I sure as hell would never have enjoyed these games, except maybe Set, as a 5 year-old. My attention span was fit for assembling legos and catching lizards, and a few years later, I became interested in math and programming. Not because my parents foisted them upon me: math because math showed up in school, and I had questions that needed answering; programming because my dad was building a website, and I wanted one too. My siblings took very different paths as well that were similarly organic.
And by accident I transformed a normal interest (games and showing things off) into something that turned out to be useful and insightful to me later.
Perhaps you need to look at more than just metrics of success. South Korea has one of the highest suicide rates in the world, and a lot of this is due to societal pressures like exams and work. While China's done what everyone was skeptical about 20 years ago, it now recognises that there's a dire lack of the "innovative spirit" - which really is part and parcel of being "free spirit".
I do agree that we can't just pander to children's interests only. Still too young, and they need basic education as a foundation. But childhood is also the perfect time to explore as much as possible, and plant those seeds of interest. Go the "Asian" way if you want, but just bear that in mind to strike a fair balance.
[1] https://www.google.com.ar/search?q=asian+mothers+vs+jewish+m...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amy_Chua
[3] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/men/relationships/fatherhood/1066...
I find it interesting to see almost no Sepharad on this list. And that the list exists at all.
>Nobel Prizes have been awarded to 887 individuals, of whom 195 were people of Jewish descent, although people of Jewish descent comprise less than 0.2% of the world's population.
Guessing it's due to upraising among Ashkenazi and strong networks effects.
In retrospect, 3 was a big year for me, haha. I remember going from not being able to read, to my parents finding out that I could read on my own (when they discovered me reading aloud the opening of Legend of Zelda for the NES) to reading proficiently by myself (thanks, Dr. Seuss!)
And at 4, I remember being very surprised when I went to kindergarten, and some of the kids made me read things for them because they couldn’t yet. I thought they must have been joking or making fun of me at first, but it turns out my parents are just great.
I can feel the crooked wooden floorboards under my bony pajama-clad bottom, and the NES controller in my hands with its creaky plastic buttons, and the warmth of the summer afternoon sun, and the vibration of my boy soprano voice reading the text on the screen. I can smell the static of the Sharp CRT television, and my dad’s warm chamois shirt with (I now realise) maybe just a hint of weed on it. And I can hear him standing above me saying “You can read?”
This all goes n-tupley when we consider any individual kid in. In that case you should just see what the kid can do and wants to do for yourself and not bother with what teachers think they are unready for.
We used to start reading in 1st grade when I was a kid. That was 7 years old back then in my country. We learned letters and stuff in kindergarten, but reading was the main task of 1st grade.
My parents decided I was pretty smart so they tried to encourage me to learn how to read sooner than 7.
I vehemently opposed this idea and said that I'm not old enough yet to read and that they should leave me alone and that I will read when it's time to read. I was upset, I think, that people were pushing me to do things beyond my age and it seemed somehow like that was not what I want.
Somehow I was a fluent reader on the first day of 1st grade. I suspect I actually knew how to read before but refused to do it until I was the right age.
I'm not sure what my point was in sharing this story, but here we are.
However, I'm actually impressed that the Math curriculum at schools today is much less narrowly arithmetical, and much in the vein of some of the puzzles mentioned here, in particular the "sets" game.
These games are good ideas, I will definitely try them, at the same time if the kid just isn't into it, no need to give up on them going to college. Let them try something else, or just go outside and play.
0: no ads or anything, this was a "teach myself android" project 1: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.bogus.trio
Wikipedia article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/László_Polgár
Another discussion: http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/05/30/hungarian-education-iii...
I think I was a little slow, or at best normal in picking up reading as a kid. But for whatever reason, by about the age of 8 I was reading well ahead of the rest. So I never read The Cat in the Hat, but I read the The Hobbit long before most kids.
And I'm glad, because that second level is where the real power-tool lies. There's little point reading non-fiction at Cat in the Hat level. But there's plenty of facts available that are simpler to read than The Hobbit.
That isn't to say I didn't learn other stuff: my favorite childhood book was about science. But it had lots of pictures, and when fist got it, my parents read an explained it to me.
I was very happy to read early, and I think it was advantageous for me, but I have not seen evidence that early reading in itself provides any lasting advantages on average. There may be a good deal of heterogeneity in the early-reading population.
When we taught our own kids to read, I was surprised that this was not the way that they would learn to read. We ended up having good success with hooked on phonics with our first two and the last one did well with vast amounts of repetition and memorization of his favorite books.
Not gifted. But definitely curious.
The potential harm is having a kid less eager to try new things because he's afraid of something.
The (minor) failure is still a learning experience, just a moral rather than mathematical one.
I'm just replying to say that if your username is "pervycreeper", you might reconsider whether to weigh in on exposing a child to anything...
I would therefore caution people on two things: (1) your personal memories of early childhood are often quite distorted, and (2) it's not fair to impose upon a child today the expectations that come from your own ego-distorted memory.
This post caught my attention because I happen to be the father of a 5-year old son, and I myself have been searching for interesting mental exercises to share with him.
It's been an exercise for me as much as for him, teaching me about patience and tempered expectations.
Five years is YOUNG. A generation ago, early childhood educators in the U.S. didn't even typically introduce reading until age six. We start reading in kindergarten now, but typical 5-year olds can generally be expected to recognize repetitive words and basic arithmetic concepts (e.g. 1 + 2 = 3). Even that is limited to short periods of study in each sitting.
Children may vary, but I believe that many of the suggestions on that MathOverflow.com page (as well as comments here about chess, etc) would be better suited for around 7-8 and up. I think it would be unrealistic to expect the majority of 5-year olds to handle much of this, and it would be a mistake to push too hard at that age.