Maybe that's why they will never come up with the next Apple/Google/SpaceX/etc.
Every single MBA I have met, without exception, has been extremely good at talking and making presentations. Ask them to do real work, and they will find a million excuses.
Another thing I have noticed, is the kind of people attracted to doing an MBA. They have seen all of Steve Jobs' talks/speeches, talk incessantly about Brand Building and strategy. Ask them to dial for dollars and you get radio silence.
Maybe we'll meet in the future, but not all developers with MBA's are that bad...
Finding an online MBA offering that is decent quality is next to impossible or the price far exceeds what most people are willing to pay. I've tried some courses from MIT & Wharton online. Their content is great & possibly well worth the price if you are able to relocate & can afford the cost. I would imagine a few of the other top schools are worth it as well. After that, I would seriously question the value from most any other MBA.
On a side note, many people with an MBA often say the most valuable thing they received was a "network".
Elon has categorically stated that MBAs are a bad idea : http://www.aps.org/publications/apsnews/201311/profiles.cfm
At a high level, when a company is bringing in the MBAs, it means they have found their gold mine and the MBAs are being brought in to mine every little cent from it. When this happens, the development priorities change. Your features get chopped up into buckets that the business charges clients more for. A simple, dinky little feature that is probably two lines of code gets walled off from those users so we can charge these users 10x more. We sit there, as developers, saying to ourselves, "wtf, why would they do that? It doesn't cost the company anything extra to run two lines of javascript...". On and on this goes until you reach the point that you stop developing entirely because your clients can't be squeezed for cash any more.
In some respects they're right. If you are a team lead, you could probably do most of what an MBA does. If you have finished an undergrad CS degree you can definitely finish Business School. It's just that this point completely neglects the fact that if you could do all the management tasks AND develop at the same time, your company probably wouldn't be paying a MBA an exorbitant amount of money to do the management work. Yeah a lot of times it seems like management just moves from pointless meeting to pointless meeting especially as an engineer sitting in on them, but that flow of information between stakeholders is incredibly important. It's absolutely inefficient, but unfortunately there's often not a better way. Like 90% of management responsibilities are just coordinating and communicating.
Now if you compare a Harvard or Wharton MBA to say a Stanford or MIT CS degree, then you'll probably find that the MBA outperforms by miles. But I think that's because those programs sell a deep network of rich and powerful people. Harvard MBA go off to run large companies, and Stanford PHDs go run research projects. I'm generalizing, but at the top end they're using very different optimization functions.
I met someone with a CS degree from Stanford who couldn't do a basic HTTP request in their main programming language (with access to Google / documentation), nor implement and reverse a linked list. These seem like really basic things that anyone with a CS degree should be able to do...
I think you should rephrase your statement to "even a shitty CS degree will convince companies that you are employable".
I guess my thesis is that if you can't go top 10, don't get an MBA unless you company pays for it.
It’s like saying you don’t know what 13 times 14 is off the top of your head so you aren’t good at maths.
Has it ever occurred to you guys that maybe some (many?) of these people were hackers prior to getting their MBA, and are very competent? Quite a few of my classmates had engineering (including software) backgrounds, and even the ones who had engineering degrees but didn't actually code were still clued in. Why this blanket dismissal of anyone with the degree?
This kind of generalization, "All X are bad/dumb/incompetent" would be shunned here and down voted to oblivion if X were "women", "men", "offshore developers", "no college degree", "interns", etc. But somehow "MBA" is totally OK. Bash away!
Because of this bizarre stigma in Silicon Valley (by the way, outside the valley, most companies consider it a plus), I tend to not even mention mine unless asked. When it comes up and I mention that I did the MBA thing a decade ago, I get reactions from my software colleagues ranging from "Wait, but you seem to know your shit!" to "Why would you do such a thing??" There are competent MBAs and there are shitty ones. Why can't this be acknowledged? Such a strange little quirk of our bubble out here...