Re:Plato Would Have Wanted Us to Unplug
by jamesrcole on Thursday October 12, 2017 @09:44PM
(#15462734)
> Obviously having studies is nice, but I feel that this is pretty intuitive
It's more than nice. Studies have shown that many intuitive notions are wrong. So it's really important to test the intuition.
Re:Plato Would Have Wanted Us to Unplug
by AnimalMuppet on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:22PM
(#15462866)
Socrates would want us to not take anyone's word for it, including Socrates'. Plato might want the same.
Obviously having studies is nice, but I feel that this is pretty intuitive (I wonder why/if Dr. Andrew Doan would disagree).
With that said, I think the correct headline would have been "Socrates Would Have Wanted Us to Unplug." And, because it's Socrates we're talking about here, we can't really take him seriously. I'm not sure about him being the Ur-millennial, but he was certainly the Ur-troll. The author herself admits she's being a bit facetious (w.r.t. books), but I think the distinction is important.
> Plato probably would have approved of Waldorf- or oppressive-Religious-homeschooling-style extremism—hell, he kind of invented it—and if we want to follow in his great tradition we should not only ban all screens but also all forms of writing and most literature.
This is really pushing it. Quoting from his "Republic" is kind of iffy because it's hard to tell whether or not the book is meant to be serious, sarcastic, taken literally, or taken in semi-jest. Interpretations vary wildly.
Either way, the article was a great read and I wholeheartedly agree with the conclusion that instead of demonizing substances (or video games), we need to fix the underlying psychological issues.