Not really, no. It's a paradox if you think a single-minded concentration on grades is the right strategy to rise to the top of a meritocracy. People skills are learned, and that's one of the things organizations like fraternities will teach you.
For those who have committed to the fraternal path, sure.
Then there are those who simply find associating with the Greek community to be morally degenerate...and those who don't have the financial means to satisfy mandatory annual dues...and those who can't reconcile value.
The paperwork has been pretty much irrelevant.
I'm not even sure where my physical diploma is. I'm sure it's in a box somewhere.
We are told or taught that the US is a land of opportunity and meritocracy. One of our great myths is that bloodline doesn't matter. It goes back to our founders and the fact that we fought against a bloodline royalty. This is what I was taught from kindergarten onwards. That america was special and exceptional. We didn't have royalty. Doesn't matter who your father was, we are all "kings" and equal.
But you leave school and join the real world and you realize all of that was nonsense. Your success in life has more to do with who your parents are than anything else.
George Bush with a C average is far better off than the valedictorian.
Ultimately, we aren't as special or different than any other nation.
I think this fact is surprising to most americans because we are taught something entirely different from the first day of school.
As I said, it's entirely possible that tech (or at least the quality of company I've worked at) is something of an anomaly, but I wouldn't be so quick to dismiss it as unrepresentative: it's not controversial at all that the importance of intelligence is rising fairly rapidly in the modern economy and tech may be more representative of the present and future than you'd think at first glance.
I think people are simply conflating GPA and intelligence. This is especially true given the study is from the NE liberal arts schools who funnel into finance regardless of their major. My math/econ double major was completely irrelevant during my 3 month training program where the brightest person in the room was an english lit major.
Yes, this is a very good point that I elided a little in my comment: I actually just wrote a different comment on this post about me not including my GPA on my resume because it reflected the fact that I miscalculated how much I could take on vs my actual intelligence (I ended up with a low-3s GPA and three degrees (all considered fairly challenging) in four years).
But I don't think that, at the population level, it's a conflation to recognize that the _correlation_ between intelligence and GPA (ceterus paribus) is pretty significant. The risk is in reducing the candidate to too few features, but that's not inherent to including the feature in your overall assessment.
Sure, access to the network of peers that comes with elite schools has long been known to be one of the biggest benefits of admission.
But it’s also things like GPA not measuring EQ, or emotional intelligence. One example, at big companies that sell software, who do you think gets paid more (not counting founder status) the most talented and elite engineers, or the the most talented and elite sales people?
Some here don’t realize it’s common for an enterprise sales rep to make more, sometimes way more, than a developer. I don’t know who has higher average GPAs but I’m guessing it’s STEM majors over business administration majors.
EDIT: To clarify this was at a talk to a group of college students - almost exclusively geared towards prospective interns or fresh graduates.
Also this is something I was told by an employee at Google... I don't understand the downvotes. Maybe my wording was harsh... should I have said "seriously decreased chances of selection"?
It's entirely possible that this has changed, but I'd be pretty surprised. Competition for tech talent has heated up A LOT since then, and using transcripts as a blunt instrument to limit your talent pool seems like a move in the wrong direction.
It's also possible (but prob unlikely) that they treat candidates in a more case-by-case fashion, and don't ask for transcripts for certain programs that are well-known to them (I got my degrees at Cal).
[1] I overextended myself in college and ended up with three degrees and a low-3s GPA
It's also possible that they asked for transcripts and you politely declined while I felt it was a non-negotiable request.
Isn’t it obvious why GPA goes down? Social activity sky rockets.
Does anyone seriously advocate getting a high GPA in the US anymore so that you can out-earn your peers?
Does anyone seriously think that the leaders of companies are the studious academic experts in their field of choice?
This is a paradox if you still pretend we live in a hierarchical meritocracy. To a certain point and income level we do; bad grades and no social connections won't help you.
But if you can choose entering a class of rich and powerful people or getting a higher GPA, and your goal is financial reward? Come on now.