News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Heathcare.gov to Go Down for Maintenance in Middle of Oba... by untog on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @08:10AM (#15346947)
It's a valid complaint. The site's technical issues have been fixed for a long time. As the article says:

given the administration’s previous efforts to sabotage the insurance markets, it’s not paranoid to view this maintenance schedule as a plan to keep down enrollment

We're all technical folks here. What possible reason could there be to close the site every Sunday morning for 12 hours? In what situation would that ever be the best answer for users?

Re:Heathcare.gov to Go Down for Maintenance in Middle of Oba... by victorqhong on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @09:50AM (#15347766)
> We're all technical folks here. What possible reason could there be to close the site every Sunday morning for 12 hours?

Sometimes the reason isn't always purely technical. Especially in the government, there could be bureaucratic reasons that cause really un-intuitive behavior that's pretty much unheard of in the commercial world.

They could be exercising migrating to their COOP site and when asked "how long does it take for the site to FULLY come up?" the contractor said 12 hours to be on the safe side. If you account for things like acceptance testing done by government employees, 12 hours is unfortunate but not unreasonable for the government.

Re:Heathcare.gov to Go Down for Maintenance in Middle of Oba... by untog on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @01:53PM (#15350432)
They're doing this exercise every week until December? And why not take those twelve hours in the middle of the night on a weekday? It doesn't add up.
Re:Heathcare.gov to Go Down for Maintenance in Middle of Oba... by MichaelBurge on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @08:25AM (#15347036)
> We're all technical folks here. What possible reason could there be to close the site every Sunday morning for 12 hours? In what situation would that ever be the best answer for users?

Database compaction?

Re:Heathcare.gov to Go Down for Maintenance in Middle of Oba... by drodgers on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @08:53AM (#15347254)
What? No. You just bring-up a replica, compact that (or do any other slow operation you want), wait for it to catch-up, then fail-over, making the replica the new master.

There's no excuse for doing slow, blocking maintenance operations on a live user-facing database.

Re:Heathcare.gov to Go Down for Maintenance in Middle of Oba... by chimeracoder on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @09:08AM (#15347383)
> There's no excuse for doing slow, blocking maintenance operations on a live user-facing database.

You can't judge a government system against the best-of-class standards of the private sector (note that I did not say the typical standards, just the top-of-line).

Government systems are rarely built or staffed by the top talent, often outsourced to lowest-bid contractors, and may not even have people on call for issues. It's not unusual for government sites to be scheduled to function only during standard business hours.

So yeah, it sucks that this site is going to be down during some of the least likely times for people to use it (midnight to noon on Sunday), but that's not at all unusual for government sites.

Re:Heathcare.gov to Go Down for Maintenance in Middle of Oba... by dbbk on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @09:25AM (#15347544)
> Government systems are rarely built or staffed by the top talent, often outsourced to lowest-bid contractors, and may not even have people on call for issues. It's not unusual for government sites to be scheduled to function only during standard business hours.

Except that's not what happened, the Obama administration set up The US Digital Service to fix Healthcare.gov and specifically staffed it with top talent.

https://www.usds.gov/

Re:Heathcare.gov to Go Down for Maintenance in Middle of Oba... by throwaway5752 on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @09:33AM (#15347606)
Can I just make a guess that you don't know anything about the Healthcare.gov infrastructure? It was extremely widely reported at the time how the Obama administration fired the first contractor (CGI Federal) for lack of quality, and how a number of people from the private sector came in to design it (sometimes at far below market rates).

Anyway, you're are making general platitudes about "government systems" without regard for the level, department, or any other factor that would influence the quality. And you think, "not unusual for government sites to be scheduled to function only during standard business hours". It would be a genuine shock to anyone knowledgeable about these sort of things if this were truly technically necessary.

Re:Heathcare.gov to Go Down for Maintenance in Middle of Oba... by chimeracoder on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @09:54AM (#15347795)
> Can I just make a guess that you don't know anything about the Healthcare.gov infrastructure?

You can, but you couldn't be further from the truth.

> Anyway, you're are making general platitudes about "government systems" without regard for the level, department, or any other factor that would influence the quality.

I guess, but that's not really relevant to my point, which is to refute the statement "There's no excuse for doing slow, blocking maintenance operations on a live user-facing database.". There is an excuse in government systems for this. You may not like it, and you may think it's an excuse that they should avoid, but that's one reason, and these sorts of issues are pretty common in government systems.

You're correct that healthcare.gov is actually one of the better-functioning sites in that regard, but even if some aspects of it mitigate the shortcomings, that doesn't mean it's not subject to some of the other same limitations.

> It would be a genuine shock to anyone knowledgeable about these sort of things if this were truly technically necessary.

I'm emphasizing that what people on HN think of as "necessary" is different from what the government thinks of as "necessary". The example that I gave was that, if you don't have anyone on-call after hours (which is incredibly common), it makes sense to keep an important system offline during those hours, rather than risk a silent failure.

Re:Heathcare.gov to Go Down for Maintenance in Middle of Oba... by throwaway5752 on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @10:05PM (#15354009)
Eh, not to metacomment but I upvoted you. I don't know why you were downvoted. What about the healthcare.gov website do you know that would require this sort of downtime window, when it didn't require it in prior years?

When I say knowledgeable about these things, I mean these contracted, designed-to-spec, CMMI level 5 projects. Even one of those would be unlikely to require this sort of maintenance. Again, open to correct if you can offer specifics.

Re:Heathcare.gov to Go Down for Maintenance in Middle of Oba... by nerdponx on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @09:32AM (#15347602)
Then do it on Tuesday night, not Sunday morning. Do it before the open enrollment period starts.

Quit lying to yourself and get some ethical standards.