IMO what's rubbing people the wrong way is not his specific points but how he is framing them. It really does not matter how brilliant his alternative is ... it's clear that HTTP is firmly entrenched and the network effects run so deep, it would require a miracle to really "start fresh". I'd really like to be proven wrong though.
On the other hand, would we have cell phones, ubiquitous credit card-capable point of sale machines, and airplanes with in-flight Internet, if people hadn't dared to dream that things could be better?
Yes, children can learn basic HTML, CSS, and JavaScript. But what if we had a platform that was easy to learn and not full of security pitfalls? One can dream. And the OP has some concrete suggestions for how to get there.
And sometimes, you have to drop existing systems, or aspects of them, to get to that better future. For example, on a cell phone, you don't actually get a dial tone and send DTMF in real time, as one did on a touch-tone landline phone. (This reminds me of jacquesm's contrast of DTMF and GSM [2], posted in the comment thread for part 1.)
It's just hard for me to understand how realistically a clean room implementation of NewWeb is gonna beat out something that's already had billions poured into it and even today is progressing. The much easier step is figuring out how to make the web better, but it isn't sexy. No matter what you come up with is gonna be imperfect and criticized and have holdouts anyway.
I don't think "why isn't what we have good enough" has ever been the mantra of pioneers in their field, but ok
I don't get why you seem to take such exception to the stance that "we can do better". We can always do better.
Do you imagine 500 years from now the same technologies and web models in play as today? Even 100 years from now? Do you really think they are the pinnacle of the web.
If you really do, I'd sincerely love to read your counter blog post on this, as I reflect on this quite a bit and have generally always come to the conclusion that there's a long way to go.
> This is like sitting there in 1600 and saying that the printing press sucks because it doesn't encrypt documents
If that's so, isn't your comment akin to saying "why isn't the printing press good enough for you"? :)
Just about every feature you list (apart from the distribution, got to give the web that) is stuff that we could do 20 years ago, so yes, I'm ungrateful that we've traveled so far but still gone no where, backwards in many ways.
> Children can learn HTML and CSS, modern web frameworks make it so that you can build great stuff on the back or frontend in a matter of days or weeks
Kids were doing that with basic since the 70's or 80's.
https://www.heropunch.io/roadmap.html#finally-relax
site still has a few bugs (it isn't officially "out" yet, but its topical so why not).
the sandbox VM is a docker container with a standard interface for storage (relax/vfs), display (wayland), messaging (relax/pub).
vfs supports torrents and partial replication, so you're pretty much always streaming. we try to cache things to keep it fast, but different systems have different storage limits so we have to assume that we're always going to be fetching from the network.
applications can actually consist of multiple docker containers with different capabilities that can be scheduled on any host that has been paired with your user key. these can be updated individually or in tandem.
docker registries have to be explicitly trusted before you can run anything. we realize that docker isn't a security boundary by default, but we are attacking that problem from a few angles.
we implement a lot of this functionality as docker engine plugins. so you get anon overlay routing and distributed storage transparently from the perspective of the application.
You can reach 2 billion people for pennies. What's more, this stuff isn't hard. Children can learn HTML and CSS, modern web frameworks make it so that you can build great stuff on the back or frontend in a matter of days or weeks. Seriously, write a small Sinatra or Flask app. It's easy.
Why is that not good enough? We really so ungrateful to believe that reinventing everything is the right step now? Nothing is stopping anyone from taking existing tech and building great, usable, lightweight sites. Seems like focusing on that would be about a billion times more productive, yeah? You can't really expect to throw away 30 years of ongoing progress and build a better experience in months or even years without losing something.
Just seems like a bunch of fluff. He'll never build anything like it. This is like sitting there in 1600 and saying that the printing press sucks because it doesn't encrypt documents. You've got so much potential that remains unharnessed (low-hanging fruit even), and we'd rather build a new system.