However, if the intent is to work out traffic trends, it can be done much cleaner. For example, one can only track addresses within a single commute (it should not be difficult to guess from data). That is, use different hashes for the same MAC at different trips.
Also, IMO any general purpose data the government collects for the public benefit that it does not declare sensitive should be public. That is, quickly posted for public to see, use, check, etc. My 2c.
> At the end of 2016, TfL ran a pilot which tracked the Wi-Fi signals from 5.6 million phones as people moved around the London Underground, even if they weren't connected to a Wi-Fi network.
* in the image's case, those percentages would do it
Wow, I guess you guys in the UK are seriously desensitized to data invasions like that.
That might seem weird to an outsider but that's just a culture difference. We're just as weirded out that anyone can own even a handgun in the US, let alone walk down the street with one.
I'm personally far more weirded out by the idea that a private company can track and use this data than the fact the state can.
a) the pervasive surveillance (i don't think it's by chance that "black mirror" is written by someone - charlie brooker- living there)
b) the stupidly high housing costs
(in that order, actually)
It was 13 years ago that the UK's then information commissioner warned we were sleep-walking into a surveillance state: https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2004/aug/16/britishidentity.f...
The worries seem positively quaint now in comparison to the data that Facebook, Google and the state now collect.
The revenue was discussed as coming from targeted advertising implying tracking of data usage.
I'm skeptical for a different reason: all they're going to see is a bunch of connections to facebook servers which will all look alike. /s
That doesn't require and collection of data, and they have explicitly ruled out doing such collection.
I imagine they can also do differential pricing of adverts across more of the stations with a better idea of footfall (though simple point footfall figures can be got in simpler ways), and indeed that is apparently part of what they're doing.
TFL's intention to "dynamically trade advertising space" is far more interesting though. Once that's in place it doesn't matter if TFL track you or not - Facebook and Google will just repurpose their existing technology, making things a step closer to the advertising in minority report.
This will likely result in a strong pressure to reduce the friction of everyone using the wifi - expect the 'paywall' to drop.
Most large public WiFi deploys come with this capability already included (albeit normally with an additional license required), whether or not the owners of the system are aware of the capability / are utilising it. Punishing TFL with sensationalist journalism for being open about this application will only make such use in future more hidden and isn't constructive.