News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Opaque and sky high bills are breaking Americans, and our... by sjg007 on Monday October 16, 2017 @02:06PM (#15485330)
Price transparency is basically a red herring.

Prices are largely set by the CMS (medicare and medicaid) and sometimes insurance companies will pay a little bit on top sometimes depending on their clout and competition from other providers / insurers. The hospital counters with the "master charge" sheet which is overinflated fiction. Then they have a giant song and dance negotiating prices / threatening to pull their patients etc... But the bulk of their revenue comes from medicaid/medicare patients so prices basically round down to those reimbursement rates.

Then the ACA keeps costs down by having doctors focus on quality rather than quantity. If patients are readmitted they get dinged on their medicare reimbursement rate. There are also other provisions in there as well to regulate reimbursement rates as well.

The ACA also reduced health care induced bankruptcies. You still may have high premiums but those were addressed by subsidies in many cases. Taking on people with pre-existing conditions was also addressed by subsidies. The expectation is that as these people get healthier, the whole system will eventually converge to a steady state where cost is mostly regulated by the CMS.

If insurers don't want to play ball then the government should just let people buy into medicaid. We already pay medicaid and medicare taxes anyway.

Re:Opaque and sky high bills are breaking Americans, and our... by chimeracoder on Tuesday October 17, 2017 @12:00AM (#15488586)
> But the bulk of their revenue comes from medicaid/medicare patients so prices basically round down to those reimbursement rates.

This is totally wrong. Private insurers reimburse several times what Medicare does. In fact, they're literally required by law to pay more.

Medicare prices are so low that providers can't sustain themselves on Medicare reimbursements alone; the government provides a special subsidy to providers who see a lot of Medicare patients because otherwise they'd operate at a loss.

Re:Opaque and sky high bills are breaking Americans, and our... by sjg007 on Tuesday October 17, 2017 @08:34PM (#15496097)
>This is totally wrong. Private insurers reimburse several times what Medicare does. In fact, they're literally required by law to pay more.

That's not true.

http://money.cnn.com/2014/04/21/news/economy/medicare-doctor...

And check out table 1 in https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5375010/

Re:Opaque and sky high bills are breaking Americans, and our... by chimeracoder on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @11:47AM (#15500124)
> That's not true. http://money.cnn.com/2014/04/21/news/economy/medicare-doctor.... And check out table 1 in https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5375010/

Both of the links you provide corroborate what I said. Mass-market media tends to do a terrible job with reporting nuanced details like the medical billing process (or computer security), but even this watered-down CNN overview notes:

> The differences can be stark. Private insurers allow an average of $1,226 for low-back disc surgery, while Medicare will only permit $654, for instance. And the gap can grow wider depending on where the patient is. In New York, insurers allow $1,352 for a gall bladder removal, compared to $580 for Medicare. Some services are more comparable. For office visits by established patients, for instance, Medicare will allow 92% of what insurers do.

As for Table 1 in the paper you linked, every single city listed there receives less from Medicare than the black-box FAIR estimates. In the case of San Francisco, Medicare basically pays 33% of what the private insurers are estimated to pay.

And that's just tracking Level 3 office visits, which is where the Medicare shortfall is generally the smallest (generalized and routine care).

Re:Opaque and sky high bills are breaking Americans, and our... by MR4D on Monday October 16, 2017 @11:06PM (#15488353)
I’m not sure you understand what a red herring is. If you do, then why do you contradict yourself in the first paragraph?

This post is so misinformed, that I’ll just tackle one: doctors are not incentivized by quality.

“Quality” as defined by the ACA is poorly defined, and half of primary care physicians say the proliferation of quality measures to assess their performance has had a negative effect on quality of care.

http://files.kff.org/attachment/report-primary-care-provider...

The ACA is a horrible piece of legislation, which, while it may have been the best of intentions, certainly has not turned out that way.

Re:Opaque and sky high bills are breaking Americans, and our... by cheald on Monday October 16, 2017 @02:29PM (#15485512)
> The ACA also reduced health care induced bankruptcies.

Do you have a source for this? I actually went looking for this info a while back and couldn't find anything either way. Chapter 7 bankruptcies have declined since 2010, but it's insane to pin that on the ACA given that we were coming out of the Great Recession and we'd had a massive spike of personal bankruptcies as a result. I couldn't find any credible information on the impact of the ACA on medical bankruptcies, and IIRC, personal bankruptcy rates are just now coming back into line with where they were in ~2006 post-BAPCPA.

Re:Opaque and sky high bills are breaking Americans, and our... by sjg007 on Monday October 16, 2017 @02:33PM (#15485549)
Re:Opaque and sky high bills are breaking Americans, and our... by cheald on Monday October 16, 2017 @02:42PM (#15485621)
Yeah, that's the problem, that's some crappy data - it's a whole bunch of correlation, and not a lot of causation. I want to see some actual data that suggests that the cause was the ACA, not a recovering economy post-massive recession.

That article uses two crazy misleading graphs: One starting in 2010 (right after the recession, when personal bankruptcy had just peaked) and one starting in 2006 (right after the passage of BAPCPA). There was a massive dip in personal bankruptcies in 2006 (2.1m filed in 2005 because of people rushing to file in 2005 before BAPCPA, 600k filed in 2006) and a massive spike in bankruptcies during the recession (peaking at 1.6m in 2010).

Using those data as bounds, then suggesting that the ACA and not bankruptcy legislation or the prevailing economic winds are the cause is statistical malpractice.

Re:Opaque and sky high bills are breaking Americans, and our... by sjg007 on Monday October 16, 2017 @02:46PM (#15485662)
Read the primary research papers cited in the article.

https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/2153989/daniel-au...

Re:Opaque and sky high bills are breaking Americans, and our... by cheald on Monday October 16, 2017 @02:56PM (#15485735)
Did you read it? It does quite successfully make the case that Massachusetts' healthcare system has probably improved medical bankruptcy rates. It doesn't make any such claim for the ACA at large. In fact, it possibly suggests the contrary - look at Tables 3 and 4 - their estimation is that overall, the percentage of bankruptcies that are medical in nature has risen, and the distribution of medical bankruptcies in the "basket" jurisdictions - the percentage of bankruptcies reporting medical debt increased sharply post-2010! This paper even specifically calls out the Himmelstein paper (which was broadly used as a justification for the ACA) as having far to broad a definition of medical bankruptcy.

I am very willing to accept that the ACA reduced medical bankruptcy rates (it makes intuitive sense!), but I maintain that there's practically no data that validates the claim, and the way that the statistics are manipulated to support that point via correlative inference makes me especially suspicious that it's not actually happening.

Re:Opaque and sky high bills are breaking Americans, and our... by nickbauman on Monday October 16, 2017 @02:23PM (#15485473)
This is a great summary. Emphasizes changing the incentives in the system is the key. If we incentivize a healthy overall population over fee-for-service quotas we get out of these conflict-of-mission scenarios where the system appears to be about making profits for some actors over everything else.

However, Trump's E.O. to kill the subsidies essentially destroys the ACA completely. We're left with a baroque, Kafkaesque flourish on the status quo before the ACA.

Re:Opaque and sky high bills are breaking Americans, and our... by andrewjl on Monday October 16, 2017 @03:17PM (#15485874)
Wouldn't a good compromise be treating medicare reimbursement rates as price maximums? Since CMS effectively sets the prices by being a monopsony of sorts, codify it into law.
Re:Opaque and sky high bills are breaking Americans, and our... by chimeracoder on Tuesday October 17, 2017 @12:03AM (#15488592)
> Wouldn't a good compromise be treating medicare reimbursement rates as price maximums? Since CMS effectively sets the prices by being a monopsony of sorts, codify it into law.

If we did that, most providers would literally shut down overnight.

A couple of decades ago, there was a whole string of hospital closures because those hospitals saw mostly Medicare patients, and Medicare reimbursements aren't enough to sustain a practice (they're subsidized by private insurance reimbursement rates).

To fix this, Congress forced Medicare to pay an additional stipend to providers who see too many Medicare patients. The reimbursement rates are the same, but they get an extra subsidy, because otherwise they'd go under.

So no, you couldn't do this unless you drastically raised the reimbursement rates first.

Re:Opaque and sky high bills are breaking Americans, and our... by andrewjl on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:45PM (#15554102)
What if CMS works with providers to understand why exactly do their rates not work. Is it a matter of unit economics? That alone cannot explain the cost increases in healthcare costs.

There was a story in New Yorker about a small startup that made a safer syringe, but it did not achieve widespread use to due to obstacles in the hospital procurement process. Makes me wonder if there are other analogous issues that also contribute to the cost increases.

Re:Opaque and sky high bills are breaking Americans, and our... by chimeracoder on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:21PM (#15554385)
> What if CMS works with providers to understand why exactly do their rates not work. Is it a matter of unit economics? That alone cannot explain the cost increases in healthcare costs.

Medicare rates are too low because... they're too low. Assume that a vaccine is sold by manufacturers for $100/unit wholesale. Medicare decides that they will pay providers $93 for every Medicare patient who receives the vaccine from that provider. There's no way to make those numbers work - if you're losing money per unit, you're going to lose money overall.