The issue should be solved now.
Update: managed to get a replacement for mine.
It just shows an error and displays:
> Please contact the team or individual within your organization that issued your current YubiKey.
I contacted Yubico support, and they said this is expected, and I'll have to contact the reseller that sold the key on Amazon.
To quote:
> Thank you for contacting Yubico Support. That was bought through MTRIX GmbH, one of our resellers. They are responsible for replacement of all devices bought through them as part of the reseller agreement. You will need to contact them for the replacement process.
Now I'm stuck with a Yubikey that's insecure, and replacement will take ages to get through.
So my key was eligible for the coupon and I got full $40 off and free shipping from Yubico store just a moment ago.
[1] https://www.amazon.co.uk/s?merchant=A2Z7AQ6XNQ4XXH&fallThrou...
Yubico told me:
> Thank you for contacting Yubico Support. That was bought through MTRIX GmbH, one of our resellers. They are responsible for replacement of all devices bought through them as part of the reseller agreement. You will need to contact them for the replacement process.
That's what happened to me, and it's infuriating.
It's not made clear at all how you have to handle RMA in such cases, and customers end up confused. I'd never have bought a Yubikey this way if I had known about the RMA and replacement procedure beforehand.
It kind of makes sense to have as few trust points involved as possible when buying a security device like this.
One could argue yubicon should only sell directly, but that would probably hurt business.
As Amazon tends to intermingle supply from different resellers for Fulfillment by Amazon products, you might have a Yubikey whose Serial No is registered to a different reseller than the one you paid - as result, replacement is going to be complicated.
EDIT: Here the message the Yubico website displays: https://i.imgur.com/FVINcQB.jpg, and the response from the support: https://i.imgur.com/it8zxgp.png
Now I'm left with a Yubikey that's produces broken RSA keys, and Yubico refuses to take responsibility.