News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Case Study of “Designed By Developers:” Stack Overflow by scotty79 on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @12:41PM (#1535680)
Ouch.

I came to stackoverflow from search engine multiple times while searching for solutions to my problems. I was pleasantly surprised how fast I could find question that was asked and after confirming that the asker has similar problem to mine how fast I could browse through responses. Also I could get to know reservations other user had to responses (stated in comments to those responses). I shouldn't probably be surprised by my amazement because the thing that recurrently cropped up in my search result in old days was experts-exchange.

After multiple visits I finally got curious what is that site that helps me so often and I clicked link in the orange banner on the top that drew my attention. Up to this moment the only parts of the page that I've noticed were, questions, answers, comments and banner on the top.

After I registered and answered few questions I picked tags that interest me. They are visible on the right. Tags are for answerers not for askers. Tags visible to unregistered users are just cool unimportant bonus info similar to pageviews and they are placed in the bottom right when nobody even looks if he's not bored and exploring.

There are maybe some features that are not necessary, and some missing but what is important for me, no unnecessary feature ever got in my face while using this site.

As for the proposed redesign I think it's horrible.

You can barely see votes and up/downvote buttons that are very important for this site to work. If people can't find them and hit them less often more bad answers would be mixed with good ones.

User info is in prominent place and it is almost of no importance ~8k rep guy can give you bad answer. Votes on answer matter, not the rep of answerer. Also insane spacing around it immediately kills aesthetics of the whole design it might have possessed. I rarely see something that awful outside of works of beginner designers (and yes, also developers).

Putting main menu in the right top corner where are all the things that you don't usually care about until you want to search for something or log in is a bad idea. But I don't use this main menu all that much so probably it wouldn't hurt too much. ... Besides if you see input box in the top right corner what do you expect it to be? A spot where you can place your pizza order? Even if that box was empty as long as it looked as input box I'd have thought that this is serchbox and when I put some stuff there and hit enter site will be searched for occurrences of it.

Questions are just barely discernible from answers. Stackoverflow does this better but I'm not sure why. Maybe with spacing? Maybe by not discouraging you from reading it by putting it somewhere in the middle of gray background?

Only thing I think might be good in the redesign is exposing "Ask a Question". But I think SO does almost as good by surrounding this option with plenty of whitespace.

As a footnote:

Don't try to redesign how thing looks until you understand what it does.

"By developers for developers" sometimes works.

Re:A Case Study of “Designed By Developers:” Stack Overflow by ay on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @09:05PM (#1537035)
As soon as you reach some nominal reputation level, the "pesky ad" disappears completely. I do not ever remember seeing it except at the very start before I registered.

The site is deliberately not optimized for the one-time users - because they only consume and not produce. The site is optimized for the long-time users who form the community that is producing the content attracting the visitors.

I find it a very fair approach.

Re:A Case Study of “Designed By Developers:” Stack Overflow by samstokes on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @09:04PM (#1537031)
I almost stopped reading when I saw "by developers for developers" as a criticism, because he's talking about Stack Overflow, a website that is explicitly "for developers". Sure, that doesn't mean usability doesn't matter, or can't be improved, but it seems silly to start a diatribe like this without at least considering that maybe usability and aesthetics have different optima for developers than for a general audience.

(To be fair, he does discuss developers as a demographic somewhere in the middle of the laundry list of 20 or so "initial concerns", in the context of the prominence of the banner ad.)

Re:A Case Study of “Designed By Developers:” Stack Overflow by scotty79 on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @09:32PM (#1537086)
By developers for developers does not always work. In my opinion it mostly fails when it comes to IDEs (with some notable exceptions).