News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Senator to Ex-CEO: Equifax Can't Be Trusted with American... by trgv on Thursday October 05, 2017 @10:35AM (#15409494)
I don't think this is a moral question.

Whether or not this information should be collected at all may be a moral question, but how it's secured is about technical competence.

I also think we should keep in mind that, even if it was well-secured, there could have still been a breach. Would that have been less bad? The result would be the same.

Re:Senator to Ex-CEO: Equifax Can't Be Trusted with American... by garrettdc on Thursday October 05, 2017 @11:43AM (#15410053)
The moral issue isn't one of technical competence, but rather of having the integrity to perform the appropriate due diligence required of a company handling such sensitive information.

No security professional is going to argue that you can or will prevent every vulnerability from being exploited. However, when you leave a critical vulnerability open for months on end, you knowingly and unnecessarily expose yourself, and any parties associated with you (by choice or otherwise), to a level of risk that is unacceptable.

If this were a 0-day exploit, then the conversation would be different. If their exec's hadn't sold off so much stock a such a suspect moment, then the conversation would be different. If the IT department had appropriately began remediating the vulnerability within a respectable timeframe but had already been exploited, then the conversation would be different.

Re:Senator to Ex-CEO: Equifax Can't Be Trusted with American... by vec on Thursday October 05, 2017 @12:30PM (#15410470)
To my view, collecting and storing that much information is presumptively immoral. It creates a public hazard, in the same vein as stockpiling explosives or toxic chemicals.

There is, however, a degree of respect for that hazard, demonstrated in concrete safety practices, that can override that presumption.

I don't think Equifax has demonstrated that respect. To a layman's view, not many companies do. It's possible that the amount of respect necessary for a hazard as large as the one Equifax created is too onerous for a for-profit entity to realistically implement, but I don't know that there's a fundamental reason that sufficiently paranoid engineering practices couldn't make this moral.

Re:Senator to Ex-CEO: Equifax Can't Be Trusted with American... by ska on Thursday October 05, 2017 @10:55AM (#15409644)

    Would that have been less bad?
Quite plausible yes, with better systems design.