Done correctly, it’s a synthetic dividend without the immediate tax burden on the shareholders. Those that want to cash out, can sell a portion of their higher priced shares.
To be explicit, there is a decision tree where a company can decide whether to have wages increase or profit, then decide what to do with the profit, and the rise of stock buybacks vs. dividends is an answer to the second question, not the first.
The corporation pays corporate taxes on the money used for the buyback. The investors taxed are avoided because they haven’t realized their gains. When they eventually sell their shares they pay taxes.
In the stepped-up basis case I mentioned, the investor may never pay taxes on the gains.
If you cash out you're still potentially paying taxes on capital gains.
The only way to avoid taxes while still profiting from the increased price of the shares (it seems to me) is to take a loan against your portfolio (possibly deduct that interest) and re-invest the money.
Retail Joe six-pack investor probably won't be able to do that; but it seems like the sort of thing a professional money manager might do?
The article directly addresses this argument. Search it for the word "tax".
I think the claim is that reinvestment causes the company to trickle down wealth to workers more than the alternatives. It's not an absurd claim, though not an obviously true one either.
https://www.wsj.com/amp/articles/amazon-takes-over-the-world...
> Something is deeply amiss when a company can ascend to almost a half trillion dollars in market value—becoming the fifth most valuable firm in the world—without paying any meaningful income tax. Does Amazon really owe so little to support public revenue and public needs? If a giant firm pays less than the average 24% in income taxes that the companies of the S&P 500 pay, it logically means that less-successful firms pay more. In this way, Amazon further adds to the winner-take-all tendencies plaguing our economy.
(I know, I know, "The poor embattled multinationals...")
Companies can also reinvest profits in the business. The textbook example is building more lemonade stands.
A genuine robber baron capitalist who intended to hang onto her own shares long term would generally just shitcan managers who behaved that way. But 401k investors don't have the option.
I'm ignoring workers here. I'm only talking about morality between owners and managers.
The point of the stock market is to efficiently let investors re-deploy capital from mature companies (earned through capital gains and dividends) to growing companies. If all the lemonade stands that need to be built have been built, your research dollars will be less effective than others’, then constraining capital to the incumbents, by dissuading dividends or buybacks, results in (a) bad investments and (b) rent seeking by the agents overseeing this restricted capital.
Edit:
Also, I think there's a bit of funny math here possibly contributing to a misunderstanding when the article says things like this:
> During that period those companies used 54% of their earnings—a total of $2.4 trillion—to buy back their own stock, almost all through purchases on the open market. Dividends absorbed an additional 37% of their earnings. That left very little for investments in productive capabilities or higher incomes for employees.
By definition, wages don't come out of profits. A company could increase wages by $1 billion, have $1 million profit, do a $1 million buyback, and then a journalist could write an article saying "company spends 100% of profit on buyback, giving none of it to workers."
In reality, many companies have a large cash hoard which is not going to employees or investors. Doing a buyback in those circumstances (notable recent examples include Apple and Facebook) doesn't have any effect on employee wages.