It says on the page and order form who you’re buying from. The problem is that reseller agreement not being public — normally the products are the same across sellers but in this case there’s a big difference in what you’re getting.
That information isn't always accurate, but that's not even that relevant here.
It's not made clear at all how you have to handle RMA in such cases, and customers end up confused. I'd never have bought a Yubikey this way if I had known about the RMA and replacement procedure beforehand.
Lesson being buy directly from yubicon.
It kind of makes sense to have as few trust points involved as possible when buying a security device like this.
One could argue yubicon should only sell directly, but that would probably hurt business.
That's what happened to me, and it's infuriating.