Re:Chelyabinsk-40 – Russia's other nuclear disaster
by blincoln on Sunday October 08, 2017 @12:04PM
(#15428701)
The same approach was originally used at Hanford in the US.[1]
I've been on a couple of tours at Hanford, and the guides told us that the Soviet weapons programme was a carbon-copy of the one in the US - just scaled up, with many more plutonium-production reactors - so it's not surprising that they made the same mistake about the cooling.
[1] http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2017/ph241/buttinger1/docs... - pages 9-10
Re:Chelyabinsk-40 – Russia's other nuclear disaster
by mikeash on Sunday October 08, 2017 @12:11PM
(#15428729)
My favorite (for certain values of “favorite”) was the British Windscale reactor, which was air cooled and just vented out a big smoke stack. Predictably, it caught fire and turned into a major disaster. One guy’s insistence on installing filters in the chimney, over the objections of many others that it was pointless, prevented it from being a Chernobyl-scale event.
Re:Chelyabinsk-40 – Russia's other nuclear disaster
by mikeash on Sunday October 08, 2017 @11:25AM
(#15428541)
The whole thing is a great lesson in how “obvious” things we take for granted today, like using a sealed cooling system in nuclear reactors, or keeping waste in containers, were ideas that had to be developed through error-prone processes.
Re:Chelyabinsk-40 – Russia's other nuclear disaster
by pvg on Sunday October 08, 2017 @11:47AM
(#15428623)
This wasn't done because the people who built these things didn't know what they were doing and what the consequences were.
Re:Chelyabinsk-40 – Russia's other nuclear disaster
by ams6110 on Sunday October 08, 2017 @03:32PM
(#15429579)
Not credible. The dangers of radiation exposure were fairly well understood. I think it's more like they were under extreme pressure from governent and military interests during the cold war to just "get it done" and safety was a secondary concern.
Especially in the USSR where they were using prison labor for a lot of the nastier work.
Re:Chelyabinsk-40 – Russia's other nuclear disaster
by mikeash on Sunday October 08, 2017 @04:27PM
(#15429840)
The dangers of acute exposure were well understood. The long term consequences much less so, as well as the many ways things could go wrong to cause exposure in the first place.
That era is full of examples of terrible human damage done because people didn’t really get the consequences of pollution. These are mostly special just because the pollution was radioactive
Re:Chelyabinsk-40 – Russia's other nuclear disaster
by pvg on Sunday October 08, 2017 @04:37PM
(#15429882)
The consequences of long-term exposure were also known, perhaps not as well as now, but I think it's inaccurate to suggest this sort of thing was done out of ignorance, rather than expedience (and general disregard for human life). This isn't something like someone eventually noticing DDT was decimating bird populations or that lead from leaded gasoline was getting into everything.
"Initially Mayak was dumping high-level radioactive waste into a nearby river, which flowed to the river Ob, flowing further down to the Arctic Ocean. All six reactors were on Lake Kyzyltash and used an open-cycle cooling system, discharging contaminated water directly back into the lake"
Ouch.