News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Programmers who want to change how we code before catastr... by wpietri on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @03:33PM (#15351460)
Motivation seems far from the only difference.

If we divide making into "builds with atoms" and "builds with bits", both sorts of things are generally unregulated. It's when you get into "builds life-critical things with atoms" that you see significant regulation. If you build a house or an office building, your engineering is regulated. If you build a doghouse or an office filing cabinet, it isn't.

I agree that societal accountability for engineers working on life-critical system, software and hardware both, is vital. For most atom-making and bit-making, though, I think stringent professional licensing is overkill. Instead I'd rather we started with accountability for the people who have much more control over the outcomes than individual software engineers: executives and managers.

Re:Programmers who want to change how we code before catastr... by IncRnd on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @03:53PM (#15351650)
> If you build a house or an office building, your engineering is regulated. If you build a doghouse or an office filing cabinet, it isn't.

A filing cabinet must be fit for the purpose it is used, or there will be liability incurred. OSHA would frown on keeping hazardous chemicals in your filing cabinet. Software should also be fit for the purpose it is marketed and used.

There are many kinds of paper, but paper being used improperly, by storing a list of credit card numbers on it, is quite similar to how many pieces of software are written.