News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Dying Art of Disagreement by rayiner on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @12:04AM (#15336048)
I’m not sure how you’re supposed to respectfully disagree about someone like Kissenger who got hundreds of thousands of people killed through his ideas.
Re:The Dying Art of Disagreement by gizmo686 on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @12:08AM (#15336076)
You can start by saying what ideas of his you think are wrong, and why they are wrong. Then you can listen to why he (or those he agrees with) believe those ideas are right.
Re:The Dying Art of Disagreement by rayiner on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @12:15AM (#15336105)
If I think your ideas are morally wrong and getting people killed, I am compelled to either try and stop you, or resign myself to cowardly inaction. I of course choose cowardly inaction—I’m selfish and enjoy the comfort of my life and don’t want to disturb it. But I don’t try to make that out to be a virtue!
Re:The Dying Art of Disagreement by gizmo686 on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @12:31AM (#15336185)
Why do you think his ideas are morally wrong. In my experience, almost every disagreement that is perceived to be moral is actual factual. That is to say, we have a disagreement on what the consequences of certain actions will be. These disagreements could be deeply rooted in ideology (as in, what is the consequences of wealth inequality), but are factual, nor moral.

Further, by not engaging, you miss the opportunity to present why you think his ideas are wrong. If people hear both sides, they can make an informed choice. If they hear neither side, they can only make an uninformed choice. If you think this arrangement benefits you, I would question how confident you are in your beliefs.

Re:The Dying Art of Disagreement by ericd on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @12:23AM (#15336142)
The way to stop people like him without killing the foundation of our democracy is to explain rationally why his ideas are terrible and why no one should listen to them, not to prevent him from speaking at all. No one is suggesting that you do nothing.
Re:The Dying Art of Disagreement by rayiner on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @12:30AM (#15336182)
Debating ideas is one thing. Thoughts are thoughts. Inviting architects of mass death to speak at your university is another thing. Thinkers and speakers get to pull the academic debate card. You should be able to say whatever the heck you want. But once you’ve got blood on your hands you’ve gotta be judged your actions, not on your ideas.
Re:The Dying Art of Disagreement by gizmo686 on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @12:39AM (#15336222)
So unless their ideas end up working perfectly in practice, we should close our ears to anyone who has practical experience?
Re:The Dying Art of Disagreement by tptacek on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @09:50AM (#15338577)
That's a weird and ugly dichotomy, between organizing and ordering the mass killing of thousands of innocent children, and "working perfectly in practice". How many children before it stops being an oopsie-daisy?
Re:The Dying Art of Disagreement by gtf21 on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @07:20AM (#15337695)
Yes but in the long run, unless you are to be crowned the ultimate arbiter of what ideas are correct, the only effective way to do this is to persuade people (sometimes including the aforementioned immoral actor) that these actions are wrong. The alternative is constant policing of every action, instead of trying to shape the way decisions are made.
Re:The Dying Art of Disagreement by Turing_Machine on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @12:10AM (#15336081)
Karl Marx's ideas have been responsible for the deaths of about 100 million people (and counting), yet they still seem to be granted plenty of airtime at our universities.
Re:The Dying Art of Disagreement by dahart on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @01:12AM (#15336364)
> Karl Marx's ideas have been responsible for the deaths of about 100 million people (and counting), yet they still seem to be granted plenty of airtime at our universities.

Karl Marx's economic ideas are part of history. Isn't airtime at universities based on what has influenced people and shaped the world, whether good or bad? Learning what went wrong in history is a feature, not a bug. Hitler gets plenty of airtime too, and unlike Marx, he was actually and directly responsible for millions of deaths.

"The countries associated with some Marxist nations have led political opponents to blame Marx for millions of deaths,[259] but the fidelity of these varied revolutionaries, leaders and parties to Marx's work is highly contested and rejected by many Marxists.[260] It is now common to distinguish between the legacy and influence of Marx specifically and the legacy and influence of those who shaped his ideas for political purposes.[261]"

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karl_Marx#Legacy

Re:The Dying Art of Disagreement by matt4077 on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @12:28AM (#15336169)
Marx wrote books, and he died in 1883. The split between Marxists/Trotskyists/Stalinists is well-documented, and reading Das Kapital, you'll see it takes as much of a twisted mind to go from his ideas to Stalin as it takes to get from the bible to the Westboro Baptist Church.

Kissinger was an active politician, and he's criticised not so much for his ideas as his actions. I seem to remember that quite a few people during the Charlottesville brouhaha were keen to insist that people should be judged by their actions.

There's also a difference between a study of Marx/Kissinger, and attending an event that has them as guests. A famous speaker's attendance is an honour for the host, but it also honours the speaker. I'm sure there are scores of left-leaning researchers and students who have read Kissinger's work or studied his actions while being highly critical of him.

The obvious example is that it's just as common to read Hitler's book and speeches as it is to read Marx when studying history.

Re:The Dying Art of Disagreement by Turing_Machine on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @12:02AM (#15344827)
> The obvious example is that it's just as common to read Hitler's book and speeches as it is to read Marx when studying history.

I'm sorry, that is not "obvious" at all. It's trivial to name dozens of academics who are self-admitted Marxists, and who give Marxist ideas fulsome praise in the classroom. They outnumber self-admitted Nazi academics by thousands to one, at a minimum (I can't think of even one example of the latter, off-hand, but I suppose there might be one or two out there).

Re:The Dying Art of Disagreement by rayiner on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @12:12AM (#15336094)
There is a difference between ideas and people who put those ideas into practice. Marx was just a writer. Lenin or Stalin—I don’t think you can respectfully disagree about them.
Re:The Dying Art of Disagreement by Turing_Machine on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @12:19AM (#15336123)
Mahmoud Ahmadinejad (whose government routinely murdered gay people, among other nasty behaviors) gave a speech at Columbia University. While the speech was (rightly) protested, he was not shouted down, nor was he forced to flee from a violent mob.
Re:The Dying Art of Disagreement by tptacek on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @09:51AM (#15338588)
Ok, so let's simply stipulate that whatever adversity Kissinger faces, so too should Ahmadinejad, who is also loathsome.
Re:The Dying Art of Disagreement by crispinb on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @12:16AM (#15336111)
Kissinger's a monster in my opinion. But everyone's monster threshold is different. Refusing to engage based on monsterhood is a road to a war of all against all. We're walking that road now. That's a far worse outcome than the odd monster slipping onto lecture stages.