Moreover, I would argue that almost anything you put down on paper as the development process can work if you've got an interested team of skilled people. Such a team will naturally adapt and adjust until they've got something effective, if necessary to the point that the original on-paper idea has all but disappeared if it wasn't helping. That's also essentially the first point of the original Agile Manifesto, though of course it's been happening since long before anyone ever wrote it down and gave it a name.
I'm agreeing with k__ here.
That aside, surely the more interesting scenario is still the reverse of the one you described: can good management leading average developers get better results from those developers by adopting certain working practices?
Which only works as long as you got highly skilled people to start with.