News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Seven Deadly Sins of AI Predictions by gharien on Sunday October 08, 2017 @01:53PM (#15429163)
Based on this essay, I don't think the author could accurately summarize the concerns AI researchers actually have. Some of his arguments are irresponsibly lazy. Take the bicentennial straw man, where he accuses researchers of a lack of imagination, and then demonstrates an inability to imagine any of the potential problems while making one long argument from ignorance.
Re:The Seven Deadly Sins of AI Predictions by evgen on Sunday October 08, 2017 @02:23PM (#15429282)
Do you have any idea who Rodney Brooks is? While his arguments may have holes, to claim that he has no idea of "the concerns AI researchers actually have" reveals you to have no clue whatsoever about AI, its history, or current status.
Re:The Seven Deadly Sins of AI Predictions by gharien on Sunday October 08, 2017 @02:29PM (#15429313)
I do know who he is, which is what makes this essay so disappointing, and why I prefaced by saying "Based on this essay". Perhaps my wording could be better- "Based solely on this essay, I wouldn't think..". This is also why I characterize his arguments as irresponsible.
Re:The Seven Deadly Sins of AI Predictions by moxious on Sunday October 08, 2017 @03:37PM (#15429598)
> while making one long argument from ignorance

Ignorance of what? You're saying his argument is lazy and ignorant, but you're not backing that up.

I think he is willfully refusing to "imagine potential problems" - because a core point of the article is that people are "imagining magic", which isn't really an argument, but more of a way of whipping people into an emotional frenzy (all jobs will be taken by robots, dystopian futures, etc)

Re:The Seven Deadly Sins of AI Predictions by gharien on Sunday October 08, 2017 @03:48PM (#15429642)
I'm referring to a specific fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_ignorance, that appeals to our ignorance. Effectively, 'We don't know what the future holds, so we don't need to worry', 'We don't know if superhuman intelligence is even possible, so we don't need to worry', 'We don't know if your prediction will happen, so lets go with mine'.
Re:The Seven Deadly Sins of AI Predictions by goatlover on Monday October 09, 2017 @03:59AM (#15432171)
His argument is that people predicting future superhuman intelligence are failing to imagine what sort of limitations future AI might have. Every technology we've invented has very real limitations. A smart phone would have astounded Newton, but it still doesn't transmute lead into gold. And smart phones exist within a web of similar technologies, which future AI will also exist in.

Brooks is challenging the notion of superhuman AI eating the world without anything limiting it.

Re:The Seven Deadly Sins of AI Predictions by b1daly on Monday October 09, 2017 @04:14AM (#15432227)
That’s an oversimplification of his argument. I interpreted it as him saying that positing a future, superhuman, malevolent, intelligent agent, that we should tremble in fear of, provides no useful line of reasoning that we could pursue to take prudent action to mitigate potential problems.

His obvervation is that the future road to superhuman intelligence will be paved with events, not known to us now, that will provide us with experience to handle the emergence of the malevolent AI.m

This shows that the author is not suggesting that since we can’t foresee the future, we simply should hide our head in the sand, plug our ears, la la la.

On the contrary, he is implying that our normal human tactics of being concerned with the future are more robust than we might fear, and will continue to serve us into the unknown future.

Re:The Seven Deadly Sins of AI Predictions by ryanackley on Sunday October 08, 2017 @02:12PM (#15429234)
I'm curious, is there a good article or source that contains an accurate summarization of concerns that bona fide AI researchers have?
Re:The Seven Deadly Sins of AI Predictions by kryptiskt on Sunday October 08, 2017 @02:19PM (#15429269)
Rodney Brooks is a bona fide AI researcher.
Re:The Seven Deadly Sins of AI Predictions by yazr on Sunday October 08, 2017 @03:12PM (#15429474)
Try Superintelligence - Nick Bostrom (very enjoyable - with a new original thought on every page)

OR

Pedro Domingos, The Master Algorithm (more difficult to read)

Re:The Seven Deadly Sins of AI Predictions by ollin on Sunday October 08, 2017 @04:02PM (#15429709)
Not to be rude, but of the active AI researchers I've seen state an opinion, almost all of them are critical of the Bostrom book, with the main critique being (iirc) that rapid/exponential self improvement is presented as an inevitability when there is very little reason to think that this is the case.

Not to say that Superintelligence isn't worth reading (as you say, it's a pretty enjoyable book), but I think it's important to point out that Bostrom's views are not broadly accepted by the people actually writing ML/AI code.

The primary concerns I've seen from the community are

a) issues with research itself (lots of derivative/incremental/epicycle-adding works with precious few lasting improvements)

b) issues with ethics (ML models propagating bias in their training data; ML models being used to violate privacy/anonymity)

c) issues with public perception/presentation (any ML/AI tech today is usually incredibly specialized, built to solve a single specific problem, but journalists and people pitching AI startups frequently represent AI as general-purpose magic that gains new capabilities with minimal human intervention).

Re:The Seven Deadly Sins of AI Predictions by vacri on Sunday October 08, 2017 @07:14PM (#15430563)
> b) issues with ethics

On a tangent, I've found it an interesting marker if a commentator speaks of the Three Laws of Robotics as if they are part of a solution. We can't even explicitly codify how those laws (ethics) should function for ourselves, let alone put them in as a restriction into a computer system. Whenever I see those mentioned as part of a solution, then I know the commentator really is only thinking of surface issues and 'sci-fi magic' answers.

Re:The Seven Deadly Sins of AI Predictions by ollin on Sunday October 08, 2017 @08:39PM (#15430833)
Yup! To cite some sources:

> Periodic reminder that most of Isaac Asimov's stories were about how the three laws of robotics DON'T ACTUALLY WORK.

(https://twitter.com/grok_/status/904675286230470656 - MIT Research Specialist in Robot Ethics, in the superintelligence-is-in-no-way-a-serious-concern camp)

> It must be emphasized that Asimov wrote fiction...The general consensus seems to be that no set of rules can ever capture every possible situation and that interaction of rules may lead to unforeseen circumstances and undetectable loopholes leading to devastating consequences for humanity

(https://intelligence.org/files/SafetyEngineering.pdf - MIRI, home of Bostrom, Yudkowsky, and other the-superintelligence-control-problem-is-super-important folks)

To the extent that there are sides here, both of them seem strongly in agreement that the Three Laws are a narrative device and not a solution to anything.

Re:The Seven Deadly Sins of AI Predictions by vacri on Sunday October 08, 2017 @07:09PM (#15430551)
Superintelligence is a fearmongering book with little internal consistency. It makes quite a few leaps of logic, and seems to be more about dreaming up doomsday scenarios than thinking about them. About the only realistic scenario is "a super AI controlled by a hostile nation"; all the stuff about turning the Earth into paperclips (or whatever) is just nonsense. It's a "pop science" book.

I did like the 'history' bit at the start, where it mentions the frustrations AI researchers have - every time they reach a goal, it's then labelled "Not AI", and the definition of AI then becomes more complex.

Re:The Seven Deadly Sins of AI Predictions by vadimberman on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:05AM (#15431508)
Enjoyable, maybe. Bostrom as an authority on AI, no.
Re:The Seven Deadly Sins of AI Predictions by evanlivingston on Sunday October 08, 2017 @02:17PM (#15429258)
I think it is a mistake to only focus on the concerns of the researchers and scientists. If you use the atom bomb as an example, the concerns a sociology professor or philosopher had for the bomb might be different than then concerns of a nuclear physcicst, but both were worth paying attention to.
Re:The Seven Deadly Sins of AI Predictions by ryanackley on Sunday October 08, 2017 @02:36PM (#15429350)
The atom bomb was a giant explosion made for killing people. The logical extrapolation is bigger explosions and more death. Doesn't take a lot of smarts to see that.

The current state of AI is some clever algorithms to solve very specific problems. What is being extrapolated from that is everyone losing their job and/or being enslaved by computers. This is the point the author is trying to make. It's basically a form of hysteria.