News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open Source Game Clones by pvg on Friday October 13, 2017 @04:21PM (#15468963)
Isn't UE reasonably close to that already for most practical, if not ideological purposes?
Re:Open Source Game Clones by AdmiralAsshat on Friday October 13, 2017 @04:36PM (#15469057)
But that only works if Unity open sources the engine. A ubiquitous engine is not the same as an open engine. The fact that we now have jDoom, Doomsday, and other enhancements to the engine that let us play Doom, Doom2, Hexen, Heretic, etc. only work because id software released the source code. Otherwise, it would be like any other proprietary engine, and we'd have to reverse-engineer it if we want to be able to play those games again.

I'm sure you could argue that Unity is currently more cross-platform than engines were 10-20 years ago and already works on Mac/Win/Linux/Android/whatever, but we can't guarantee it will be around in 20 years.

Re:Open Source Game Clones by mintplant on Friday October 13, 2017 @04:42PM (#15469102)
UE is Unreal Engine, not Unity. Presumably Unreal Engine 4, which gives full source access to anyone who agrees to their EULA and takes patches through GitHub.
Re:Open Source Game Clones by improv32 on Friday October 13, 2017 @04:52PM (#15469151)
I think he meant Unreal Engine, which isn't strictly open source but you get access with a monthly fee
Re:Open Source Game Clones by ReverseCold on Friday October 13, 2017 @05:37PM (#15469394)
There is no monthly fee, they take a % of revenue of whatever game you sell.
Re:Open Source Game Clones by pvg on Friday October 13, 2017 @04:43PM (#15469103)
Oh I meant Unreal, not Unity, should have spelled it out. Unreal source is available.
Re:Open Source Game Clones by em3rgent0rdr on Friday October 13, 2017 @05:19PM (#15469320)
This is why acronyms should be avoided on the internet, unless they are unambiguously unique or presumably understood by any reader.
Re:Open Source Game Clones by pvg on Friday October 13, 2017 @06:32PM (#15469654)
ZOMG, no, IMHO. More seriously, 'UE' is a pretty standard abbreviation in the context. But yes, typing it out would have been better. lol.
Re:Open Source Game Clones by AgentME on Friday October 13, 2017 @10:52PM (#15470418)
Don't people usually end making changes to the Unreal Engine executable and tie their game to it? As far as I know, it's not possible for me to take the Unreal Engine source code, compile it possibly with modifications, and play arbitrary Unreal Engine games with it (like say Gears of War 4).
Re:Open Source Game Clones by badsectoracula on Friday October 13, 2017 @05:23PM (#15469335)
Considering that ideology often comes from practical considerations and that the practical consideration in UE's licensing is that you are still bound to Epic and unable take the code and run with it, then i'd say that no, it isn't reasonably close.
Re:Open Source Game Clones by pvg on Friday October 13, 2017 @06:43PM (#15469693)
unable take the code and run with it

There are really very few practical limits there. You can distribute a game with a modified engine. But what the poster was talking about was a common engine with source that will be around for a long time. UE sounds like a fairly close match. Maybe they had something else in mind but 'the ideological is the practical and vice versa so this ain't nothing' seems more like some sort of odd logical (ideological?) contortion than an argument.

Re:Open Source Game Clones by badsectoracula on Saturday October 14, 2017 @09:44PM (#15475419)
There is the very practical limit of having to pay Epic if what you make with it happens to make you money above some arbitrary point. This introduces additional overhead to your finances - you may think it is justified, but it is still a limit.

Another very practical limit is that you can only distribute changes to the engine through either Epic's marketplace or a fork of their GitHub (so you cannot distribute changes through your own website, for example).

Also you cannot make a modification to the engine itself (even through the "allowed" means) and distribute it yourself as an alternative version/fork of the engine.

Finally, yet another very practical limit, is that you cannot take source code out of the engine for use in other engines and products - no matter what.

All these are practical - not ideological - issues that proper open source projects do not have. Unreal Engine is not open source, you just have access to the engine's source code for minor and project-specific modifications and even that comes with several limitations as i already mentioned above (and there are others tool, just read the engine's EULA).