News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Barbarian Virtues by zokier on Friday October 06, 2017 @02:02PM (#15418874)
That is ultimately pretty scathing review. Is the book really just another iteration of the noble savage idea?

I do wonder why this landed on the frontpage, is it because the attractiveness of the basic idea, or because the dialogue here presented some new insight (that I might have missed)?

Re:Barbarian Virtues by steauengeglase on Friday October 06, 2017 @04:35PM (#15420237)
No idea why it was posted. I've only started this one, but what Scott seems to be advocating is essentially Anarcho-syndicalism.

Where Marx said that hunter-gatherers were engaging in Primitive Communism, Scott argues that they were engaging in Political Anarchy. He kinda has a point (at least when you look at hunter-gatherers who are still around 10,000 years later). We just assume that Marx must have been right since he was taking a diagnostic approach, but without archeological, genetic, and anthropological evidence, can we be certain that it was anything other than hypothesis? If Marx was wrong about man's "year zero", what else was he wrong about?

Not that I'm totally on board with Scott and his critique of civilization, but I do think he has some useful views when it comes to pre-history.