Re:Rv8: a high performance RISC-V to x86 binary translator [...
by dmitrygr on Sunday October 15, 2017 @01:30PM
(#15478077)
But...why? X86 to riscv could at least be claimed to be useful (run legacy soft). There is ZERO riscv software at all (and thus zero closed source riscv software).
Re:Rv8: a high performance RISC-V to x86 binary translator [...
by legulere on Sunday October 15, 2017 @01:37PM
(#15478104)
From the introduction:
Given Intel’s and AMD’s access to the latest process nodes, 4+ GHz clock speeds, superscalar execution, several dozen cores and hundreds of GB of memory in a server, a near native speed RISC-V binary translator is likely to be the fastest RISC-V implementation and most practical build environment for things such as operating system distributions for some years to come.
Re:Rv8: a high performance RISC-V to x86 binary translator [...
by adrianmonk on Sunday October 15, 2017 @02:11PM
(#15478288)
They can, but this is more universal.
Also, I could see an argument for it if your build includes automated testing and you want to run your actual binaries (albeit via emulation) in those tests.
Re:Rv8: a high performance RISC-V to x86 binary translator [...
by dmitrygr on Sunday October 15, 2017 @11:24PM
(#15480633)
Well, there are designs that claim to be. They are neither ordereable in quantities of 100,000+ nor do they include any peripherals or even built-in flash.
Re:Rv8: a high performance RISC-V to x86 binary translator [...
by legulere on Monday October 16, 2017 @06:43AM
(#15482259)
That’s a it of a chicken egg problem. Also with ARM64, Linux distributons in the beginning had problems finding fitting server hardware for their build servers.
Re:Rv8: a high performance RISC-V to x86 binary translator [...
by progman on Monday October 16, 2017 @08:45AM
(#15482785)
> There is ZERO riscv software at all
Really? If you mean software for the RISC-V/x86 emulation you are possibly right. Regarding RISC-V in general however your statement is not true.
Fabrice Bellard has published a working Linux on 32/64 bit RISC-V [1]. There is no reason that we could not expect Linux to run on real RISC-V hardware next year on a SiFive Quadcore.
Re:Rv8: a high performance RISC-V to x86 binary translator [...
by snvzz on Sunday October 15, 2017 @02:18PM
(#15478344)
x86 isn't that good. RISC-V has similar code density as amd64 while being fairly simpler.
There's not much appeal to x86 as an ISA, other than for running legacy software.
Re:Rv8: a high performance RISC-V to x86 binary translator [...
by snvzz on Sunday October 15, 2017 @07:43PM
(#15479989)
Most "legacy software" can be rebuilt from source code.
For software where the sources aren't available, there's only a small subset where performance is the main priority. The rest can be handled through emulation.
Given Intel’s and AMD’s access to the latest process nodes, 4+ GHz clock speeds, superscalar execution, several dozen cores and hundreds of GB of memory in a server, a near native speed RISC-V binary translator is likely to be the fastest RISC-V implementation and most practical build environment for things such as operating system distributions for some years to come.
Also, I could see an argument for it if your build includes automated testing and you want to run your actual binaries (albeit via emulation) in those tests.
Exactly. So if you are porting your code to RISC-V don't you want as fast of a simulator as possible?
Really? If you mean software for the RISC-V/x86 emulation you are possibly right. Regarding RISC-V in general however your statement is not true.
Fabrice Bellard has published a working Linux on 32/64 bit RISC-V [1]. There is no reason that we could not expect Linux to run on real RISC-V hardware next year on a SiFive Quadcore.
[1] https://bellard.org/jslinux/