It's an ethical failure that this industry has so many examples of above.
Whether or not this information should be collected at all may be a moral question, but how it's secured is about technical competence.
I also think we should keep in mind that, even if it was well-secured, there could have still been a breach. Would that have been less bad? The result would be the same.
No security professional is going to argue that you can or will prevent every vulnerability from being exploited. However, when you leave a critical vulnerability open for months on end, you knowingly and unnecessarily expose yourself, and any parties associated with you (by choice or otherwise), to a level of risk that is unacceptable.
If this were a 0-day exploit, then the conversation would be different. If their exec's hadn't sold off so much stock a such a suspect moment, then the conversation would be different. If the IT department had appropriately began remediating the vulnerability within a respectable timeframe but had already been exploited, then the conversation would be different.
There is, however, a degree of respect for that hazard, demonstrated in concrete safety practices, that can override that presumption.
I don't think Equifax has demonstrated that respect. To a layman's view, not many companies do. It's possible that the amount of respect necessary for a hazard as large as the one Equifax created is too onerous for a for-profit entity to realistically implement, but I don't know that there's a fundamental reason that sufficiently paranoid engineering practices couldn't make this moral.
Would that have been less bad?
Quite plausible yes, with better systems design.You can take proactive efforts to minimize the risk of breaches; they appeared to store large amounts of unencrypted (or encrypted in aggregate) personally identifiably information together and allowed a single struts vulnerability unfettered access.
For instance, one could not duplicate social security numbers, or could allow you to encrypt your data so you need to provide a key for others to access it. The possibilities are endless.
Yes.
As a professional engineer you are responsible for the systems you build and maintain. The security of the modern internet depends on engineers on the ground understanding and proactively fixing security issues.
There is no one else who can take responsiblity for code you deploy to production. The buck stops with you.
I'm not saying that such a model is the right one for devs, but it would certainly be an interesting move away from "not my fault - nobody would let me do it right".
CEOs would, of course, then have the choice to hire non-accredited engineers to work on their software, and then the buck does stop there because they made an active decision.
I would say I'm in a similar position, but that's because I'm more or less essential (no ego here, and can't explain obviously, but I am) and if I walk out, the company has a lot of BFPs to deal with.
Perhaps there should be some sort of guild? Some way that we could make it harder for ourselves to be replaced in such a way where we can actually stop bucks without just getting fired while they find some script kiddie to do what we wouldn't.
I mean how many firms do we read about a DAY on here who are collecting by the truckload consumer data, either to be used or sold later? And how many of said firms are taking proper steps to anonymize or secure (or both) said data properly?
* The executives selling stock before telling the public about the breach[1] — but "Equifax responded to TechCrunch’s questions about the timing of the transactions, particularly those of CFO John Gamble, with the following statement claiming that the executives in question were not aware of the hack which the company was made aware of on July 29"
* entering in phony name into the "Have I been breached?" site resulted in random answers; "Others have tweeted they received different answers after entering the same information."[2]
* Equifax hosted said "Have I been breached?" site, and services related to protecting oneself from the breach, on a domain that looked for all the world like a phishing site, and further, "What’s more, there is nothing tying the domain registration records for trustedidpremier.com to Equifax: The domain is registered to a WHOIS privacy service, which masks information about who really owns the domain (again, not exactly something you might expect from an identity monitoring site)." [4]
* Equifax wanted people to agree to a forced arbitration clause. [3]
* Equifax directed people to a fake phishing site [5]
…that it became a moral failing.
[1]: https://techcrunch.com/2017/09/07/equifax-managers-dumped-st...
[2]: https://techcrunch.com/2017/09/08/psa-no-matter-what-you-wri...
[3]: https://theintercept.com/2017/09/08/equifax-is-proving-why-f...
[4]: https://krebsonsecurity.com/2017/09/equifax-or-equiphish/
[5]: https://www.theverge.com/2017/9/20/16339612/equifax-tweet-wr...
If this Struts vulnerability can lead to the personal information of literally half of America? I'm not a lawyer, but that sounds pretty damn negligent to me.
I agree with your larger point that the system probably shouldn't be built in the first place, at least not the way it is now, but there are still plenty of things they could have done, like not store it in plaintext at rest.
If now somehow the database gets exposed, good luck! You'll also need to get the individual keys to decipher everything.
Then, although still you can be blamed for not using a vulnerability scanner, there is much less at stake.
[1] https://www.compose.com/articles/encrypting-sensitive-data-i...
What part of that doesn't seem like a moral failure?
The elite have this country over a barrel, it sucks. All anyone that isn't rich can do is to choose to die before they will work for these companies.
We've got tons of young men and women that sign up to be in the armed forces who happily go die to enrich the already wealthy...and we celebrate them!
So as a society can we start shaming workers that work for Palanatir, Comcast, Pfizer, Equifax? You being on your death-bed and unable to afford food is not an excuse to make the world worse. Die with some fucking integrity.
The amazing thing about our society is that in most cases, the incentives of individuals are such that even bad people engage in good behavior. You say that businesses and business persons have been making destructive decisions "for decades" but there's definitely a reporting bias there; an overwhelming majority of businesses quietly ship bacon, pack boxes, deliver fertilizer, fold laundry, etc without any moral/shame oversight from senators or society at large. In fact, many of these businesses are likely ran by sonofabitches, but they still engage in good behavior because their incentives are aligned with their consumers.
The problem with Equifax and other headline news behaviors (pollution, bank crashes, etc) is not 'bad people made terrible decisions' but 'bad people had no incentive to make right decisions' because, for example, the credit bureaus are simply not motivated to protect consumer data. Legal and financial incentives are both aligned against consumers, not for them.
It's a little unfair to pile on the CEO of Equifax or the company because that's just fighting yesterday's battle too late. What we should be doing is fixing the incentive structures such that future Equifaxes don't happen.
Also, as other commenters have pointed out, we don't want to discourage good people from running credit bureaus out of fear that innocent mistakes may get them hung.
I couldn't agree more with the rest of your comment, but I draw an almost opposite conclusion.
We should discourage people, good and otherwise, from running credit bureaus. Collecting and holding sensitive personal data on millions of people is inherently a mistake, and after the last few years of data breaches it's getting hard to argue that it's an innocent one.
Companies have proved time and again that they can't be trusted with huge datasets on the general public. They don't have much incentive to apply the level of paranoia necessary to actually protect data that valuable, and even when they do they rarely have the level of InfoSec skills and, more importantly, culture to actually pull it off. In practice we see 2 or 3 nines of reliability when we actually need about 5 nines.
We should stop waiting until leaks happen. Holding sensitive personal data on hundreds of millions of people ought to be congressional hearing level scandalous whether that data has leaked yet or not.
No it's not. He and the CSO are ultimately responsible. That is part of why they get high pay and golden parachutes. That is their job.
Their incentive to make the right decisions is being shown right now via investigations and congressional testimonies which may lead to other charges.
Trump is pushing the GOP tax proposal which has massive tax cuts. Bannon appeases the GOP non-rich voting base with these platitudes.
Trump trusts Bannon (or Bannon would be out of a job), despite any Kardashians-like fake acrimony.
This is just like the pre-election micro-targeting - they are saying whatever message appeals to whoever they talk to.
Bannon _is_ out of his job at the White House.
http://www.newsweek.com/trump-legal-fund-paid-billionaire-ro...
Also, the wife and I were one of the millions whose personal details were stolen from the OMB hack.
We should hold a high standard.
We should not hold a double standard.
The Senators are beating up on this CEO for a security breach that happened under his watch -- suggesting he ought to be fired. For the OMB hack they were the ones with the power to fire the CEO of the organization responsible, i.e. the President. Did even a single one of them call for impeachment? Did any senators resign for thier lack of appropriate oversight?
They attack equifax for having bad security policies and procedures and dismiss the claim that one misfeasant employee is responsible. Well they are the organization largely in charge of writing and overseeing policies and procedures for the federal government. Did they attack themselves for doing a bad job after the OMB hack? Did they change any of those policies and procedures in response?
They are calling on equifax to fully compensate people whose information was released. What laws did they introduce and pass to fully compensate people whose information was lost by the organization they are in charge of?
Technically the identity of the speaker is of no moment, but it's a little hard to avoid rolling ones eyes in the face of such blatant hypocrisy.
Katherine Archuleta was in charge of the OMB during the time of the hack, lawmakers _did_ call for her to be fired, and she ultimately resigned due to the breach.
I think a more appropriate analogy would be that Obama was the "board of directors" of the OPM.
Equifax on the other hand is a complete organization. It has a bunch of different departments that all work together to accomplish the overall goal. Just like OPM, the State Department, and the Treasury all work together to accomplish the overall goal of governing the nation.
Therefore, the proper analogy for Equifax is the USG, not OPM, and the proper analogy for Equifax's CEO is Obama, not Archuleta. The group that is analogous to the Equifax Board of Directors is Congress.
Equifax fits into the relatively tidy box of credit reporting, identity theft protection, and maybe a few other services that I missed. The OPM fits into the relatively tidy box of investigating and managing security clearances, hiring Administrative Law Judges, and maybe a few other services that I missed. I can't even reasonably estimate the number of these services (to the same level of granularity) that the entire USG is responsible for.
Getting rid of the business structure analogy, really I just disagree with the sentiment that Obama should have been fired or pressured to resign over the OPM hack. I don't think there is much to be discussed there, so perhaps we should agree to disagree.
> "This simply is not a company that deserves to be trusted with Americans' personal data," said Sen. Sherrod Brown, D-Ohio,
Obviously this quote leaves out a lot of nuance, but I like it and I like what Senator Brown has said in general. What Equifax has let happen is very bad, and I think moral judgments and perhaps even shame (which is how a society can enforce morality) should be brought onto its leaders individually.
I hate how businesses and business persons have been making horrible, destructive decisions for decades (not that humans in all fields weren’t beforehand) and have been escaping any kind of shame. Indeed they’ve been praised in many cases.
If you look at the top-level pages on Wikipedia (there are about 11 of them), one of them is for “Society”. About a third way down you’ll see “Business” listed under Society. I think this is a good reminder that business is a part of and functions for society, not the other way around.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portal:Contents/Society_and_so...