up more inches on screen than they would on paper.) This is actually too small: according to this Wikipedia article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dots_per_inch, people read the screen from 30% farther than they read paper. So the DPI should be scaled to compensate. Then you need further fudge factors to account for small font sizes some websites use, and some other stuff I'm too lazy to think about now. But still 25 to 50 percent should do it, I think?
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by Yizahi on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @08:06AM
(#15498380)
Braswell series Atom N3700 that is about the same (only GPU is better there), is adequate for youtube, facebook and other office stuff multitasking. It can even run Visual Studio, but with lags. Most of the slowness in my laptop was from 5400rpm HDD, here SSD will improve things.
Re:Linux on the GPD Pocket 7
by nnq on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @08:54AM
(#15498716)
Why would anyone want a device of such inconvenient size for a human being? This size seems optimized for a falcon (superhuman eyesight) with huge pockets. I thought these were extinct.
You'd want it either <=4.5" so it fits comfy in a normal person's pocket (5" phones are bearable but incredibly annoying), or >=10" to be able to actually see stuff on the screen (ever tried one of those horrible 6-8" tablets?). Heck, even most women's purses can accommodate a 13" device easily...
And the linked sale price is 433 € with shipping to Germany from a location inside the EU (so no import duty), that's a bit better than your quoted price.
(EDIT: adjusted price, didn't update properly)
I still use my stowaway bluetooth keyboard from my palm pilot days. It's still the best external keyboard for its size, AFAICT.
Other options could be something like https://uk.gearbest.com/tv-box-mini-pc/pp_372953.html?wid=25 (much cheaper) with a bluetooth keyboard, I've seen people report success with Linux on certain ~7" tables (again much cheaper, just add bt keyboard and case).
If connectivity isn't an issue you don't even need Linux on the device directly: I've RDPd to Windows and SSHed to Linux from my phone before now. I've always got a machine on (or wakeable via WoL) somewhere that I can use. You can do the same from a tablet tethered to a phone. There are X servers for Android too, though I've not tried any of them yet (if I did it would only be to play, in reality if I need anything like that I'm breaking out the laptop or waiting until I have access to something else useful).
Other than that, it's been a pretty nice device for development. One of the nice features is that it's so small, I don't have to stow it during airplane take-off and landing, and can continue programming throughout. The keyboard requires some getting used to, though.
I saw similar behavior on a Windows 10 tablet recently. I suspect there's some issue between recent Windows 10 builds and the reference firmware for Cherry Trail.
(That said, I really look forward to the GPD Pocket II, if and when its available .. there are definite improvements that can be made, such as the keyboard layout..)
Also, I already have a perfectly working dell xps 13 with linux, so this would really be more of a luxury item.
And the grouped keys is a little hard to get used to.
If they licensed the tech for Psions fold out keyboard for the next version I would probably have to upgrade.
Over on /r/gpdpocket there is a thread discussing alternative layouts of the keyboard - so its quite possible that this will be community-optimised for the next release.
Linux runs great on it and as of 3 days ago the remaining issues (Wifi/Bluetooth) were resolved.
I love my GPD Pocket!
https://www.theverge.com/2014/4/2/5574146/microsoft-making-w...
Nvidia has Linux for Tegra, but not sure if the final hardware enablement was ever done for Pixel C.
There are some companies that sell them, e.g. getdigital:
https://www.getdigital.eu/Key-Sticker-Tux.html
Even my last Dell that came with Linux had a Windows key.
There are some ad-hoc patches made by an anonymous dude on the Internet.
Good luck ever running some other distribution or another kernel version.
(Needless to say, these patches will never be merged into mainline kernels and when the said dude gets bored they will, of course, be abandoned.)
Proof: http://www.gpd.hk/news.asp?id=1519&selectclassid=002002
Don't take everything for granted. It's not because someone writes about something that they have researched the subject.
No. It's an unsupported code dump of patched kernel code: https://github.com/253647445/Pocket-Ubuntu-kernel
Needless to say, nobody is every going to merge or ever update this.
End of problem.
I'm actually in the market for a small device that runs Linux and is officially supported. I'm going to head back out on the road and I'm thinking that a smaller device that fits in a backpack would be nice and I generally avoid Windows.
The price isn't too bad. If I lose it, I won't much care. That's a definite bonus. So, this will be on my list. Thanks for correcting the article.
Edit: Just so I know, what criteria are you using for 'official?'
It's only an "official image" if it comes from Ubuntu's website or from a kernerl compiled from sources from kernel.org.
The only annoying thing is editing some config as the screen is natively a portrait (it is a tablet part).
I've been badly burned by "netbooks" powered by Atom CPUs... nice battery life but forget opening Facebook or Youtube, and the ultra low screen resolution doesn't help either when web sites are designed for FullHD+ monitors.
You should have no issues, the Atom used in these is not your 2010 PIII based Atom, it's a modern part that can handle the modern Web.
> "and the ultra low screen resolution doesn't help either when web sites are designed for FullHD+ monitors."
If 1920x1200 is "ultra low screen resolution" then what do you consider high res? The GPD has higher resolution than my 27" 1080p display, and I have to turn up magnification on that just to be able to read comfortably on most sites.
Here's a benchmark comparison between the Atom used in the EeePC 901 (N270 @ 1.6Ghz), the GPD Pocket (x7-Z8750 @ 1.6Ghz), and a 1.1Ghz P3: https://www.cpubenchmark.net/compare.php?cmp[]=2968&cmp[]=13...
The P3 is slightly faster than the old Atom in spite of the lower clock, and the new one is over 2x as fast single threaded and over 7x as fast multithreaded.
Specifically, the GMA950 that didn't have hardware video decode for H.264, which was already the mainstream choice for any Internet video. Combined with the anemic in-order Bonnell core, it was dead on arrival for most uses involving any sort of video. Some netbooks even came with a separate Broadcom PCIe card whose only purpose was hardware video decode.
I don't know how far you sit from the screen, nor which websites you typically visit, but unless I miscalculated, your screen resolution is roughly 82 pixels per inch. I also don't know what OS you run, but at least on Windows, things render by default at 96 pixels per inch. (I've heard that some other systems have smaller text than windows though.) Thus on Windows you should be seeing things about 18% larger than "true" size. (That is, things take up more inches on screen than they would on paper.) This is actually too small: according to this Wikipedia article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dots_per_inch, people read the screen from 30% farther than they read paper. So the DPI should be scaled to compensate. Then you need further fudge factors to account for small font sizes some websites use, and some other stuff I'm too lazy to think about now. But still 25 to 50 percent should do it, I think?
When I wear contact lenses instead of my glasses, I browse at normal magnification.
Pentium 3? Ew. I thought the Atoms were descendants of the Core2 family.
> If 1920x1200 is "ultra low screen resolution" then what do you consider high res?
You're right - I had overlooked this in the specs and based my judgment on the "screenshot" a bit below...
You'd want it either <=4.5" so it fits comfy in a normal person's pocket (5" phones are bearable but incredibly annoying), or >=10" to be able to actually see stuff on the screen (ever tried one of those horrible 6-8" tablets?). Heck, even most women's purses can accommodate a 13" device easily...
Yep and I loved my nexus 7 and Shield K1, so....
edit: not to mention that most Kindle are at that size too...